Receipts say otherwise..And even if we exclude Mariah for some obvious reasons, we still have Queen Xtina out there, so the answer to your question is no
Ok sis 2 things
1. Those ranges are incorrect. Bey's highest note is an F6 and Xtina's range has drastically shrunk since her vocal peak due to straining/screaming.
2. Range actually means nothing. You can be a good singer and have a limited range (see Adele) or be a bad singer with huge range (see Katy Perry). There is no correlation and it ultimately boils down to if the singer actually sounds good regardless of how high or low the note is.
All of you keep throwing random names in here.
Here's what one of the most talented, if not THE most talented vocalist, can do that others can't.
This thread is about talented vocalists, not success and sales. Nicole is on TOP and that video above proves that. Can any of the for-mentioned names sing like that?
Far, far, far, far... far from it. Vocal range isn't everything. Her voice is boring and doesn't sound unique. No sexiness in it, no emotion. She just doesn't do much for me. Sorry.
All of you keep throwing random names in here.
Here's what one of the most talented, if not THE most talented vocalist, can do that others can't.
This thread is about talented vocalists, not success and sales. Nicole is on TOP and that video above proves that. Can any of the for-mentioned names sing like that?
Now wait one ****ing moment at this absolute tea
This can't possibly be her voice
Why is she churning out trash pop with a voice like that? Lemme go search for more performances from her.
Now wait one ****ing moment at this absolute tea
This can't possibly be her voice
Why is she churning out trash pop with a voice like that? Lemme go search for more performances from her.
Receive your ultimate LIFE from one of the most talented and versatile vocalists of our times. There's literally NO LIMITS to Nicole's voice.
When does having great or appealing voice/timbre equates to having the knowledge, skill and fundamental training (practicing) needed to be a competent vocalist, never mind a virtuoso of Beyonce's caliber!? I've never understood this? Is it because I'm a singer/musician myself, so I understand what it takes to achieve the things that Beyonce and others like Mariah, Whitney, Aretha, Ella Fitzgerald, Cecelia Bertoil, do with their voices??
This logic that having an interesting tone/color and knack for emotive vocals is all that's needed to be GREAT is simply beyond me; I'll never understand! It's like saying that if I purchase a Fazioli Brunei for $400,000 and started banging incoherent melodies on the keys, does that make me the world's greatest pianist because of the natural color/quality of the note?? Does it matter that what I'm doing makes no sense, musically??
Like..
Far, far, far, far... far from it. Vocal range isn't everything. Her voice is boring and doesn't sound unique. No sexiness in it, no emotion. She just doesn't do much for me. Sorry.
I know you're trolling but who has a sexier voice than Bey?
I know you're trolling but who has a sexier voice than Bey?
I know this is a matter of taste, but Beyonce's voice sounds more powerfull instead of sexy. Nicole has a certain tone that's incredibly sexy and sultry.
beyonce has good control of her voice and a lot of technical skill, but personally i like the power in adele's voice better. so she's really skilled in some ways, but she doesn't really show off in others. really, it comes down to whether you personally like power vs control better.
I know this is a matter of taste, but Beyonce's voice sounds more powerfull instead of sexy. Nicole has a certain tone that's incredibly sexy and sultry.
The Closer I Get To You, Speechless, Dance 4 U, and Rocket are all sexier sounding than that.
Quote:
Originally posted by accelgors
beyonce has good control of her voice and a lot of technical skill, but personally i like the power in adele's voice better. so she's really skilled in some ways, but she doesn't really show off in others. really, it comes down to whether you personally like power vs control better.
Bey's voice is more powerful than Adele's though
If anything you like Adele's voice more
When does having great or appealing voice/timbre equates to having the knowledge, skill and fundamental training (practicing) needed to be a competent vocalist, never mind a virtuoso of Beyonce's caliber!? I've never understood this? Is it because I'm a singer/musician myself, so I understand what it takes to achieve the things that Beyonce and others like Mariah, Whitney, Aretha, Ella Fitzgerald, Cecelia Bertoil, do with their voices??
This logic that having an interesting tone/color and knack for emotive vocals is all that's needed to be GREAT is simply beyond me; I'll never understand! It's like saying that if I purchase a Fazioli Brunei for $400,000 and started banging incoherent melodies on the keys, does that make me the world's greatest pianist because of the natural color/quality of the note?? Does it matter that what I'm doing makes no sense, musically??
Like..
The fact that you always hit the nail on the head, yet they continue to scream, "but tone and emotions!," or name someone who doesn't even qualify for the title
When does having great or appealing voice/timbre equates to having the knowledge, skill and fundamental training (practicing) needed to be a competent vocalist, never mind a virtuoso of Beyonce's caliber!? I've never understood this? Is it because I'm a singer/musician myself, so I understand what it takes to achieve the things that Beyonce and others like Mariah, Whitney, Aretha, Ella Fitzgerald, Cecelia Bertoil, do with their voices??
This logic that having an interesting tone/color and knack for emotive vocals is all that's needed to be GREAT is simply beyond me; I'll never understand! It's like saying that if I purchase a Fazioli Brunei for $400,000 and started banging incoherent melodies on the keys, does that make me the world's greatest pianist because of the natural color/quality of the note?? Does it matter that what I'm doing makes no sense, musically??
Like..
Great post that actually knows what they're talking about.
You should get into Nicole tbh. You'll be pleasantly surprise by what she can do with her voice. Nicole and Beyonce are the Top 2 vocalists today.
