Highest Score: 8 (vinKC) Lowest Score: 0 (Pluto, Regina George, TheoJuke, Toysoldier99, MP2K, Subomie, Great Username)
The Consensus
"A bit too on-the-nose. People on drugs don’t need to be told what it’s like; people who aren’t on drugs probably have better music to listen to." - supaspaz
My Thoughts: It's really weird that this album, Make Believe, was the one to truly break Weezer out into the mainstream rock universe. It's biggest single, Beverly Hills, is terrible, but this is just so middle of the road? Not even in a good way, like Perfect Situation. It's telling that only two people commented on it, and no one gave it a ten.
Highest Score: 9 (Morris) Lowest Score: 0 (Pluto, Regina George, Toysoldier99, MP2K, jqnetto, Great Username, Red)
The Consensus
"I wish I could give this a negative rating." - Red
"Gross ...makes me think of middle school girls with too much mascara and eyeliner, talking about giving themselves papercuts to feel alive. Gurl please." - Starmie
"I’m so confused. I thought we left Papa Roach behind in, like, 2002?" - supaspaz
My Thoughts: I remain ... puzzled at how far behind the tastes are of the usual YTT/rock loving Latinos that populate the ATRL Top 50s are. I mean, Papa Roach is some 2000 ****. I felt this way when I compiled this list in 2006! It starts off alright, then gets terrible so quickly!