[Hilary & Rock]

Originally posted by eli's_rhythm

I'm glad keriihill got #2 but I really don't understand why mine was so much worse than his... can we have scoring explanations?

BTW--your top 5/not top 50 question was VERY confusing. At first I was putting songs in that didn't go top 50 in the US but went top 5 in other countries, and then I saw you edit it and say that it had NOTHING to do with the Hot 100 and I should just put in songs that went top five in other countries, so I did that instead. But here it is again. WTF?

The idea for that question was this:
1. THE SONGS HAD TO BE TOP 5 IN ANY COUNTRY BESIDES U.S.
2. IF THE SONG WAS A TOP 50 SONG IN THE U.S. IT WASN'T VALID
Example:
Poker Face

I'll post some of the comments of the judges and the ratings of them as well, but gimme some time!!!
I'm updating my countdown now!! and I just updated my Hilary Duff Music Video Survivor! I'm a little busy

[arkl]

I want explanations and the scores please.....

[arkl]

Death @ Pedro wasting Britney Spears

[JimMy]

Can´t wait for the second round!!!

[Rhythm]

Originally posted by keriihill

well done

A bit in awe - I honestly didn't expect to come first. I had the mentality that since I was a judge, I could just cruise on by at a moderate pace. Now that I actually review my answers, I thought the third question would actually bring me down. That, and the fact that alot of the other answers were brilliant.

i.e. Lady Gaga - Donkey Dick!?!
Janet and her MTV parody.
Genius.

Thanks, though.

[The Knowledge]

Originally posted by Rhythm

A bit in awe - I honestly didn't expect to come first. I had the mentality that since I was a judge, I could just cruise on by at a moderate pace. Now that I actually review my answers, I thought the third question would actually bring me down. That, and the fact that alot of the other answers were brilliant.

i.e. Lady Gaga - Donkey Dick!?!
Janet and her MTV parody.
Genius.

Thanks, though.

i didn't think id be that high...im only new to ATRL...so yeah
The lady gaga one wasn't even funny.

good luck for next round

[Rhythm]

Originally posted by Hilary & Rock

The idea for that question was this:
1. THE SONGS HAD TO BE TOP 5 IN ANY COUNTRY BESIDES U.S.
2. IF THE SONG WAS A TOP 50 SONG IN THE U.S. IT WASN'T VALID
Example:
Poker Face

I'll post some of the comments of the judges and the ratings of them as well, but gimme some time!!!
I'm updating my countdown now!! and I just updated my Hilary Duff Music Video Survivor! I'm a little busy

Wasn't Poker Face #1 in the U.S.?

In fact, Poker Face was #1 on every worldwide chart, except Spanish, Italian, and Japanese charts - where it charted #2, #2, and #21, respectively.

[arkl]

Originally posted by Rhythm

Wasn't Poker Face #1 in the U.S.?

In fact, Poker Face was #1 on every worldwide chart, except Spanish, Italian, and Japanese charts - where it charted #2, #2, and #21, respectively.

He cited that as an example to argument number 2

[The Knowledge]

Originally posted by arkl

He cited that as an example to agument number 2

but wasn't it meant to be a song that didn't go top 50 in U.S?

[arkl]

Originally posted by keriihill

but wasn't it meant to be a song that didn't go top 50 in U.S?

Yes and PF is INVALID. Thats why whoever answered that just deprived himself of a score point.

[LONGWAY2GO.]

im still in

[Rhythm]

Originally posted by arkl

He cited that as an example to argument number 2

Ah.

[The Knowledge]

Originally posted by arkl

Yes and PF is INVALID. Thats why whoever answered that just deprived himself of a score point.

thought so

[eli's_rhythm]

Originally posted by Hilary & Rock

The idea for that question was this:
1. THE SONGS HAD TO BE TOP 5 IN ANY COUNTRY BESIDES U.S.
2. IF THE SONG WAS A TOP 50 SONG IN THE U.S. IT WASN'T VALID
Example:
Poker Face

This is what I thought at first but then I read this:

Originally posted by Hilary & Rock

THE IDEA OF THE 3RD QUESTION HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH BILLBOARD, THE PURPOUSE WAS TO FIND A TOP 5 HIT IN ANY COUNTRY

So can you see why I was confused?

[UnusualBoy]

OMG, I'm #5 hopefully top 3 next week

[tcatron565]

Barely made it. Some questions were hard. Especially if your artists had only released one single world wide. "Potential Breakup Song" is the only international charter they had, but it also went to #17 in the US, so I couldn't use it... At least I'm still in. I'm going to come hard this next round!

[Hilary & Rock]

Originally posted by eli's_rhythm

This is what I thought at first but then I read this:


So can you see why I was confused?

