Discussion: Bigger Hits: Britney vs Beyoncé vs Xtina vs Avril vs Pink - Page 13

PULSE.

Quote:

Originally posted by Concrete

And how does that change the fact that most of those are iconic and in the case of a couple, had undeniable cultural impact

Iconic to who? Surely not the world since they don't purchase or request any of those "iconic hits"

♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚

Bey = Britney > Pink >> Avril = Legend X.

Lucyyyyyyyyy

Britney > Beyonce > Xtina = Pink > Avril

Pedro

Quote:

Originally posted by PULSE.

Recent Airplay

BRITNEY SPEARS Everytime: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Baby, One More Time: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Oops...I Did It Again: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS (You Drive Me) Crazy: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS I'm A Slave 4 U: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Lucky: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Gimme More: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Sometimes: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Piece Of Me: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Break The Ice: 0

It's funny because you think iTunes numbers or radio airplay proves anything.

I guess Michael Jackson hasn't iconic songs either then

PULSE.

Quote:

Originally posted by Pedro

It's funny because you think iTunes numbers or radio airplay proves anything.

I guess Michael Jackson hasn't iconic songs either then

..Baby One More Time
#60 Cayman Islands

Sometimes
not charting

(You Drive Me) Crazy
Not charting

Oops! I Dit it Again
#350 Brunei Darussalam

Toxic
#290 Dominica
#348 Vietnam

Everytime
#44 Bahrain

Gimme More
not charting

Piece of Me
#343 Sweden
#368 Finland
================================================== ==========

Billie Jean
#22 Papua New Guinea
#51 Niger
#83 Bermuda
#179 United Arab Emirates
#205 Saudi Arabia
#211 Namibia
#253 Kyrgyzstan
#255 Singapore
#257 Lithuania
#266 Spain
#274 Mongolia
#353 Oman
#359 Burkina Faso
#383 Lebanon
#390 Israel

Beat It
#73 United Arab Emirates
#215 Saudi Arabia
#239 Singapore
#273 Mongolia
#333 Norway
#340 Cambodia
#389 Slovakia

Thriller
#198 Saudi Arabia
#261 Lebanon
#263 Spain
#287 Dominica

He is ALSO charting higher and in more places than Britney's so called "iconic hits" with music that's over 30 yrs old. NOTE* the album, Thriller sold over 80M copies worldwide (the best-selling album ever) and yet people are still buying the hits.

ItsJustMe.

Quote:

Originally posted by PULSE.

Recent Airplay

BRITNEY SPEARS Everytime: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Baby, One More Time: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Oops...I Did It Again: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS (You Drive Me) Crazy: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS I'm A Slave 4 U: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Lucky: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Gimme More: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Sometimes: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Piece Of Me: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Break The Ice: 0

they don't even get played and yet people still know those songs! britney's impact really is undeniable

Pedro

Quote:

Originally posted by PULSE.

..Baby One More Time
#60 Cayman Islands

Sometimes
not charting

(You Drive Me) Crazy
Not charting

Oops! I Dit it Again
#350 Brunei Darussalam

Toxic
#290 Dominica
#348 Vietnam

Everytime
#44 Bahrain

Gimme More
not charting

Piece of Me
#343 Sweden
#368 Finland
================================================== ==========

Billie Jean
#22 Papua New Guinea
#51 Niger
#83 Bermuda
#179 United Arab Emirates
#205 Saudi Arabia
#211 Namibia
#253 Kyrgyzstan
#255 Singapore
#257 Lithuania
#266 Spain
#274 Mongolia
#353 Oman
#359 Burkina Faso
#383 Lebanon
#390 Israel

Beat It
#73 United Arab Emirates
#215 Saudi Arabia
#239 Singapore
#273 Mongolia
#333 Norway
#340 Cambodia
#389 Slovakia

Thriller
#198 Saudi Arabia
#261 Lebanon
#263 Spain
#287 Dominica

He is ALSO charting higher and in more places than Britney's so called "iconic hits" with music that's over 30 yrs old. NOTE* the album, Thriller sold over 80M copies worldwide (the best-selling album ever) and yet people are still buying the hits.

