|
Rate the American Idols: Season 5!
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
Used the last few weeks' performances to rank:
1) Chris – (Best)
2) Mandisa
3) Elliott
4) Katharine
5) Paris
6) Lisa
7) Ace
8) Taylor
9) Kellie
10) Bucky
11) Melissa
*GAP*
12) Kevin – (Worst)
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/19/2003
Posts: 3,226
|
this is based soley on how much i like them overall, voice & character!
01. KATHARINE - i want her to win, love the voice!!!
02. CHRIS - he's really good if he wins i wouldnt mind either
03. KELLIE - sorry i think shes cool, she needs a show
04. MANDISA - great talent
05. LISA - straight hair is enough to be in top 5, the rest talent lol
06. PARIS - very great talent also
07. MELISSA - adds a little variety into the show
08. TAYLOR - he's pretty good not too fond though
09. ACE - he annoys me with the falsettos
10. ELLIOTT - really good voice but i dunno just not into him
11. BUCKY - seems really nice guy but i just dont like him
12. KEVIN - please go away now!!!
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/30/2002
Posts: 3,522
|
Stevie Wonder...haha loved it
No comments...
1. Chris - Loved the twist he put on the song. Agreed with Simon, could be major at rock radio.
2. Katharine - Kelly Clarkson in the making?
3. Lisa - Stepped it up! NEEDS to stick to uptempo songs.
4. Taylor - Great performance.
5. Paris - Hair was F'd up..but I'll give it up for her...she did a good job.
6. Mandisa - Best of the first half of the show.
7. Elliott - Has a great voice, but doesn't really do anything on stage. No personality.
8. Melissa - Who cares if she forgot the words? One of Melissa's best performances, IMO. I hope she's safe from bottom 3.
9. Kellie - A favorite of mine, but HORRIBLE tonight.
10. Bucky - I was looking so forward to Superstition, and he ruined it.
11. Ace - CANNOT sing.
12. Kevin - Kevin, you're the man, but singing is not meant for you. And I love Part Time Lover.
Should be bottom 3: Kevin, Ace, Bucky
Should be going home: Kevin
Will be bottom 3: Kevin, Melissa, Bucky
Will be going home: Kevin
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
Not in the mood for something very elaborate. I'll just comment on a few, but everyone from 1-9 actually did pretty well tonight.
1) Katharine
2) Mandisa
3) Paris
4) Chris
5) Elliot
6) Melissa - Even those she forgot part of the lyrics, I thought she did well. Well enough to be in the top half (I know I'll get a ton of disagreements from those who are spiteful towards her just because they showed her with Ayla when Ayla got her humungous ass booted off)
7) Lisa - Does anyone else notice her consistancy to be flat the whole time?
8) Ace
9) Bucky - I expected much worse.
---
10) Kevin - I feel awkward watching him perform, or just in general.
11) Taylor - There is no way you could convince me that he's 29.
12) Kellie
Leave: Kellie or Taylor
Goodbye: Bucky or Melissa
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
01. Melissa - 10/10, not just becuz shes my fave, she gave a great performance. She looked fantastic too. She resembled Kelly Clarkson a ton tonight! I loved her runs and the power notes that she gave.
02. Chris - 10/10, I didn't know that was a Stevie song either. Anyways he did great with it.
03. Mandisa - 9.5/10, She did pretty good. Not the best song, but her power vocals were simply amazing.
04. Paris - 9/10, She did a great job with the song. I like her better with the long pigtails though. Short hair makes ehr liek liek shes about 37 instead of 17.
05. Lisa - 8/10, For the first time I liked her. She was flatting a lot but pulled it together.
06. Katharine - 8/10, I love the song, but wrong choice for her. A sultry soul voice belongs on it. Katharine sharped a lot on the high notes. But it was good.
07. Elliot - 8/10, It was good. Last note was really good. All he needs is braces though. He kinda looks like Adam Sandler.
