| |
Fan Base: Hilary Duff
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 14,461
|
whew, this thread is getting heated 
well to calm the tention a bit, when i was going to the beach last week with my friends, 'Come Clean' came on and i stated crying because that song was my life when i was little and my friends recorded it and showed it to everyone
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/5/2014
Posts: 9,550
|
I honestly don't understand why some of you defend everything she does. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/2/2014
Posts: 2,978
|
Duffaholic, Right Now and MikeyDuff y'all are exhausting tbh. STOP WITH YOUR FCKING DELUSION AND LOOK AT THE FACTS: the bitch doesn't care. She promised us a tour in February. Here we are today, and she's saying she doesn't think she wants to do music anymore.
Yasin has only been stating facts. The bitch has been lying and you know that very well. Just because some of you have a certain relationship with her doesn't mean you have to lick her ass all the time. Hilary has done us wrong. I understand her "family first" decision but it doesn't mean we can't express our disappointment with that. And no, we're not leaving the base! We're also supporting her, running fan accounts, buying multiple copies of her music and movies, gifting, etc. We actually love the damn woman! This is why we want to see more of her and why we want her to be at the top of her game again!
You will have to accept our different opinions. This is what makes this base alive anyway cos Hilary is doing nothing tbh... Her going to 3 Fashion Week shows is now work for us, when is her next vacation by the way? She has been on 2 this year and we're only 2 months into the new year. Good for her, I hope she had a good time. But it's really disappointing to see how she really doesn't give a **** about her fans. She knows what we're asking for... Dignity was released 9 years ago, her last tour date was 8 years ago yet we're still here. Can't she make a little more efforts? 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 1,674
|
I just came in here to say that I heard Sparks once and My Kind played twice in different stores this weekend but y'all are a mess 
(Also my friend got in my car and played One in a Million)
(Also also did anyone ever get that fan edition with the names in it because mine never came and now they're sold out so idk if my name is in it )
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/3/2014
Posts: 693
|
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D
Since you wanna be lazy and stubborn and don't wanna go back and look at your own posts, I guess I have to spell it out for you...
You were clearly suggesting that she makes the music for the charts and made her seem overly confident. Why else were you referencing that quote if that wasn't what you were suggesting? I'm genuinely curious...
|
I know exactly what I've written that's why I said and I will say it again, all I did was ONLY quoting her I didn't give my personal opinion ! But you doesn't seem or maybe you don't want to understand it. So let's make it simpler for you, please answer these questions with yes or no (only yes or no) :
- Did she say "When I come back, I want to do it in a big way!" ?
- Did she say "HELL YEAH! Of course. I think you have to believe it and be confident in anything you want. So of course I believe that. It might take a few years, but I think I’ll do it again " when she was asked "Do you think you’ll sell another 15M records ?" ?
- Did she say "I definitely plan on touring, I think that's really important as an artist. It would have to be meticulously planned" when she was asking about touring ?
All I did was quoting these three statements nothing more and nothing less.
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D
Because they both have to do with charts/sales?
She light-heartedly said that she could sell another 15 million records, which you have no trouble pointing out, to make her seem chart hungry. But more recently she has said that she was proud of BIBO going top 5 and had no desire to be a huge popstar.
|
I still don't see the relation but why wouldn't I point it out ?! WTH she said it not me !
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D
When it comes to Hilary, we should use her more recent quotes to back up what we're saying, instead of using ones from the AAY era, when she was clearly more excited about the music.
|
I think when we want to know what somebody was planning to do we rely on their plans before doing that thing... More concretely, if we want to know what was Hilary intending to do with her comeback we have to use her statements before the release of BIBO otherwise it would make no sense.
Quote:
Originally posted by Right Now
The amount of lies in this post and absolutely no back up for it. Im the only one here (other than maybe Mikey) who actually looks at it from a realistic point of view instead of "WeLl J.lo and BriTneY cAn Do iT!!?!" nonsense when nothing about Hilary suggests that she wants to do whatever they are doing. Avery and I were talking about this yesterday, if you all can't stand her and how her career is going so much, why are you still checking for her?
Stick a fork in you, you're done. |
Where are the lies ? When you accuse someone of lying you must have proofs.
Who talked about Britney or JLo or any other artist ? I never did so your mixing everything here.
Your problem is that you don't accept any opinion other than yours and you saying that you're the only realistic fan here illustrate it very well and btw we've seen how realistic you are before...