THAT's THE TRUE!!!
I said so because a lot of people were asking if it had to be a Top 50 in Billboard or something like that

SORRY IF I CONFUSED YOU BUT YOU DID GOOD!

[M A R N ✮]

i should of been higher i know evermore the most in the world except them

[Hilary & Rock]

RATINGS

Some of the judges commented your answers, so Imma post those comments and the ratings...

Rhythm

Hilary & Rock: 23 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 15 pts
justice:
1. 3 pts
- Nice story but not funny enough... sry
2. 5 pts
- Excellent pic!!
4. 5 +2 pts
- If 100 would be the perfect score, I'd give you 100 lol. 5 Grammys
5. 5 pts
- Way to put it!!
TOTAL = 18 + 2 points
Matty:
1. 5!!! AMAZING HAHA
2. 4 (1 extra point for pink), OMG too much of a close up her face looks weird and shes a beautiful woman
4. 7 (2 extra points for getting an award), YES! That was a great night for her
5. 4, damn that was just a few, and you have more! What are making a beyonce achievement book!?!? Haha
TOTAL: 20

AVERAGE: 19.5

kerihill

Hilary & Rock: 23 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 18 pts
Rhythm: 17 pts
justice:
1. 5 pts
- Gotta love the key part
2. 5 pts
- WOW!!!
4. 4 pts
- Two persons in the pic which is confusing. Who won the award anyway? Should've been an INDIVIDUAL award and alone in the pic
5. 5 pts
- Excellent statement. I have no arguments at all
TOTAL = 19 points
Matty:
1. 3, haha her getting outraged was the best out of all
2. 5 (1 extra point for pink), pink komono (sp?) very original picture
4. 4, even though its not her getting the award it has her brother in it
5. 4, very well said!
TOTAL: 16


AVERAGE: 19

Awkdelicious

Hilary & Rock: 23 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 13 pts
Rhythm: 20 pts
justice:
1. 1.5 pts
- Funny faces aren't necessarily funny videos
2. 5 pts
- HAWT!!!
4. 5 +2 pts
- So many awards
5. 4.5 pts
- Excellent point in stressing her role as a Latin artist. A little billboard mentioning would've earned you a perfect score
TOTAL = 16 + 2 points
Matty:
1. 2, it was a bit boring video but she looked pretty nevertheless
2. 6 (1 extra point for pink), HOT!!!!!!
4. 6 (2 extra points for getting an award), She looked gorgeous.
5. 4, that was impressive!
TOTAL: 18


AVERAGE: 18.4

JimMyxcoRe

Hilary & Rock: 21 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 14 pts
Rhythm: 15 pts
justice:
1. 5 points!!
- OMG gracious!!! Donkey dick
2. 5 points!!
- short, simple and to the point, nice job!!
4. 5 +2 points!!
- Excellent job
5. 5 points!!
- Great job stressing her #1's and her "fashion" lol
TOTAL = 20 points +2 for winning an award
Matty:
1. 3, haha and she kept her cool after saying that lol
2. 6 (one extra point for pink), WERQ!
4. 6 (two extra points for getting award), her face is awkward in that pic but good award.
5. 4
TOTAL: 19


AVERAGE: 18.2

UnusualBoy

Hilary & Rock: 22 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 17 pts
Rhythm: 16 pts
justice:
1. 5 pts
- posting HIMYM would be great too
2. 5 pts
- That's a FIERCE pic
4. 5 pts
- too bad she didn't win any of the two nominations so there will be no plus 2 pts
5. 4 pts
- There are a BILLION reasons to place here, why didn't you mention them. At least mentioning her #1 albums can get you full 5 points.
TOTAL = 19 points
Matty:
1. 2, cute but would’ve been better with the actual audio and not that dreadful song
2. 6 (one extra point for pink), HOTTTTTT!!!!!
4. 2, its alright shes had better performance pictures
5. 3, well said
TOTAL: 13


AVERAGE: 18.2

KarlosVzla

Hilary & Rock: 19 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 15 pts
Rhythm: 16 pts
justice:
1. 4 pts
- Too long. Great beginning but VERY BORING ending i must say
2. 4 pts
- not exactly pink
4. 5 + 2 pts
- Yes, MTV movie awards is relevant
5. 4 pts
- If you mentioned party in the u.s.a. snatching the #1 on itunes then you would've gotten full points
TOTAL = 17 + 2 points
Matty:
1. 4, haha so corny but funny
2. 5 (1 extra point for pink), nice!!!
4. 5 (2 extra points for getting award), very pretty! Is that a nipple dent?
5. 3, that’s true
TOTAL: 17


