|
Official Rate the American Idol Thread! (Season 6)
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 2/21/2005
Posts: 21,684
|
01 Jordin - A+
Another perfect performance by her.
02 Melinda - A
Good as always, but not as good as Jordin.
03 Blake - B+
Not my favorite performance from him but I liked it
04 Lakisha - B+
I think she is in danger this week. Damn busy signals.
05 Chris - C
Way better than last week, he needs to be eliminated anyways.
06 Phil - C
It was kinda boring, he can do better than that.
Should be bottom 3: Phil, Chris, and Lakisha
Will be bottom 3: Phil, Lakisha, and Blake
Should go home: Chris
Will go home: Lakisha
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/6/2004
Posts: 6,276
|
Oh, I HOPE to God that none of the black girls will go. It pisses me off, though, because LaKisha is BETTER than Fantasia BY FAR, but the judges were like, 'You didn't sing FANTASIA'S song better than FANTASIA'...Well, Duh. Personally, however, I thought it WAS better than Fantasia's version.
I really hope Chris, Phil, or Blake goes home.
Should Be Bottom 3: Chris, Phil, Jordin (I thought she's done better...)
Will Be Bottom 3: Phil, LaKisha, Chris
Should Go Home: Chris
Will Go Home: Phil or LaKisha
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Jordin - 10 - omg
Blake - 10 - Amazing, best male performance ever on Idol.
Melinda - 9.7 - Her best performance. Probably the best live singer ever.
LaKisha - 9.3 - Miles better than Fantasia. Probably as good as Diana.
Chris - 8.8 - It was very good, but not as great as last week. Song choice could've been better.
Phil - 8.6 - I loved it, awesome song. Nicely sung.
Should be bottom 3: LaKisha, Chris, Phil
Should go home: Phil
Will be bottom 3: Phil, Chris, Blake
Will go home: Chris
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/14/2004
Posts: 82
|
1. Blake
2. Phil
3. Chris
4. Melinda
5. LaKisha
6. Jordin
Should Go home - LaKisha & Melinda
Will Go home - LaKisha & Chris
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/30/2002
Posts: 3,522
|
This is gonna be tough. And why didn't anybody sing "It's My Life?"
1. Phil
2. Lakisha
3. Blake
4. Chris
5. Melinda
6. Jordin
Should go Home: ehhh, Chris and Jordin
Will go home: Lakisha and Phil
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/25/2001
Posts: 7,563
|
1. Blake (10/10) perfect
2. Lakisha (9/10) I never like her but tonight she was fantastic.
3. Melinda (8.5/10) Great but a tad yelly. But that's a rock thing anyway. I thought she did a great job performing and I loved it.
4. Phil (7.5/10) Not really memorable...but good otherwise
5. Jordin (7/10) It was rough but not as bad as the judges were making it out to be. I loved her look and the higher notes were great.
6. Chris (5/10) Didn't enjoy it at all.
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 2/21/2005
Posts: 21,684
|
I thought it was gonna be a horrible night, but it turned out really good.
01 Lakisha - A+
It was her best performance ever, she just can't go home this week.
01 Blake - A+
Also my favorite performance from him, it was so different and original.
03 Phil - A
It was great and his best, it proved he has the best male voice in the competition.
04 Melinda - B+
Another great performance by her, for some reason I didn't like her as much as other times.
05 Jordin - B
I knew she was not gonna do as good as always.
06 Chris - C-
Please, go home. There is room for only one Justin Timberlake. Ryan
Should be bottom 3: Chris, Phil, and Melinda
Will be bottom 3: Phil, Jordin and Chris
Should go home: Phil and Chris
Will go home: Phil and Chris
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
01. LaKisha - 10/10, My god, she finally pulled off an amazing performance. There is no way she can go after that. One of the best of the season.
02. Jordin - 9/10, Rough verses, orgasmic choruses. Another good week.
03. Melinda - 8/10, Good but not amazing.
04. Phil - 8/10, One of his best.
05. Blake - 7/10, Pretty good.
06. Chris - 4/10, Ouch, he really butchered it with over singing.
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
There are many ways to break my heart. One involves a Bon Jovi night, since I dislike Bon Jovi. The second is the dual elim, which ruins the tradition that performer 2 on Top 5 night goes home.