Quote:
Originally posted by Duffaholic
I get having your own opinion, which you have every right to have. To add on to what Mikey said, some of you are constantly bringing the girl down, I get it frustration... we're all in the same boat here, don't make it worse than it already is. You are twisting her words, and making it sound a lot worse than she is actually coming off.
|
I don't see how reporting things she said is twisting her words !
Quote:
Originally posted by Duffaholic
Let's live in the present and not grab quotes from two or three years ago. It's just irrelevant facts at this point.
|
Like I said before we were talking about what was Hilary intending to do with her comeback so we have to use her statements before the release of BIBO. And we can use any quote we want as long as there is no rule to forbid it.
Quote:
Originally posted by Duffaholic
If it bothers you that much, why do you still invest your time on her, and keep checking on her. You bring her down now, but when we get pics of her going to the studio you will be up on her again. The negativity and jabs towards her are getting old.
|
If the truth bring you or bring her down then yes we're bringing you down.
Do you find it weird that we criticize her when she does bad things and we applaud her when she does good things ? That's weird...
I wonder if the three of you have ever heard about something called Democracy ? If not please google it and try to read about it.
Every time a fan has a different opinion than yours you jump on him and tbh it's getting very annoying. You're not in a position that allows you to tell us what we have to do and what quotes we should use. The majority of us have been fans of Hilary since a long time ago and maybe before you and we care about her that's why we keep on supporting her !
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/3/2014
Posts: 693
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Alien.
I honestly don't understand why some of you defend everything she does. |
The more annoying thing is that they don't accept any other opinion than theirs. As soon as somebody says something they don't agree with, they jump on him like a repressive police.
And this time I didn't even give my opinion i just QUOTED her
Quote:
Originally posted by DuffStan
Duffaholic, Right Now and MikeyDuff y'all are exhausting tbh. STOP WITH YOUR FCKING DELUSION AND LOOK AT THE FACTS: the bitch doesn't care. She promised us a tour in February. Here we are today, and she's saying she doesn't think she wants to do music anymore.
Yasin has only been stating facts. The bitch has been lying and you know that very well. Just because some of you have a certain relationship with her doesn't mean you have to lick her ass all the time. Hilary has done us wrong. I understand her "family first" decision but it doesn't mean we can't express our disappointment with that. And no, we're not leaving the base! We're also supporting her, running fan accounts, buying multiple copies of her music and movies, gifting, etc. We actually love the damn woman! This is why we want to see more of her and why we want her to be at the top of her game again!
You will have to accept our different opinions. This is what makes this base alive anyway cos Hilary is doing nothing tbh... Her going to 3 Fashion Week shows is now work for us, when is her next vacation by the way? She has been on 2 this year and we're only 2 months into the new year. Good for her, I hope she had a good time. But it's really disappointing to see how she really doesn't give a **** about her fans. She knows what we're asking for... Dignity was released 9 years ago, her last tour date was 8 years ago yet we're still here. Can't she make a little more efforts? |
Exactly ! They don't seem to get that when you love somebody you still can (and in my opinion you should) criticize them when they take bad decisions. We all do mistakes and Hilary does too she's not a goddess, at least not for me.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/5/2014
Posts: 9,550
|
Yeah... I don't think she cares about the fans anymore tbh.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/9/2012
Posts: 13,858
|
Well yeah her music career is over, we are fans now of a TV Land star 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/6/2012
Posts: 8,413
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Yasin
I know exactly what I've written that's why I said and I will say it again, all I did was ONLY quoting her I didn't give my personal opinion ! But you doesn't seem or maybe you don't want to understand it. So let's make it simpler for you, please answer these questions with yes or no (only yes or no) :
- Did she say "When I come back, I want to do it in a big way!" ?
- Did she say "HELL YEAH! Of course. I think you have to believe it and be confident in anything you want. So of course I believe that. It might take a few years, but I think I’ll do it again " when she was asked "Do you think you’ll sell another 15M records ?" ?
- Did she say "I definitely plan on touring, I think that's really important as an artist. It would have to be meticulously planned" when she was asking about touring ?
All I did was quoting these three statements nothing more and nothing less.
I still don't see the relation but why wouldn't I point it out ?! WTH she said it not me !