AVERAGE: 17.2

HotNCold

Hilary & Rock: 18 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 15 pts
Rhythm: 15 pts
justice:
1. 4.5 points
- excellent ending but the beginning to mid was boring i must admit
2. 5 points
- EPIC!!
4. 5 + 2 points!!
- Excellent
5. 4 points
- was almost convinced. If you have stressed IKAG tied with Rihanna's Umbrella then i could've given a perfect score
TOTAL = 18.5 + 2 (for the award)
Matty:
1. 3, that’s cute
2. 5 (one extra point for pink), HOT!
4. 5 (two extra points for getting award), gotta give it to her for going even though she was really sick at the event
5. 2
TOTAL: 15


AVERAGE: 16.7

Duca

Hilary & Rock: 19 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 14 pts
Rhythm: 15 pts
justice:
1. 3 pts
- Something SHORTER and SIMPLER would've been more preferable
2. 4.5 pts
- Not exactly pink but close enough
4. 5 + 2pts
- Very well put
5. 1.5 pts
- I needed facts please!! at least mentioning He Said She Said from TRL would be nice though
TOTAL = 14 + 2 points
Matty:
1. 3, long but funny
2. 4 (1 extra point for pink), pretty
4. 7 (2 extra points for getting award), HOTNESS!!!
5. 3, nice…
TOTAL: 17

AVERAGE: 16.2

Hilary & Rock

-mUsIcLoVeR- : 14 pts
Rhythm: 15 pts
justice:
1. 2.5 points
- not really as funny as the others. But I really understand that it's really hard to find a funny video from her since she's too serious
2. 5 points
- WOW!! HAWT!!
4. 5 + 2 points!!
- Nice screenshot!!
5. 5 points
- By mentioning her music, acting and business career, you had me totally convinced
TOTAL = 17.5 + 2 (for the award)
Matty:
1. 3, cute
2. 5 (one extra point for pink), HOT!
4. 4 (two extra points for getting award), the fans arms cut of the picture but she looked victorious getting the award.
5. 4, very well said
TOTAL: 16


AVERAGE: 16.125

eli's_rhythm

Hilary & Rock: 19 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 12 pts
Rhythm: 18 pts
justice:
1. 1.5 pts
- Honestly, i lost my attention watching the video after the 1st minute.
2. 5 pts
- LOL hahaha!! PJs are definitely IN!!!
4. 5 +2 pts
- Excellent choice !!
5. 4 pts
- Not totally convinced though

TOTAL = 15.5 + 2 pts
Matty:
1. 1
2. 3 (1 extra point for pink), Love the PJ’s
4. 6 (2 extra points for getting award), Awesome!
5. 4, well said!
TOTAL: 14


AVERAGE: 16.1

AshleeSimpsonFan

Hilary & Rock: 18 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 14 pts
Rhythm: 15 pts
justice:
1. 1 pt
- I thought I fell asleep.....
2. 5 pts
- Nice!!
4. 5 + 2 pts
- Excellent choice!! This award is relevant eventhough it's in Australia. Nobody can say that one continent is better than the other
5. 4 pts
- no further comment
TOTAL = 15 + 2 points
Matty:
1. 2, ashlee was near the end it was mainly just pete
2. 3, HOT
4. 4 (two extra points for getting award), pretty!
5. 4, loved it!
TOTAL: 13


AVERAGE: 15.4

arkl

Hilary & Rock: 23 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 10 pts
Rhythm: 15 pts
justice:
1. 3.5 pts
- The airport scene was the only funny part of it
2. 5 pts
- pink brief? YOU WISH!!
4. 5 +2 pts
- Wise choice
5. 3 pts
- That pic will definitely own almost all male artist physically, what about the female artists? and what about his music accomplishments? Does "Hero" ever ring a bell to you? lol
TOTAL = 16.5 + 2 points
Matty:
1. 2, some funny moments
2. 3, ok…
4. 3, kissing the award showing compassion to what he received lol
5. 2, any male artist could do that
TOTAL: 10


AVERAGE: 15.3

Long Way 2 Go

Hilary & Rock: 16 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 13 pts
Rhythm: 11 pts
justice:
1. 5 points
- Definitely funny!! and the fact that you admit that your fave is only human and can commit mistakes, you get full credit
2. 5 points
- LMAO at the face!!
4. 4 points
- should've placed what year though ^_^
5. 2 points
- not really convinced. should've mentioned her first #1 album though
TOTAL = 16
Matty:
1. 3, haha and she did a little pose afterward like what I fell what now
2. 5 (one extra point for pink), Haha I love the LaLa Land video
4. 4, GORGEOUS!
5. 3, nicely said
TOTAL: 15


