[BeamMeUp]

I never got the 'no emotion from Beyoncé' thing. Is it something Britney stans made up to find flaw in the Bey's performances? Or do people just not watch her live videos & have this notion that technicality comes with loss of emotion.

It's tired, it's the easy way out. 'Gaga has emotion cause it's raw,' spare me!



I really don't think Stefani could go THERE.

[SaDaré]

Originally posted by Kisuke

and they say she can't convey emotion

[mariska]

Originally posted by VAN de

That makes you a stan. Congrats.

It means I have an opinion. If you want my honest-to-god opinion, I find Beyonce to put on a facade when she sings. She tries to be emotional but it just comes out contrived. I love her, I really do, but seriously.. the woman has flaws. Just as Gaga does. I cannot emotionally connect with Bey. It has nothing to do with me being obsessed with Gaga. I'd hold the same opinion even if I hated Gaga.

[Loghen]

Originally posted by VAN de

Yes, their voices when performing live.

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by hausofkisuke

God you are annoying and Beyonce.

Originally posted by iBeyoncé.

What a stupid thread.

!!!!

[Sunshine.]

Originally posted by mariska

It means I have an opinion. If you want my honest-to-god opinion, I find Beyonce to put on a facade when she sings. She tries to be emotional but it just comes out contrived. I love her, I really do, but seriously.. the woman has flaws. Just as Gaga does. I cannot emotionally connect with Bey. It has nothing to do with me being obsessed with Gaga. I'd hold the same opinion even if I hated Gaga.

Yes, stan. She faked her emotions about being pregnant when she sang at the VMA's.

[Lyzz the Monster]

Beyonce is definitely a better vocalist but I prefer Gaga's voice.
They're both talented and amazing performance artists.

[Da beezness!]

Originally posted by Kworb

Whose got a better voice overall? Beyoncé
Who's got a better range? Beyoncé
Who's got a better tone? Gaga
Whose voice convey better emotion? Gaga

This is it. On the objective criteria (range and voice overall), Beyoncé is the only possible answer. Thus Beyoncé has a better voice.

[MrPeanut]

Beyonce of course.

[mariska]

Originally posted by VAN de

Yes, stan. She faked her emotions about being pregnant when she sang at the VMA's.

Wasn't that performance lipsynced or prerecorded or something?

But yes, she did.

[Cesar]

Originally posted by Deuces.

Obviously Beyoncé....but they both **** on Britney tbh.

THIS

[beyoncefan1]

Beyonce obviously. I've seen her and GaGa live and lemme tell I got WAY more life from her than I did GaGa. I'm not saying GaGa isn't a good singer because she is very talented in fact she has one the best voices in pop today which is rare to find nowadays but I connect so much more with Beyonce emotionally and pyshically. Her voice beyond flawless and when she goes into her different ranges with a great example being I Care I just melt in so many different ways.

[Sunshine.]

Originally posted by mariska

Wasn't that performance lipsynced?

Yes. Her vocals are fake, her emotions are fake, her image is fake, her whole career is fake.

[=NEX=]

Originally posted by VAN de

Yes. Her vocals are fake, her emotions are fake, her image is fake, her whole career is fake.

Ok. Lets wrap this thread on this note.

[_Monster_]

This thread got boring after the 3rd page. Beyonce is the better vocalist/singer. But that still doesn't take anything away from Gaga's voice.

The End.

[botnus]

Isnt op a beygaga hater? What a messy thread