[P!nkInside]

Originally posted by Remixed

The bolded things are related to music, and yes she changed the sound because it's been far more frequent ever since her first two singles in particular became bigger smashes than any of the songs you listed.

No they are not.

And I already gave you receipts of dance-pop songs that smashed before Gaga. I don't see what the debate is about

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Originally posted by Yourfavefan

Ke$ha made it pop up on radio with tik tok and had many copies.. nobody really copied just dance

You made it too easy.

[Ramcoro]

Originally posted by Dickard

Why is it always the Katy fans that rush to the Gaga threads?

Because Gaga stans came in and brought up Katy first and try to discredit everything Katy has done as "copying Gaga" even if Katy did it first.

[Monceau]

Of course.

[Dickard]

Originally posted by P!nkInside

Because Katy is always brought up

I just wish that people would view them separately. It's constantly a competition between the two

[Allie]

Originally posted by Dickard

Someone is upset
how am I being hypocritical?
I'm just stating that it's the same people who are jumping on Gaga's ****.
I'm not gonna sit here and lie through my teeth and say Katy hasn't been successful or a little influential, because she has. So why are some of you discrediting Gaga?

Never in my post did I once discredit her, I already told you that she's made a ton of impact and I voted yes.

[Dickard]

Originally posted by Ramcoro

Because Gaga stans came in and brought up Katy first and try to discredit everything Katy has done as "copying Gaga" even if Katy did it first.

Katy has done many things first.
But she has been influenced by Gaga in some way, you can't deny.
It's not detrimental so no harm done.

[P!nkInside]

Originally posted by Dickard

I just wish that people would view them separately. It's constantly a competition between the two

I know they're totally different artists with different beliefs.
But i guess its part of the deal. Like people always compare Beyonce and Rihanna

[Dickard]

Originally posted by Allie

Never in my post did I once discredit her, I already told you that she's made a ton of impact and I voted yes.

I never said it was you specifically. Some of you refers to thread as a whole. Get off your high horse already, this is an online discussion not a presidential debate.

[Ramcoro]

About the Gaga "brought dance music back"


Okay yea 2010 had more dance pop than 2009, and 2009 had more dance pop than 2008, but 2008 also had more dance pop than 2007, and 2007 had more dance pop than 2006.

See the trend? The trend that Gaga's debut was in the middle of.

[Dickard]

Originally posted by P!nkInside

I know they're totally different artists with different beliefs.
But i guess its part of the deal. Like people always compare Beyonce and Rihanna

Really narrow-minded to do if it's constantly being done

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Originally posted by P!nkInside

We're talking about MUSICAL and not LYRICAL content

I am side-eyeing you so hard right now.

LYRICS ARE A PART OF MUSIC AND ITS' COMPOSITION.

Your misinformed transparency is embarassing.

[Remixed]

Music videos
Performances
Lyrics
Type of music
influence on other artists

all parts of music

[Forevermore]

Yes.

[P!nkInside]

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

I am side-eyeing you so hard right now.

LYRICS ARE A PART OF MUSIC AND IT'S COMPOSITION.

Your misinformed transparency is embarassing.

You did not get the point.
He/She said IKAG cannot be considered for the revival of dance-pop because people found it's lyrics to be offensive.
When in reality, if one talks of the genre of a song, it's production is taken into consideration and not its lyrics.

Stop twisting what i say

[P!nkInside]

Originally posted by Remixed

Music videos
Performances
Lyrics
Type of music
influence on other artists

all parts of music

Did you read the OP?

[Ramcoro]

Originally posted by Dickard

Katy has done many things first.
But she has been influenced by Gaga in some way, you can't deny.
It's not detrimental so no harm done.

Like what?

[coolcristobal]

Originally posted by P!nkInside

Who deserved credit for the PRODUCTION of the song. Not the lyrics. Not the vocals.
And RedOne deserves all the credit for the PRODUCTION

If this is the case, then NO singers have made any impact on dance music, their producers did!

[Dickard]

Originally posted by Ramcoro

Like what?

Fashion-wise and some artistic choices (some, not all) seem to have Gaga influence.
Of course, one could argue that she's just progressing as an artist.
Perspective

[P!nkInside]

Originally posted by coolcristobal

If this is the case, then NO singers have made any impact on dance music, their producers did!

Simple as that