Since nobody seemed to follow matty's instructions to provide "a few sentences" explaining why you chose your avi, instead of trying to penalize everyone for that I'm going to vote primarily off the avis themselves. Especially since that's what the rest of atrl sees when they notice you around the forum (they don't get your explanations).
I actually love extrachapsticks way of ranking but I'm too lazy to change. Lucky for some of you, unlucky for some.
--
I promised I wouldn't write long critiques but I couldn't help myself. Some of you nailed this challenge and the majority of you kinda flopped. Very surprised by my ranking, tbh.
Lucky for some of you, unlucky for some. 
