[FBF]

Originally posted by Floyd Mayweather

I never doubted her consistency with getting hits but where are those songs gonna be next year?

There's no denying some Rih songs faded, like What's my name for example, but there's no denying either she has some classics, WFL, or Umbrella for instance

As far as singles goes, she really has the strongest discography since Britney (Gaga if she didn't flop too early would've been considered too)

[Green]

Originally posted by TSLGNMA

Sales and charts: WFL
Impact: Single Ladies

I agree

[Floyd Mayweather]

Originally posted by itsnickcray

We found love.

Single ladies is extremely dated. That's why she isnt even performing the song on her Formation tour.

Nah, Bey just doesn't rely on hits to sell out her tours

[Erreur2 La Nature]

I think We Found Love has been way bigger than Single Lady in terms of impact. I don't know what the sales were.

[Ryann]

We Found Love is the only correct answer although Single Ladies had more cultural impact.

[Floyd Mayweather]

Originally posted by FBF

There's no denying some Rih songs faded, like What's my name for example, but there's no denying either she has some classics, WFL, or Umbrella for instance

As far as singles goes, she really has the strongest discography since Britney (Gaga if she didn't flop too early would've been considered too)

I agree with Umbrella but not with We Found Love


Yeah I don't agree with the second half at all

[*-ChriZ-*]

Originally posted by Notorious K.E.N

Its true though. Rihanna's disco is timeless and the GP still uses. The only time i heard a Beyonce song played this entire decade has been drunk in love after the grammys. I havent even heard Single Ladies since it was popular

I dont know where you guys are living, but Ive never left any club without listening to at least 1 Bey song a day, usually even more.

Most frequent club bangers are:

Crazy in Love -> always!
Single Ladies ; sometimes as a remix -> most of the time
7/11
Drunk In Love (sometimes as a remix)

[Notorious K.E.N]

Originally posted by *-ChriZ-*

I dont know where you guys are living, but Ive never left any club without listening to at least 1 Bey song a day, usually even more.

Most frequent club bangers are:

Crazy in Love -> always!
Single Ladies ; sometimes as a remix -> most of the time
7/11
Drunk In Love (sometimes as a remix)

The US and im sure Rihanna is doing much much better WW

[Nemo]

Originally posted by Doogle

We Found Love was obviously the bigger hit in the sense of it sold more (I think so idk receipts), did better on charts and was always on radio

But Single Ladies genuinely has impact that very few songs can match, it's well known thanks to the dance and how quotable it is

Doogle spilling the tea as usual. love ya

[***Chu]

Single Ladies.

[Eternium]

Originally posted by White_King

WFL by really far
No one does the SL dance anymore

The dance is literally called Mexican Breakfast and is featured in the 220M+ viewed lyric video for Sia's Cheap Thrills which will end up being a bigger hit than anything Bey/Rih have had in years.

You can argue that it's a tribute to Bob Fosse, but you can't possibly argue that it's forgotten.

[materialboy]

Single Ladies

[alkralkra]

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

[cherrychapstick]

We Found Love is bigger than Single Ladies although the latter is more of a cultural force. On iTunes (http://kworb.net/ww/wwtotals.html) and YouTube (http://kworb.net/youtube/topvideos.html), WFL performs better than SL.

[Tutankhamun]

People here acting like WFL was a big hit with no impact.
It was the first EDM hit song with this chill/melancholic vibe that's still dominating global charts in 2016.
WFL had way more impact than SL as far as the MUSIC goes.

But to answer the OP, Single Ladies was definitely the bigger hit among the GP

[taylor__fan]

WFL and is not even close

SL success and impact is overrated

[-ToxicGuy-]

We Found Love and it's not even close

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Bringing EDM into mainstream Pop isn't impact?
I Knew You Were Trouble, Into You, etc isn't impact?
Launching the now biggest DJ's career isn't impact?

We Found Love by a LARGE margin.

[White_King]

Originally posted by Eternium

The dance is literally called Mexican Breakfast and is featured in the 220M+ viewed lyric video for Sia's Cheap Thrills which will end up being a bigger hit than anything Bey/Rih have had in years.

You can argue that it's a tribute to Bob Fosse, but you can't possibly argue that it's forgotten.

I know it's not an original dance, i meant no one does 'the single ladies' dance anymore. That was a fad that is forgotten

[DoubleDutchess]

Originally posted by Glassmouth

Single Ladies truly impacted pop culture, We Found Love was just another #1. Sorry.