[istan4badgalriri]

Originally posted by 5hfangurl

There is not a single songwriter that has EVER claimed that Bey didn't have an integral involvement with the writing. Some of yall seem to forget that songwriting isn't just about writing down the words. It includes melodies, harmonies, tempo, ad-libs. None of the songs would've ended up being the way that they are hadn't she taken part of the writing.

.

[Pop]

About 50-60%.

[Beyonce_runthis]

We can't answer this question because we don't know. We only know what some of the producers told us. Like how she wrote all her verses for formation.

[katara]

Less than 5%.

[ks_dollar]

Originally posted by Kuntmonster

Ok you sound stupid right now. Take Daddy Lessons for example - he doesn't literally mean "she went and made all of these changes" - if that was the case, the original writer and Beyoncé would be the only credited writers. But in Daddy Lessons there are 7 or so writers credited.

When he says "she took it away and made these changes" he actually means she took it away and sat down with a team of people and made the changes, not solely her on her own. Again, hence there being a lot of writers on the song and not just those two. If she literally took his song and made the changes all herself there would be 2 writers on the song.

This is what Beyoncé does, always has done and always will do. The hive just need to accept that she has a huge team of people helping her out and stop being delusional.

/endthread

Cheers. 🍻

[Aegean]

From what I've read on the Internet (not a very reliable source I know), the only reason she gets writing credits is that she usually does the melodies, vocal arrangement etc. I personally don't care if an artist writes their songs or not

[MrLovett]

Originally posted by Kuntmonster

Ok you sound stupid right now. Take Daddy Lessons for example - he doesn't literally mean "she went and made all of these changes" - if that was the case, the original writer and Beyoncé would be the only credited writers. But in Daddy Lessons there are 7 or so writers credited.

When he says "she took it away and made these changes" he actually means she took it away and sat down with a team of people and made the changes, not solely her on her own. Again, hence there being a lot of writers on the song and not just those two. If she literally took his song and made the changes all herself there would be 2 writers on the song.

This is what Beyoncé does, always has done and always will do. The hive just need to accept that she has a huge team of people helping her out and stop being delusional.

/endthread

There's FOUR writers on "Daddy Lessons", not seven. You can't even be bothered to do the correct research for your lies. It's getting embarrassing. Just go focus on your fave and stop with this whole "trying to drag Beyoncé" thing, because you're really not very good at it.

[MrLovett]

Originally posted by Jay Trene

Beyonce is not a song writer, she edits an already finished song to suit her. And that is not something to be ridiculed over!!

How ever Columbia records are to be blamed for branding Beyonce as the Multi talented, multi skilled performer, dancer, singer, song writer, producer etc... They branded her this way ever since Destiny's Child to make her stand out. Unfortunately Beyonce is receiving back slash for this.

She wrote virtually all the lyrics on the Survivor album. She is 100% a songwriter, people just choose not to give her full credit because she likes working with different people on the creation of her music now. Just because she doesn't write the whole song from start to finish, doesn't mean she's not a songwriter.

[6_INCH_HEELS]

Y'all still seething?

[TheFireLexus]

[pieuxvu]

Enough to make it the best album of the year

[Fenrir]

Originally posted by Superpower

So we went from:
1. Beyoncé steals credits

to

2. Bwhahaha 78 writers!!11!!

to

3. But she only wrote 40% of the album

What's next?

They're certainly running out of ideas.

[GrownBoy92]

60 %

[Kisuke]

Enough to get more money then the girls saying nothing will ever see

[CallumDavies]

yall are pressed to the gods

[6_INCH_HEELS]

Originally posted by CallumDavies

yall are pressed to the gods

They've been carrying on like kicked puppies for 3 days already. I sure hope they don't plan on being this hurt all the way to Feb.

[CallumDavies]

the people in here who's faves don't write at all

beyonce literally has awards for song writing

[taylor__fan]

1% maybe?

[Havoc]

Originally posted by Kuntmonster

Ok you sound stupid right now. Take Daddy Lessons for example - he doesn't literally mean "she went and made all of these changes" - if that was the case, the original writer and Beyoncé would be the only credited writers. But in Daddy Lessons there are 7 or so writers credited.

When he says "she took it away and made these changes" he actually means she took it away and sat down with a team of people and made the changes, not solely her on her own. Again, hence there being a lot of writers on the song and not just those two. If she literally took his song and made the changes all herself there would be 2 writers on the song.

No you're the one that sounds stupid with your assumptions. YOU WERE NOT THERE. If the original writer specifically pointed out that it was Beyonce that made the changes to the song, I'm going to take their word of it over yours considering they were the ones that have first-hand information on how the song was created. Not to mention various different writers keep saying the same thing about her over and over and over and over again and her involvement is evidence from her style being present so much of her discography despite all the different writers she's worked with. You're also assuming that only 1 writer was involved in the song before it got to Bey.

Also, there are only THREE other writers listed on Daddy's Lessons, not 7. Please stop pulling things out of your ass.

This is what Beyoncé does, always has done and always will do. The hive just need to accept that she has a huge team of people helping her out and stop being delusional.

OH REALLY?! 0:46-1:37
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ksOHrS-RqN4

[Cockney Cupcake]

Can non Adele stans keep her out of their mouths and stop hiding behind her & others in their attempts to drag Bey? Thank you.