The Contenders:
- Adam Lambert "Whataya Want From Me"
- Boys Like Girls f/ Taylor Swift "Two Is Better Than One"
- Jay-Z f/ Alicia Keys "Empire State Of Mind"
- Ke$ha "Tik Tok"
- Owl City "Fireflies"
- Paramore "Brick By Boring Brick"
- Rihanna "Russian Roulette"
- Rihanna f/ Jeezy "Hard"
- Timbaland f/ Katy Perry "If We Ever Meet Again"
Voted Off:
- Selena Gomez & The Scene "Naturally"
- Shakira f/ Lil Wayne "Give It Up To Me"
- Shakira "Did It Again"
- Mariah Carey "H.A.T.E.U."
- Jason Derulo "Whatcha Say"
- Ne-Yo "Never Knew I Needed"
- Muse "Undisclosed Desires"
- Timbaland f/ SoShy & Nelly Furtado "Morning After Dark"
- Lifehouse "Halfway Gone"
- Jay Sean f/ Lil Jon & Sean Paul "Do You Remember"
- Sugababes "Get Sexy"
- Usher "Hey Daddy (Daddy's Home)"
- Adam Lambert "For Your Entertainment"
- Mariah Carey "I Want To Know What Love Is"
- James Morrison "Get To You"
- Beyonce f/ Lady Gaga "Video Phone"
- Iyaz "Replay"
- Chris Brown "Crawl"
- LMFAO f/ Lil Jon "Shots"
- Justin Bieber "One Less Lonely Girl"
- Alicia Keys "Try Sleeping With A Broken Heart" (December 2009 Winner)
- Lady Gaga "Bad Romance" (November 2009 Winner)
Immunity:
- Boys Like Girls f/ Taylor Swift "Two Is Better Than One"
- Rihanna f/ Jeezy "Hard"
Vote Off 2, Save 1
Off:
- Owl City "Fireflies"
- Rihanna "Russian Roulette"