I think when we want to know what somebody was planning to do we rely on their plans before doing that thing... More concretely, if we want to know what was Hilary intending to do with her comeback we have to use her statements before the release of BIBO otherwise it would make no sense. |
I'm not even gonna respond to all of this because you're clearly set in your ways and we're just gonna go around in circles. But I will say this: You responded to QueenBea's post with those quotes for a reason. It doesn't matter if you clearly stated your opinion or not, the implications were there and it was transparent what you were doing. You knew exactly what you were implying, stop playing dumb now.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/2/2014
Posts: 2,978
|
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D
I'm not even gonna respond to all of this because you're clearly set in your ways and we're just gonna go around in circles. But I will say this: You responded to QueenBea's post with those quotes for a reason. It doesn't matter if you clearly stated your opinion or not, the implications were there and it was transparent what you were doing. You knew exactly what you were implying, stop playing dumb now.
|
You're the one looking dumb right now though.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/6/2012
Posts: 8,413
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DuffStan
You're the one looking dumb right now though.
|
Please explain... You said some stuff upthread involving me, but you grouped me together with Duffaholic & Right Now, as if we share the EXACT same opinions. But I'd like to know what I said specifically that you take issue with...
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/2/2014
Posts: 2,978
|
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D
Please explain... You said some stuff upthread involving me, but you grouped me together with Duffaholic & Right Now, as if we share the EXACT same opinions. But I'd like to know what I said specifically that you take issue with...
|
What's annoying me is that you're refusing to accept the fact that Yasin isn't stubborn and lazy like you're calling him. He brought you facts, yet you're still refusing to address them.
"When it comes to Hilary, we should use her more recent quotes to back up what we're saying, instead of using ones from the AAY era, when she was clearly more excited about the music."
Here are more recent quotes from her ( July 2015, AFTER the release of BIBO):
Quote:
"Yes, I will tour. It took me so long to make my record because it wasn't where it needed to be. When I started making the record, I wasn't like, "I have to get it out at this time"; I was like, "It's gotta be right - after seven years, why be in a rush now?"
[...]
I'll shoot from September until December and then I'll tour after Christmas."
"I think it'll be a world tour. I don't know if I can set it up like how I used to for five months at a time. Obviously my child is my number one priority, but I think I can do a month at a time and then come back and then go back out for a month. And it'll have to be a world tour because some of my biggest markets are in South America and Australia and Asia, so we'll see. No promises, but that's what I want to happen."
|
Source: http://www.pridesource.com/article.html?article=72139
She obviously WANTED to tour, before and after releasing BIBO yet she hasn't. Is it Younger? Is it her laziness? Is it both?
Luca is turning four this year, she needs to stop acting like she's the only mom in the world cos she's not. And we all know how hard it is, for working and non-working moms and dads. So she can keep her rich bitch problems to herself. Nobody is asking her to leave Luca for months, we're barely asking for a show in her major markets!
Also, what about that tour feature on her website? Are y'all gonna ignore that too?
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/5/2014
Posts: 9,550
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DuffStan
What's annoying me is that you're refusing to accept the fact that Yasin isn't stubborn and lazy like you're calling him. He brought you facts, yet you're still refusing to address them.
"When it comes to Hilary, we should use her more recent quotes to back up what we're saying, instead of using ones from the AAY era, when she was clearly more excited about the music."
Here are more recent quotes from her ( July 2015, AFTER the release of BIBO):
Source: http://www.pridesource.com/article.html?article=72139
She obviously WANTED to tour, before and after releasing BIBO yet she hasn't. Is it Younger? Is it her laziness? Is it both?
Luca is turning four this year, she needs to stop acting like she's the only mom in the world cos she's not. And we all know how hard it is, for working and non-working moms and dads. So she can keep her rich bitch problems to herself. Nobody is asking her to leave Luca for months, we're barely asking for a show in her major markets!
Also, what about that tour feature on her website? Are y'all gonna ignore that too?
|
This is why we compare her to other celeb moms who work 3 times as hard as her. Why can't y'all accept the fact the she doesn't wanna work and is just being lazy? but continue with "queen!!!111 xD is slaying with her candids".
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/3/2014
Posts: 693
|
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D
I'm not even gonna respond to all of this because you're clearly set in your ways and we're just gonna go around in circles. But I will say this: You responded to QueenBea's post with those quotes for a reason. It doesn't matter if you clearly stated your opinion or not, the implications were there and it was transparent what you were doing. You knew exactly what you were implying, stop playing dumb now.
|
Ah so you finally admit that I just quoted Hilary and didn't add any word on what she said. If you have any problem with these quotes please resolve it with Hilary.
When I think that all this hysteria wave was provoked by quotes from Hilary herself, what if I expressed my personal opinion ? 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/2/2014
Posts: 2,978
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Alien.
