[Kh-Loud]

Neither Rihanna nor GAGA is. Beyonce was the popstar of LAST GENERATION. she will still be the in the next several GENERATIONS.

[RobynYoBank]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Literally, the only thing the GaGa stans (a certain few) ever throw at you are sales receipts if they want to argue that GaGa has more iconic songs than Rihanna, which makes zero sense. Not worth the effort to deal with that circular mess.

So #1 songs that other people wrote and produced for Rihanna are a more substantial receipt than millions of people worldwide actually spending their hard-earned money on the music and productions of another star?

[chris1991]

Originally posted by Retro Dance Freak

Six weeks at #1, 8.2 million sold worldwide. Did "Only Girl" do that?

BTW is iconic too, get over it.

But its not though.
Like someone said, only because it sold that much doesnt make it iconic. Nobody used the song after they bought it.

And im not just againt the song because its gaga. Bad Romance & Poker face are far far far more iconic then btw will ever be. Btw just isnt iconic. It mat be iconic to the monsters but not the general public.

[KyKy]

Like Angelina Jolie has anything to do with deciding who the pop star of our generation is

[BadBitch]

Let's not forget this.

I can believe it. She's a big star.

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=136336

Even Mother Monster knows the tea.

[Jolie's Lips]

Can the Navy at least provide some receipts besides the whole 'only gays love Gaga. All songs by Rih are legendary; no one knows a Gaga song' thing? Usually they're pretty good at providing us inflated receipts so I'm waiting.

[rihannabiggestfan]

Originally posted by Kh-Loud

BEYONCE is the pop star of the GENERATION. Rihanna is too mediocre be called that. There's nothing that she can do and others cant do better. The next generation would laugh and make fun of how crappy n low standard the music industry was if Rihanna was one.

i am SCREAMING

[b3dro]

Originally posted by Kh-Loud

Neither Rihanna nor GAGA is. Beyonce was the popstar of LAST GENERATION. she will still be the in the next several GENERATIONS.

Get out of this thread

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Kh-Loud

BEYONCE is the pop star of the GENERATION. Rihanna is too mediocre be called that. There's nothing that she can do and others cant do better. The next generation would laugh and make fun of how crappy n low standard the music industry was if Rihanna was one.

Originally posted by Kh-Loud

Neither Rihanna nor GAGA is. Beyonce was the popstar of LAST GENERATION. she will still be the in the next several GENERATIONS.

Sam stop.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by MrDeeds

To be the pop star of the generation, you have to be liked BY A generation, not by a minority.

Britney had more haters (and more limited demographic appeal) and got more criticism in her prime than Gaga has. Was she not the pop star of her generation?

[Beautiful Sinner]

Originally posted by Kh-Loud

Neither Rihanna nor GAGA is. Beyonce was the popstar of LAST GENERATION. she will still be the in the next several GENERATIONS.

She never was and never will be.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by Icing

music that people bop + drink to now but will ultimately be forgotten.

Isn't that how select groups of people describe most of GaGa's music but now, plus the alienation of the GP with her last efforts

[KyKy]

Originally posted by BadBitch

Let's not forget this.


http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=136336

Even Mother Monster knows the tea.

Not even GaGa herself claiming this.

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by Icing

Lmao no. She can churn out all the hits/#1s in the world and still no one will give a **** about her. Zero star power, music that people bop + drink to now but will ultimately be forgotten (bar Umbrella).

Originally posted by Slant Magazine

Rihanna had been tagged with the ice-queen label as early as Good Girl Gone Bad, owing less to the presence of a distinct persona than to the total lack of one. In that context, "icy" essentially meant "vacant," and vacant is what Rihanna remains even as she attempts to infuse her dance confections with a bit of warm blood. As always, Rihanna is little more than a cipher for multiplatinum producers' committee, less a singer than a delivery system for hooks and beats.

[Mélina]

Originally posted by Kh-Loud

BEYONCE is the pop star of the GENERATION. Rihanna is too mediocre be called that. There's nothing that she can do and others cant do better. The next generation would laugh and make fun of how crappy n low standard the music industry was if Rihanna was one.

Sam

[Callisto.]

Originally posted by Kh-Loud

Neither Rihanna nor GAGA is. Beyonce was the popstar of LAST GENERATION. she will still be the in the next several GENERATIONS.

Bitch I'm sick of you

[Sinister]

Originally posted by Icing

Lmao no. She can churn out all the hits/#1s in the world and still no one will give a **** about her. Zero star power, music that people bop + drink to now but will ultimately be forgotten (bar Umbrella).

don't sit there and lie

Rihanna has a lot of star powere...you just can't see it

There's a reason why many artist are begging her for collabos...she's a crossover smash and she has the Red hair and the "Rihanna Bob"

[Retro]

Originally posted by chris1991

But its not though.
Like someone said, only because it sold that much doesnt make it iconic. Nobody used the song after they bought it.

And im not just againt the song because its gaga. Bad Romance & Poker face are far far far more iconic then btw will ever be. Btw just isnt iconic. It mat be iconic to the monsters but not the general public.

And who the hell are you to say nobody uses it besides Monsters? Jesus?
I know plenty of people who still remember and use it. That must count for something seeing how much some people in here think their schools are a legitimate indicator of public interest.

[BadBitch]

Originally posted by Kh-Loud

Neither Rihanna nor GAGA is. Beyonce was the popstar of LAST GENERATION. she will still be the in the next several GENERATIONS.

[MrDeeds]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

Britney had more haters (and more limited demographic appeal) and got more criticism in her prime than Gaga has. Was she not the pop star of her generation?

Dudes could jack off to Britney. Enough said.