Anyways, 6 do-overs
LaKisha (8/10) You dressed, as Kaos phrased it to me although Nick totally said it first and was all ****y delicious about it, probably , like a cherry-flavored Oreo. That's the sole complaint coming from me, as you just took that song and sang the **** out of it. Perfectly controlled, sold well, great pitch. Too bad ya going home anyways, but way to go out.
Melinda (7/10) I love Melinda trying to be all badass. The vocal was not fantastic (it was still Melinda good ^_^) but she sold the song better than anyone would expect and the badass act was well served. *Prays she's not a shocker of an elim*
Blake (6/10) THE **** DID YOU DO TO YOUR HEAD?!?!?!?! You look like a very butch ****. The vocal nonsense needed to stop as does the arm things. I know you can barely sing, although your vocal actually worked here, but it was everything else that made me annoyed.
Phil (4/10) Once again, he can't start a song. But for the first time ever, he fixed it right away. He clearly has done this enough in the bar scene to fix it. He actually sold it rather well. This could be interesting to see if the overpraise will be deleted once we get the shocking boot so the vamp can be a villain.
Jordin (2/10) Got the dreaded 2 slot and would normally be nixed anyways on normal Top 5. And she got the double musicians and Sanjy hair. Weird phrasing and less connected than even on "Hey Baby" which was sorta rough. SHUT. UP. DURING. JUDGES. COMMENTARY.
C.Richardson (0/10) Wow, he sounds girlier than I do when talking (damn that high pitch voice I has >_<). The less said about the vocal would be better but I will say he avoided the JT impersonation, which highlighted how flat his voice is. I really wish your punkass would go home.
Should be last 3: Chris, Jordin, Phil
Shall be last 3: Lakisha, Phil, Melinda
Should be gone: Chris and Jordin. Sorry, the faves need to go. Plus they sucked ass anyways.
Will be thrown off a cliff: LaKisha and...I have no idea. I'd say Chris but 19E would be panicked for a replacement Chosen Runner Up for Princess Jordin. I'm going with the shocker and say Melinda. I doubt it, but I could really see any but Crown Princess Jordin going.
Oh, Jordin getting all neg comments? It's testing her fan base which means she got enough votes last week they are unconcerned with her leaving. But if she polls bad this time, expect speed recovery for BeeGee's night.
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/25/2001
Posts: 7,563
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mikal
LaKisha (8/10) You dressed, as Kaos phrased it, like a cherry-flavored Oreo.
|
He's actually a biter, and I said that while I was watching it.
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Blake 9.9 Very cool. One of his best.
Melinda 9.6 She rocked it. Awesome performance.
Chris 9.5 Amazing. He can teach Daughtry a thing or two.
LaKisha 9.3 Nice controlled belting. Very good.
Jordin 9.1 I loved it. Especially her screeching.
Phil 8.8 Very good, but still worst of the night.
Overall:
1. Melinda - 9.38
2. Blake - 9.24
3. Jordin - 9.06
4. Chris - 8.85
5. LaKisha - 8.63
6. Phil - 8.19
Should go: LaKisha and Phil
Will go: Chris and LaKisha
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Nick
He's actually a biter, and I said that while I was watching it.
|
I edited mah comments for ya
And I wonder, seriously, if the inside of Kworb's all goth metal and Utada head there's a very special pink princess room where he and Paula talk about how cute Chris is and such.
Said with love, of course, for Kworby is, to me, love
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Just listen to Chris' last growl.. aliiiiiiive.. so cool
It doesn't sound fake like when Daughtry did it
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
I've already watched the show twice now, and before the results tonight I'm going to watch it for a 3rd time. (All within 24 hours!) I've really enjoyed Bon Jovi week.
$70 million dollars from Idol Gives Back all going to those in need. Great Job People!! That's HUGE! I'm glad to see my contribution made it in. ^__^!!!!
Blake - That was a cool and original performance. I was hoping to hear him Beat-box, which he delivered + more. He immediately had me when he put the record on. I loved it.