08. Kellie - 6/10, Well she sang it okay. Kinda boring. She kept building up to a climax that never happened. Fake eyelashes feel like tarantulas? Wtf is she talking about. haha
09. Ace - 5/10, err it was okay. Probably his worst to date.
10. Taylor - 5/10, Having on stage seizures isn't talent. He sang it alright, but I hate him.
11. Bucky - 3/10, Screwed a good song. He looks awful and needs to go.
12. Kevin - 2/10, Oh Jesus, Why does Chicken Little even try? He sang it alright, but the performance was horrible.
Should Be Bottom 3 - Kevin, Bucky, and Taylor
Should Be Bottom 2 - Kevin & Bucky
Should Go Home - Kevin
Will Be Bottom 3 - Bucky, Kevin, & Melissa
Will Be Bottom 2 - Bucky & Kevin
Will Go Home - Bucky
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 1/5/2002
Posts: 11,088
|
1. taylor (great song!)
2. katharine (amazing)
3. melissa (i loved the ending!!)
4. mandisa (wish she picked a better song, but still love her)
5. chris (didnt like the song, but he's still awesome)
6. elliot (best so far of him)
7. lisa (her best, a bit boring, but better)
8. kellie (really bad, kellie can't shut up can she? omg her trancular thing ^+^)
9. bucky (sucks)
10. paris (stfu, stop singing, you aren't a godness or a princess. the judges just pimp you because of your grandmother and they want another fantasia as the winner that could be more successful because fantasia made them no money.)
11. ace (go away. you aren't hot, you can't sing. leave!)
12. kevin (worst ever. you are no sex symbol. you aren't sexy. and thanks for ruining my song.)
b3: bucky, kevin, melissa
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/6/2005
Posts: 17,088
|
1. Taylor
He's SO excited and into music. This is what I want to see. I'm like Simon and I know what's good and isn't good, so if I seem to have the same opinions, it's because I USUALLY, which is like 99% of the time, agree with him. Awesome Taylor ^___^
2. Katharine
Well no doubt she looked absolutely gorgeous. On top of that she sang wonderfully, and she has awesome stage presence. She's got it all guyzzzzzzz.
3. Lisa
Love this girl and I love this song. The go perfectly together. She's so stunning and has an AWESOME voice, even though she didn't fully showcase it tonight. I think she sang it and gave it a lot of effort.
4. Mandisa
Awww. She didn't do a BAD job, I mean come on, she's f.uckin amazing! But, Mandisa didn't pull it off because, I know she has more of a range than I saw tonight. Not too shabby, though!
5. Paris
Okay, SHE seemed a bit robotic. She was pretty good though. Did anyone else notice how she bobbed her head like, side to side, like a lunatic, 10 times or so? Regardless, Paris has got potential and I really like the song choice. She's so talented, hope she steps up her game in the weeks to come.
6. Melissa
She was actually pretty good tonight, no matter what you guys say. She has a good voice, a bit flat at times but all in all, I thought Melissa looked amazing tonight and sang decent. Overall average performance.
7. Chris
Well, I didn't think it was amazing. I mean, part of the reason this is so low is because I lost so much respect for him. He talks about how he heard this from the Red Hot Chili Peppers and was 'glad to see that it was a Stevie song'. That's repulsive beyond belief. And it WASN'T that good at a second glance when they re-reviewed the performanced tonight.
8. Elliot
Elliot wasn't that good tonight. First of all, get your damn teeth fixed. AGH! It's scary! Second of all, if you've got a range, and have gotten very good compliments in the past, I don't know why he tried to play it safe. I KNOW he's got more than that. He's the best male singer on here and he's so much better than tonight. He'll stay on though, duh.
9. Ace
This is disgusting beyond belief. If you like him for his looks, okay, that'll keep him on, but boy oh boy, he was terrible tonight. Terrible song choice. He'll be gone soon enough if he doesn't choose a good song. Maybe tonight was just bad. Maybe everyone will be a lot better next week, hopefully.
9-12. Bucky, Kevin, Kellie (in any order, Kellie still #13)
YOU GUYS ARE SO F.UCKING TERRIBLE AGH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NO COMMENT
Should be going home tomorrow night: Kellie (EW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)
Will be: Bucky
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2004
Posts: 2,787
|
omg tina you dont like kellie now?
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
Stevie Wonder rules!
Ace –I didn’t care for him vocally; he was kinda off half the time, but did manage to use the stage to his advantage. But knowing the appeal Ace exudes, he’ll pass this week
Kellie – Ehhh… not so good. She sang it way too safe. This was several steps down from last week, this girl looked really nervous. At least she held her own charm.
Elliot – I like this guy more and more, as the weeks go on; seeing him with Stevie was really cool. As for his performance: Did an OK job tonight. Nothing didn’t really strike me till the last note, and he looked nervous as well.