Goodness! Such relevant iTunes countries! You really need to let your bias go away babe

PULSE.

Quote:

Originally posted by ItsJustMe.

they don't even get played and yet people still know those songs! britney's impact really is undeniable

The short-live impact that seems only her stans care about.

PULSE.

Quote:

Originally posted by Pedro

Goodness! Such relevant iTunes countries! You really need to let your bias go away babe

No, you need to let it go, darling.

Nippy'sReceipts

Quote:

Originally posted by Swag

Beyonce is the kind of artist that doesn't need 10,000 hits to be huge.

to answer britney > beyonce > pink > xtina >>>>>>>>>>>>avril

Agree

ItsJustMe.

Quote:

Originally posted by PULSE.

The short-live impact that only seems her stans career about.

if that makes you feel better then you should think that.

abrahamjmr

Quote:

Originally posted by PULSE.

..Baby One More Time
#60 Cayman Islands

Sometimes
not charting

(You Drive Me) Crazy
Not charting

Oops! I Dit it Again
#350 Brunei Darussalam

Toxic
#290 Dominica
#348 Vietnam

Everytime
#44 Bahrain

Gimme More
not charting

Piece of Me
#343 Sweden
#368 Finland
================================================== ==========

Billie Jean
#22 Papua New Guinea
#51 Niger
#83 Bermuda
#179 United Arab Emirates
#205 Saudi Arabia
#211 Namibia
#253 Kyrgyzstan
#255 Singapore
#257 Lithuania
#266 Spain
#274 Mongolia
#353 Oman
#359 Burkina Faso
#383 Lebanon
#390 Israel

Beat It
#73 United Arab Emirates
#215 Saudi Arabia
#239 Singapore
#273 Mongolia
#333 Norway
#340 Cambodia
#389 Slovakia

Thriller
#198 Saudi Arabia
#261 Lebanon
#263 Spain
#287 Dominica

He is ALSO charting higher and in more places than Britney's so called "iconic hits" with music that's over 30 yrs old. NOTE* the album, Thriller sold over 80M copies worldwide (the best-selling album ever) and yet people are still buying the hits.

And all of those countries together don't even make a thousand copies at best. Keep trying.

Timber

Quote:

Originally posted by ItsJustMe.

they don't even get played and yet people still know those songs! britney's impact really is undeniable

I only knew 3 songs of hers when I joined atrl.

ItsJustMe.

Quote:

Originally posted by Timber

I only knew 3 songs of hers when I joined atrl.

so you're either 2 years old or you lived under a rock. poor you tbh

alestevens

Quote:

Originally posted by PULSE.

Recent Airplay

BRITNEY SPEARS Everytime: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Baby, One More Time: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Oops...I Did It Again: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS (You Drive Me) Crazy: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS I'm A Slave 4 U: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Lucky: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Gimme More: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Sometimes: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Piece Of Me: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Break The Ice: 0

Let me assume you took this from the "Pop girls recurrent airplay" thread, since it has that same exact list in that same exact order.

Recurrent airplay / VEVO views

BEYONCE Crazy In Love: 2.197
BEYONCE Irreplaceable: 1.542
BEYONCE Halo: 1.518
BEYONCE Single Ladies (Put A Ring...): 1.246
BEYONCE Love On Top: 1.099
BEYONCE Baby Boy f/Sean Paul: 0.312
BEYONCE Me, Myself, And I: 0.310
BEYONCE F/JAY-Z Deja Vu: 0.191
BEYONCE Best Thing I Never Had: 0.150
BEYONCE Naughty Girl: 0.091
BEYONCE Get Me Bodied: 0.079
BEYONCE Upgrade U f/Jay-Z: 0.060
BEYONCE Dance For You: 0.049
BEYONCE Diva: 0.037
BEYONCE Dangerously In Love 2: 0.020
BEYONCE Ego: 0.019
BEYONCE If I Were A Boy: 0.014
BEYONCE Check On It f/Slim Thug: 0.010
BEYONCE Beautiful Liar f/Shakira: 0
BEYONCE Ring The Alarm: 0