Melinda - I think she could've had a stronger song choice, but this was swell enough. I really liked her rendition of The odds were against her and she kicked ass. She was also intresting to watch, I really like her personality. (Oh...is it supposed to go like this? *Holds up Rock on sign backwards*...)
Phil - ...Votefortheworst.com (which is washed up + desperate currently with three strikes out of this season's competition - Antonella, Sundance, and Sanjaya.) picked a good candidate to root for even though he can sing and is better than Sanjaya. He nailed "Blaze of Glory," and probably gave his best performance yet this season.
4th Place = Jordin - I don't think it was as bad as the judges said. I thought it was decent, but she could've picked a bigger and better song. Even though she wanted an upbeat song, I think Jordin should've stuck her neck out and did "Always." It would've been a vocal obstacle for her, but I think it would've really locked her into the top 3 if she nailed it.
4th place = Lakisha - First half of the performance = Good-OK, but nothing more. Second half = But I don't think this was not enough to make up for last week, w/a smooch from Simon or not. She's a likely person to be going home tonight.
6th place = Chris - I thought he did fair with what he had to work with, but Dead or Alive wasn't really for him. If he goes tonight, it'll be death by song choice with some notice about his kinda-annoying vocals. At the same time, he put himself at some sort of risk, because people are going to compare him to Chris Daughtry from last year who absolutely killed w/ his performance and still has the best cover of this classic to date.
Last place - George and Laura Bush - ...Was Bill Clinton & maybe some other ACTUAL President/famous representative that busy? I didn't hear a warm ovation when their faces were shown.
Best Judge - Simon, especially after what we saw him doing and promoting last week.
How I see tonight going:
Top 2 = Blake and Melinda
Middle 2 = Jordin and Phil
Bottom 2 = Chris and Lakisha
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/22/2004
Posts: 2,991
|
I don't know if anyone posted this here yet, but it's been confirmed that Robin Thicke will be performing on American Idol tonight.
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Quote:
Originally posted by dianasguy
I don't know if anyone posted this here yet, but it's been confirmed that Robin Thicke will be performing on American Idol tonight.
|
More group performances, less washed up celebs plz
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/1/2005
Posts: 12,107
|
Wow, Kworbo always overpraises Chris and he doesn't even like Justin Timberlake.
Anyways, I don't think Jordin's performance was bad enough to see an upset, as they had to combine votes from last week. Chris is a goner and as far as the 2nd slot, let's hope it's Phil, but it might just be Lakisha. = /
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/14/2007
Posts: 6,202
|
Here are my performance ranks (in no particular order) (Last week in parenthesis)
Melinda 8/10 (LW 9/10)- Usual good performance, but she will never win.
Phil 9/10 (LW 4/10)- Much improved over last weeks performance. It might just keep him in the competition.
Jordin -3/10 (LW 9/10)- Yes thats a negative 3. It was just terrible this week. However she did well enough last week to keep her in the competition.
Chris 5/10 (LW 5/10)- Just average. Nothing special. He never was.
Blake 10/10 (LW 8/10)- He may just win it all.
Lakisha- 4/10 (LW 6/10)- Didn't really care for it.
Averages of both weeks: (in order)
Blake 9
Melinda 8.5
Phil 6.5
Chris 5
Lakisha 5
Jordin 3 (but like I said, she will survive and will go to the final 2 with Blake)
Going home:
Chris and Lakisha (both deserve to go. Neither can ever win)
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 11/16/2004
Posts: 28,450
|
1) Blake (+2)
2/3) Jordin (=/-1)
2/3) Melinda (-1/-2)
4) Lakisha (+1)
5) Chris R (-1)
6) Gina (+1)
7) Stephanie (+1)
8) Haley (+1)
9) Phil (-3)
10) Chris S (=)
11) Brandon (=)
12) Sanjaya (=)
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 2/21/2005
Posts: 21,684
|
Overall
01 Jordin
02 Blake
03 Lakisha
04 Melinda
----------
05 Haley
06 Phil
07 Chris R.
08 Gina
09 Stephanie
10 Sanjaya
11 Chris S.
12 Brandon
|
|
|
|
|