Mandisa – Started slow but worked up to show her high vocals. Really wasn’t impressed with her performance either. Mandisa was the best out of the 1st third of the 12 contestants that performed tonight. I also saw some nerves going off in her as well, and taking off the shoes helped her out when it came to that.
Bucky – Did all right tonight, he held his ground. Right song choice, but he could’ve moved around some more on stage. I also think he would’ve benefited if he just would’ve hit a high note. Other then that, it was all good, and he had fun.
Melissa – Uh oh, messed up the lyrics in front of a big music icon. ‘~’… Melissa did well tonight, especially towards the end. This was her best performance yet, and I’d like to see her go onto next week.
Lisa – Signed, sealed, delivered wasn’t that great of a song choice for her. Reuben Studdard has had the best rendition of the song. Lisa really didn’t spark until the last note for me; if she didn’t have that, the judges would’ve been negative towards her. I just didn’t care for her voice with that song, but it was OK.
Kevin – Gideon, we could’ve used you this week. Yep, I was expecting nerves, and he had them with Stevie. As for his performance, it was karaoke and ugly. Let’s get this straight: The only thing that’s getting him by in this competition is his personality. With that, he probably bought himself another week with his comment towards Simon at the end. `_` (Even though Simon was just being truthful.) At least he’s gained some confidence…
Katherine – Wow, you could hear the potential in her voice during her session with Wonder. Had some nerves, but she sounded great tonight. I liked it, best yet. And being compared to Kelly Clarkson? That’s a big compliment. I look forward to her next week.
Taylor – He had another usual performance, while having a lot fun at it. I don’t like his singing voice, but he has had a tremendous amount of positive energy, which just might pull him for another few weeks.
Paris – Did great, excellent vocals, and also had fun this week. However, I think she should’ve done signed, sealed, delivered though, I think she would’ve done a number on it. Paris will at least be around for another few weeks guaranteed.
Chris – He should’ve smashed the microphone stand; that would’ve been cool. (You could see that he wanted to towards the end.) He pulled off his rock element flawlessly. Chris not only did Wonder proud, but also the red Hot Chili Peppers. My favorite performance, once again.
1st Vote = Chris
2nd Vote = Katherine
3rd Vote = Bucky (So he doesn’t go home)
4th Vote = Melissa (So she doesn’t go home)
Worst = Kevin. (UH, D-UUUHHHHHHHHHH).
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/2/2004
Posts: 5,939
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Taste Like Fire
6) Melissa - Even those she forgot part of the lyrics, I thought she did well. Well enough to be in the top half (I know I'll get a ton of disagreements from those who are spiteful towards her just because they showed her with Ayla when Ayla got her humungous ass booted off)
|
You and your irrational hate for Ayla. You completely concocted bitchy image of her. She was a nice, intelligent and a well-rounded girl. And she was never once arrogant.
For shame.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mugshot
You and your irrational hate for Ayla. You completely concocted bitchy image of her. She was a nice, intelligent and a well-rounded girl. And she was never once arrogant.
For shame.
|
All I said was that she's humungous, which she is
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
Welcome to the 12 Colonies Of Assy Crap
Paris (9/10) GO AHEAD GIRL! Returned to the awesomeness of Week 1 and I for one could not be happier.
Mandisa (7/10) Couple rank held notes, and her outfit made her twice as broad. But otherwise I liked it.
Katharine (6/10) Who's more robotic, her or Lisa? Better than the last two weeks, and comming off Kevin, that's not hard too do.
Lisa (6/10) Now she shows personality by going all Vonzell. Still as robotic as Diana and Carrie were. Bad scream note.
Bucky (5/10) Flinching through the entire commercial break over him singing "Superstition." And while it wasn't as bad as expected, it was bland. However, for Bucky, that's an improvement. As is scalping Kellie and using her hair as a wig. Very bouncy and luxurious, that hair.
Elliot (5/10) Well, how nice. A theme built for Elliot (Stevie #3 for him). Weryedes? It's very middle-act of some musical of a song, with a lot of warblyness to cover that he can't hold a note.
Chris (4/10) Both an obvious choise and a workable one. And yet he did really bad on it. I can't decide what it was that did it in (maybe the obviousness of it all) but it was not good and a total cop-out.
