Quote:
Originally posted by SupremeGoddess
what about Beautiful Liar, Deja Vu, Ring The Alarm, Listen and Upgrade U?
|
Upgrade U & Listen weren't singles, Deja Vu & Ring The Alarm came before Irreplaceable
Here's how I see Beautiful Liar. I have no idea how it would do w/o Irreplaceable. It would have still been huge WW, but I'm not sure about US.
Listen was part of an updated version of B'Day Deluxe, plus it had Dreamgirls promo.
How I see it, B'Day would sell maybe 500K-1 million less if it wasn't for Irreplaceable :/