I reckon this album will get good reviews from most, there are a few outlets that just seem to hate her so idk if it will be universal acclaim but it will be better than AP by far.
Diamond Heart, John Wayne, Dancin' In Circles, and Angel down are my favorites. I love all of them except Come to Mama & Hey Girl, but I think they'll grow on me
Diamond Heart -- 8.5/10 [Amazing production. Shoulda been chosen over Perfect Illusion as the lead if she wanted rock influences]
A-Yo -- 9/10 [Absolutely love this song. She sounds like she's having so much fun]
Joanne -- 5.5/10 [The chorus saved the song]
John Wayne -- 9.5/10 [Amazing production. AMAZING AMAZING.]
Dancin' In Circles -- 9/10 [What I imagined the album would sound like a few months back. I don't like the whispering in the chorus. Wish she just said "Let's Funk Downtown", Great overall]
Perfect Illusion -- 4/10 [Something different but it's not a grower]
Million Reasons -- 10/10 [Best Gaga song in recent years]
Sinner's Prayer -- 7.5/10 [Love the production again and her vocals are perfect to fit the feel of the song. This album was very well produced tbh]
Come to Mama -- 5/10 [This sounds like a Meghan Trainor Christmas single.]
Hey Girl -- 6.5/10 [Disappointing tbh]
Angel Down -- 8.5/10 [Excited to hear the work tape. Another great ballad]