AVERAGE: 14.2

fiercE

Hilary & Rock: 14 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 9 pts
Rhythm: 14 pts
justice:
1. 3.5 pts
- You could've done better. Come on, he's a comedian!! there are tons of funny scenes in drake and josh (and with drake alone for that matter)
2. 4.5 pts
- Not totally red but almost
4. 5 +2 pts
- Nick awards is definitely relevant. Kids represent majority of the population and can make sound decisions too when it comes to their favorites
5. 4.5 pts
- Thanks for giving at least 1 actual and FACTUAL accomplishment. Giving you also the E for the effort considering it's hard to find an accomplishment for this artist and you know it (i didn't even know he had an album out)
TOTAL = 17.5 +2 points
Matty:
1. 1, showed more of josh than drake…
2. 3, ok…
4. 4 (two extra points for getting award), nice…
5. 3, nicely said
TOTAL: 11


AVERAGE: 13.5

JM4ever

Hilary & Rock: 17 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 11 pts
Rhythm: 15 pts
justice:
1. 2 pts
- Not that funny sorry
2. 5 pts
- Nice and simple
4. 5 pts
- Missed the 2 points for not winning. Should've mentioned TCA
5. 5 pts
- You got me in the sold out concert AND maze
TOTAL = 17 points
Matty:
1. 1, everyone rocks out to break music
2. 1, not the most pleasing album cover
4. 2, Jordin overpowered him in that 2nd picture that’s not good if your wanting be the best stan
5. 2, for that 6th reason someone had a lot of time on their hands…
TOTAL: 6


AVERAGE: 15.2

tcatron565

Hilary & Rock: 15 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 15 pts
Rhythm: 11 pts
justice:
1. 2 points
- OMG it's too long. They were laughing but it wasn't really funny
2. 3 points
- Well it's not exactly pink or red. more of a stripe but black was more dominant AND only 1 of them were wearing that lol
4. 5 points
- If they would've won you could've gotten 7points.
5. 5 points!!
- Even with your argument for #1 and 2, you already had me convinced
TOTAL = 15 points
Matty:
1. 1, I got bored listening to it
2. 1, its only a bit of red
4. 2, lets keep the peace going
5. 3
TOTAL: 7


AVERAGE: 12.6

Xx-M!ss-Marn!e-Xx

Hilary & Rock: 14 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 7 pts
Rhythm: 9 pts
justice:
1. 3 pts
- I would've given 1 point if it weren't for the great accoustic and the rehab part in the end
2. 2 pts
- I believe it's what we call maroon
4. 5 + 2 pts
- Excellent answer. Again, This award is relevant eventhough it's in Australia. Nobody can say that one continent is better than the other
5. 1 pts
- Say WHAT!? We want proof not subjective comparisons
TOTAL = 11 + 2 points
Matty:
1. 4, haha those lyrics are hilarious!
2. 2, to me its more purple but I guess it’s a deep red
4. 2, cool
5. 3, jon hume crashed britney and beyonce down the ass?
TOTAL: 11


AVERAGE: 10.8

Lukitoo

Hilary & Rock: 14 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 11 pts
Rhythm: 9 pts
justice:
1. 2 pts
- they weren't really funny there. Only the camerawoman was funny (in a way)
2. 1.5 pts
- The red is almost invisible in the picture.
4. 5 pts
- Yes that is a relevant awards show. Too bad no awards so no 2 points
5. 2 pts
- I'm not convinced at ALL. Should've mention any chart or album that appeared in the Billboard
TOTAL = 10.5 points
Matty:
1. 1, wheres the funny but they were humble and I liked that
2. 2, red shoes not that noticeable but the look good
4. 3, very cute and adorable
5. 3, nicely said
TOTAL: 9


AVERAGE: 10.7

spc08

Hilary & Rock: 16 pts
Rhythm: 3 pts
-mUsIcLoVeR- : 5 pts
justice:
1. 3 points
- Okay....
2. 5 points
- simple yet to the point
4. 4 + 2 points
- I wanted to give 5 but should've mentioned what award and what year this is ^_^ I guess the 2 points additional can be given
5. 2 points
- Those are only personality and talents. what about her accomplishments?????
TOTAL = 14 + 2 (for the award)
Matty:
1. 1, WTF
2. 3 (one extra point for pink), she looks pretty
4. 5 (two extra points for getting award), she looks pretty and the grammy is big.
5. 3
TOTAL: 12


AVERAGE: 10.4

[eli's_rhythm]

Edit: it's fine I just checked the quote.

Justice, you should've watched the end of the video. It's really boring at the beginning but it gets hilarious and candid. I should've told you to skip ahead.