BRITNEY SPEARS Toxic: 1.142
BRITNEY SPEARS I Wanna Go: 0.197
BRITNEY SPEARS Till The World Ends: 0.147
BRITNEY SPEARS Womanizer: 0.041
BRITNEY SPEARS Hold It Against Me: 0.026
BRITNEY SPEARS I'm A Slave 4 U (2005 Remix): 0.022
BRITNEY SPEARS Circus: 0.019
BRITNEY SPEARS If U Seek Amy: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Everytime: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Baby, One More Time: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Oops...I Did It Again: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS (You Drive Me) Crazy: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS I'm A Slave 4 U: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Lucky: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Gimme More: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Sometimes: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Piece Of Me: 0
BRITNEY SPEARS Break The Ice: 0

Now lets order this same songs, by VEVO views (i removed the 2 Bey videos with the least views so they can have the same amount):

The one in green, shows that it has more views than the same video in the same position by the other artist

BEYONCE Single Ladies (Put A Ring...): 282M views
BEYONCE Halo: 201M views
BEYONCE Best Thing I Never Had: 141M views
BEYONCE If I Were A Boy: 128M views
BEYONCE Love On Top: 125M views
BEYONCE Crazy In Love: 100M views
BEYONCE Irreplaceable: 83M views
BEYONCE Beautiful Liar f/Shakira: 77M views
BEYONCE Diva: 70M views
BEYONCE Dance For You: 53M views
BEYONCE Upgrade U f/Jay-Z: 39M views
BEYONCE Ego: 33M views
BEYONCE Baby Boy f/Sean Paul: 32M views
BEYONCE F/JAY-Z Deja Vu: 30M views
BEYONCE Me, Myself, And I: 27M views
BEYONCE Naughty Girl: 25M views
BEYONCE Check On It f/Slim Thug: 25M views

BRITNEY SPEARS I Wanna Go: 156M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Till The World Ends: 126M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Womanizer: 110M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Baby, One More Time: 95M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Circus: 94M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Toxic: 92M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Hold It Against Me: 92M views

BRITNEY SPEARS Gimme More: 86M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Piece Of Me: 67M views (double upload)
BRITNEY SPEARS Everytime: 47 M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Oops...I Did It Again: 47M views
BRITNEY SPEARS I'm A Slave 4 U: 41M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Sometimes: 39M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Break The Ice: 39M views
BRITNEY SPEARS (You Drive Me) Crazy: 37M views
BRITNEY SPEARS If U Seek Amy: 36M views
BRITNEY SPEARS Lucky: 36M views

Monkey_Juice

The hive always makes themselves look ignorant, this recent success is getting into their heads a little too much.

Baby One More Time ----------> Anything beyonce has ever done

Britney ---> Beyonce ---> Xtina ---> Pink ---> Avril

Haburo

Britney > Beyoncé > P!nk > Christina > Avril

dinorel

Britney > Beyonce > Pink > Xtina > Avril

genetic fail

Britney >>>>>>>>>>>>>> others

suneclipse121

Quote:

Originally posted by Monkey_Juice

The hive always makes themselves look ignorant, this recent success is getting into their heads a little too much.

Baby One More Time ----------> Anything beyonce has ever done

Britney ---> Beyonce ---> Xtina ---> Pink ---> Avril

Ummm no...
Although that song was big for Britney it really sounds dated today and only her fans bring it up. The GP might recognize it but it's was a cute pop song that came and went.

Britney stans need to move on from 1999 and come to reality in 2014. The reality is Britney is arguably finished and the impact she had is felt today in many popstars I'll give her that.