[Rhisiart]

I'm going to try and do this, I'm interested in this a lot. I have Dangerous Woman scores ready from the Ariana Discog Rate, but I'll definitely be editing those once I'm able to compare with the other 3 albums.

I tried listening to Confident a few days ago, but I only managed to get halfway before I needed to stop. I'm going to try again now, maybe I'll be in a better mood.

[ultraviolenttrash]

I'll do this. Haven't listened to Confident and Thank You yet. I like DW and Revival tho.

[Rhisiart]

Demi's cackle in the middle of Mr. Hughes.

Second time around, and I like Confident better. The back-half of the album is definitely better than the front-half. I liked the ballads a lot, which I'm surprised about since I don't like Stone Cold at all.

Halfway done! I think I'll save Meghan for last...

[Dom]

Selena's album is so good, damn.

[Dom]

Champagne Problems is a bop.

[Dom]

Averages:

Selena Gomez - Revival 6.7 (10x4, 1x1)

Ariana Grande - Dangerous Woman 6.5 (11, 10x3, 1x1)

Demi Lovato - Confident 5.5 (10x2 , 1x1, 0x1)

Meghan Trainor - Thank You 5.3 (10x2 , 1x2)

[Rhisiart]

Almost done! Revival was very good and consistent, I didn't expect to like it that much. Now I just need to listen to Thank You.

[Rihlana]

I should have waited a little longer to send my rates

I'm seeing the light for some songs, and the light is dying for some others.

[Elysium]

Originally posted by ultraviolenttrash

I'll do this. Haven't listened to Confident and Thank You yet. I like DW and Revival tho.

That's all you end up liking from this rate.

Dangerous Woman: 8.09
High - 11/Low - 4
Revival: 6.30
High - 10/Low - 1.5
Confident: 3.64
High - 10/Low - 1
Thank You: 3.13
High - 7/Low - 0

Ariana & Selena's releases are the best of their careers and deserve to sweep this rate. Demi's is a mess but Cool For The Summer deserves top 20.

Meghan

Thank You is one of the worst albums I've ever heard.

[Save The Day]

I'm here for the Stars lashings. I can bop to some songs on Confident but Stars is just an insult to my ears

[Rihlana]

Is Thank You REALLY the worst album you've listened to? THE ACTUAL PINNACLE OF TERRIBLE ALBUMS?
Is there legitimately nothing worse?

For me, it was my 3rd favourite album IN THIS RATE, I think.

[Elysium]

Originally posted by Rihlana

Is Thank You REALLY the worst album you've listened to? THE ACTUAL PINNACLE OF TERRIBLE ALBUMS?
Is there legitimately nothing worse?

For me, it was my 3rd favourite album IN THIS RATE, I think.

Well, no because I said it was one of the worst I've listened to, not THE worst one ever.

Eh, I've never really liked Meghan's sound ever since she debuted and Thank You is consistent in that. Champagne Problems is pretty good though.

[Rihlana]

Originally posted by Elysium

Well, no because I said it was one of the worst I've listened to, not THE worst one ever.

Eh, I've never really liked Meghan's sound ever since she debuted and Thank You is consistent in that. Champagne Problems is pretty good though.

Sorry if this looked aimed at you specifically, but I've just seen a lot of people say that it is the worst album that they've ever heard! But everybody is entitled to their own opinion!

Champagne Problems is a bopT

[Elysium]

Originally posted by Rihlana

Sorry if this looked aimed at you specifically, but I've just seen a lot of people say that it is the worst album that they've ever heard! But everybody is entitled to their own opinion!

Champagne Problems is a bopT

No worries at all!

I wonder if all 4 artists will crack the top 10? I mean, my scores for Thank You & Confident will probably help stop that but what do y'all think?

[Ditayoncé]

Originally posted by Rihlana

Is Thank You REALLY the worst album you've listened to? THE ACTUAL PINNACLE OF TERRIBLE ALBUMS?
Is there legitimately nothing worse?

For me, it was my 3rd favourite album IN THIS RATE, I think.

Well yeah it was THE worst album i've ever listened to. Even ARTPOP was better
Me too deserves top 10 though

[Rihlana]

Originally posted by Elysium

No worries at all!

I wonder if all 4 artists will crack the top 10? I mean, my scores for Thank You & Confident will probably help stop that but what do y'all think?

HAHAHAHA, that gif

I think they probably can! With Demi and Meghan, I think it'll definitely be their singles, but for Ariana, I think some album tracks may even find their way right up there. Selena is somewhat of an anomaly. For me, it was my least favourite album in the rate, but so many people love it, so maybe a few album tracks will get up there as well! But of course, I could be totally wrong. We'll have to wait and see

Originally posted by Ditayoncé

Well yeah it was THE worst album i've ever listened to. Even ARTPOP was better
Me too deserves top 10 though

WOW! Poor you for having to go through that then!
Yeah, Me Too is a great song.

[Agnes Ng]

i am going to do this... just finish confident and dangerous women again. Only need to go through Thank you but the comments you all made had make me very scared. Is the album that bad? I think No and Me too is fine....

Maybe i should wait for the weekend to do it zzz.

[AbeHicks]

Originally posted by Agnes Ng

i am going to do this... just finish confident and dangerous women again. Only need to go through Thank you but the comments you all made had make me very scared. Is the album that bad? I think No and Me too is fine....

Maybe i should wait for the weekend to do it zzz.

Nah, it's fine it's just not the type of music ATRL users enjoy.
Hopeless Romanitc & Just A Friend To You are great songs.

[Black Umbrella]

I felt bad because I thought the deadline was over, I'm gonna send my rate later today, I love all four albums

[Fenrir]

Sent. First time listening through Thank You and....well, I wasn't really impressed...



Dangerous Woman
Average: 6.94
Highest: 11
Lowest: 1

Revival
Average: 5.56
Highest: 10
Lowest: 1

Confident
Average: 4.85
Highest: 8
Lowest: 2

Thank You
Average: 3.47
Highest: 7
Lowest: 0