[Tainted Blood]

Please. Gaga can't dance and writing and producing are IRRELEVANT when it comes to be a performer. Also Beyonce sing better. You tried.

[alkralkra]

Is this still going?

[Mélina]

Originally posted by alkralkra

Is this still going?

!!!

[787dreamliner]

Yes , I prefer GaGa. Bey's skill doesn't develop much from 2003.

[And Now I Wonder]

I voted Kelly. Because of this perfection.

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by And Now I Wonder

I voted Kelly. Because of this perfection.

The QUEEN better SLAY that walk across the stage!

[Barbarella]

Originally posted by JakeHouser

Yes... LADY GAGA >>> Anyone else that performs.

Originally posted by KevinKDC

When was beyonce ever the performer of any kind of generation ???????

Originally posted by man*****

The world says Gaga. Bey you is kind, you is special too!

Originally posted by jomarr

Beyonce was so last generation and she failed the be THE performer

Originally posted by givemethatpop

Beyoncé's performing skills are boring and repetitive. Once you've seen one of her performances, you've seen them all.

Originally posted by TheVoiceXtina

Of Course

[B2R4D]

No. Beyonce is "irreplaceable" and she will be one of the greats. Gaga may have the performance skill and talent, but people will never fully take her seriously at all.

[givemethatpop]

Originally posted by B2R4D

No. Beyonce is "irreplaceable" and she will be one of the greats. Gaga may have the performance skill and talent, but people will never fully take her seriously at all.

Stop acting like Beyoncé's not seen as a manufactured, generic star just like any of our faves

[Keira]

I had to vote for Beyonce she is a great performer, even though I don't like her music.

[MelovesBey]

Didn't Gaga copy Madonna? So how can she be the performer of this generation? I like gaga but let's be real!!!!


Apples and Oranges...

[givemethatpop]

Originally posted by MelovesBey

Didn't Gaga copy Madonna? So how can she be the performer of this generation? I like gaga but let's be real!!!!

The best post in this ****ing thread.

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

An artist needs to make art when she performs ==> GaGa

[.aR]

Have ya'll forgot about how Beyonce actually performs??

She doesn't need all the lights, props, gimmicks, theatrics......meat dress

[givemethatpop]

Originally posted by .aR

Have ya'll forgot about how Beyonce actually performs??

She doesn't need all the lights, props, gimmicks, theatrics......meat dress

But you know lights, gimmicks and theatrics are part of a performance as well, no?

[B2R4D]

Originally posted by givemethatpop

Stop acting like Beyoncé's not seen as a manufactured, generic star just like any of our faves

Look.. I don't stan for either of these girls, so my head is obviously out of delusional stan-land. It's fair to say that I'm taking a truthful and non-bias approach to the question. I said what I felt.. My statement was not wrong, but it wasn't right either. That's why it's called an opinion.

[.aR]

Originally posted by givemethatpop

But you know lights, gimmicks and theatrics are part of a performance as well, no?

Performance yes, but this question is about the PERFORMER, the ENTERTAINER. Not who has the better gimmicks.....

[givemethatpop]

Originally posted by .aR

Performance yes, but this question is about the PERFORMER, the ENTERTAINER. Not who has the better gimmicks.....

The best performer is the one who makes the best performances.

Florence doesn't dance but her performances **** on most of ATRL faves', only using lights, theatrics, back-up dancers...

[MrPeanut]

No.

[itsJAMESbitch]

Originally posted by givemethatpop

The best performer is the one who makes the best performances.

Florence doesn't dance but her performances **** on most of ATRL faves', only using lights, theatrics, back-up dancers...

how do you not get this simple concept? that doesn't make the person who is PERFORMING better at PERFORMING. you just prefer the theatricality of the whole performance more. thats all.