This is why we compare her to other celeb moms who work 3 times as hard as her. Why can't y'all accept the fact the she doesn't wanna work and is just being lazy? but continue with "queen!!!111 xD is slaying with her candids".
|
Let's not forget she's ONLY 28. They're all acting like she's 48 with 5 Grammys and an Oscar.
She hasn't even proven herself yet. It's really embarrassing at this point. Do you think radio will still play in her thirties? She's not getting any more roles you guys, she's turning down everything and y'all know that.
Heck, even Haylie is more active than she is right now! Her RGK projects are doing so well and she's currently filming a movie! What is Hilary doing? She wasted her 20s. Do you get what we're talking about or you still wanna act dumb?
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/6/2012
Posts: 8,413
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DuffStan
What's annoying me is that you're refusing to accept the fact that Yasin isn't stubborn and lazy like you're calling him. He brought you facts, yet you're still refusing to address them.
"When it comes to Hilary, we should use her more recent quotes to back up what we're saying, instead of using ones from the AAY era, when she was clearly more excited about the music."
Here are more recent quotes from her ( July 2015, AFTER the release of BIBO):
Source: http://www.pridesource.com/article.html?article=72139
She obviously WANTED to tour, before and after releasing BIBO yet she hasn't. Is it Younger? Is it her laziness? Is it both?
Luca is turning four this year, she needs to stop acting like she's the only mom in the world cos she's not. And we all know how hard it is, for working and non-working moms and dads. So she can keep her first world problems to herself. Nobody is asking her to leave Luca for months, we're barely asking for a show in her major markets!
Also, what about that tour feature on her website? Are y'all gonna ignore that too?
|
I'm not ignoring them. I wouldn't have been referring to them as "quotes" this whole time if I was ignoring them. Yes she did say those things, but don't twist her words to make her seem like she only cares about her chart performance and how much she sells.
I think literally EVERYONE in this base is disappointed in her for not following through with the tour, so that's not a very good example, sis. I've specifically said that she's fickle and that's frustrating. I just don't see a need to twist her words (Yasin) or bash her (You said that you hated her, that she's not a good actress, can't sing live, etc.)
You must exhaust yourself with all that negativity.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/5/2014
Posts: 9,550
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DuffStan
Let's not forget she's ONLY 28. They're all acting like she's 48 with 5 Grammys and an Oscar.
She hasn't even proven herself yet. It's really embarrassing at this point. Do you think radio will still play in her thirties? She's not getting any more roles you guys, she's turning down everything and y'all know that.
Heck, even Haylie is more active than she is right now! Her RGK projects are doing so well and she's currently filming a movie! What is Hilary doing? She wasted her 20s. Do you get what we're talking about or you still wanna act dumb?
|
Yeah, it's really sad that she wasted all of her 20's doing nothing with her career. Those Disney girls didn't need breaks and are killing the game.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/6/2012
Posts: 8,413
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Alien.
This is why we compare her to other celeb moms who work 3 times as hard as her. Why can't y'all accept the fact the she doesn't wanna work and is just being lazy? but continue with "queen!!!111 xD is slaying with her candids".
|
You do that too tho
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/3/2014
Posts: 693
|
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D
I'm not ignoring them. I wouldn't have been referring to them as "quotes" this whole time if I was ignoring them. Yes she did say those things, but don't twist her words to make her seem like she only cares about her chart performance and how much she sells.
I think literally EVERYONE in this base is disappointed in her for not following through with the tour, so that's not a very good example, sis. I've specifically said that she's fickle and that's frustrating. I just don't see a need to twist her words (Yasin) or bash her (You said that you hated her, that she's not a good actress, can't sing live, etc.)
You must exhaust yourself with all that negativity.
|
When did I twist her words if I was just quoting her ?! You keep talking about "twisting her words" who twisted her words ?!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/2/2014
Posts: 2,978
|
Quote:
Originally posted by MikeyDuff1D
I'm not ignoring them. I wouldn't have been referring to them as "quotes" this whole time if I was ignoring them. Yes she did say those things, but don't twist her words to make her seem like she only cares about her chart performance and how much she sells.
I think literally EVERYONE in this base is disappointed in her for not following through with the tour, so that's not a very good example, sis. I've specifically said that she's fickle and that's frustrating. I just don't see a need to twist her words (Yasin) or bash her (You said that you hated her, that she's not a good actress, can't sing live, etc.)
You must exhaust yourself with all that negativity.
|
Yeah, I'm more exhausted than Hilary Duff right now
|
|
|
|
|
|