Taylor (4/10) Can Michael McDonald sue over his impersonation? And can someone tie his legs together to keep him from movie? It's fine. Annoying, but fine.
Ace (3/10) Straining in the opener. Breathy boy-band nonsense. Recharge back to Jackson-lite. Oi.
Melissa (2/10) Bye Melissa! Shot voice never recovered, making her flat on a boring as hell song. Sorta did better on the second chorus, but not enough to sav a song with the ever-fateful "goodbye" prevalaent throughout.
Kellie (0/10) GO ON STEVIE! TEACH THE FAKE DUMB BITCH HOW TO SING! And more nasaly than...um...anything ever. Like, worse than all Pretty Pony Princesses ever. Flat and warbly and aggravating as always. AND GOD DAMN IT, STOP WITH THE "I'm a dumb bitchy country bumpkin" NONSENSE NOW.
Kevin (0/10) THE HELL IS WRONG WITH HIM? Is he not in on the the joke which is his performances? Horrible, flat, worse than some bad high school singing. Still looks unconfortable and AGH MY EARS! WHY WON'T YOU LET HIM GO! Especially after thinking being a jackass to Simon. Dumbass, YOU DID NOT WIN YET.
Should Be Bottom 3: Melissa, Kellie, Kevin
Will Be Bottom 3: Melissa, Kevin, Bucky
Should Get Gone: Kevin
Will Be Leaving Us: Melissa
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/19/2003
Posts: 3,226
|
01. katharine ............ she has to win, no exception!
02. taylor .................. wow i was never a fan, but he impressed me a lot
03. mandisa .............. always great, very consistent
04. paris ................... fun performance, good vocals
05. lisa ..................... good performance, but she really needs a song to shine soon
06. chris ................... my favorite guy, but it was an ok performance
07. melissa ............... wow i was actually surprise, she made it her own, good job
08. kellie ................... was very disappointed, that wasnt the kellie i like
09. elliot ................... was never really a fan, he was ok
10. bucky .................. it was his personal best i think but his best is not good enough
11. ace ..................... he is just starting to go down faster than a rock in my bock
12. kevin ................... to me he is just a loser who thinks he's all that now, go home!
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 1/5/2002
Posts: 11,088
|
Quote:
Originally posted by sammie
omg tina you dont like kellie now?
|
I mean, I LIKE her, but sometimes she's bit over the top and had a bad performance last nite.
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Paris: 8.5
Melissa: 8.0
Lisa: 7.8
Kellie: 7.5
Elliott: 7.3
Mandisa: 7.0
Ace: 6.0
Bucky: 5.5
Chris: 4.9
Taylor: 4.2
Kevin: 4.0
Katherine: 3.5
Top 12:
1. Paris: 33.8 (=)
2. Melissa: 30.3 (+1)
3. Lisa: 29.6 (+1)
4. Mandisa: 29.4 (-2)
5. Elliott: 26.4 (+3)
6. Kellie: 26.3 (+3)
7. Ace: 25.6 (=)
8. Chris: 24.6 (-2)
9. Katherine: 23.2 (-4)
10. Taylor: 19.7 (=)
11. Kevin: 17.7 (=)
12. Bucky: 17.1 (=)
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
1) Katharine
2) Paris
3) Mandisa
---
4) Elliot
5) Ace
6) Lisa
7) Chris - Lowered just because that performance was nothing but a cop-out
---
8) Bucky
9) Kevin
---
10) Kellie
11) Taylor
---
12) Melissa
13) Kinnik
14) Will
15) Becky
16) Stevie
17) Brenna
18) Gedeon
19) Sway
20) Patrick
21) Ayla
22) Heather
23) David
24) Bobby
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 11/16/2004
Posts: 28,450
|
1) Katharine (=)
2) Chris (=)
3) Mandisa (=)
4) Lisa (=)
5)Taylor (+3)
6) Paris (=)
7) Elliott (-2)
8) Ace (-1)
9) Kellie (=)
10) Bucky (+1)
11) Kevin (+1)
12) Melissa (-2)
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/1/2005
Posts: 12,107
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mugshot
You and your irrational hate for Ayla. You completely concocted bitchy image of her. She was a nice, intelligent and a well-rounded girl. And she was never once arrogant.
For shame.
|
Eric has it right.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
01. Mandisa
02. Paris
03. Chris
04. Elliot
05. Katharine
06. Ace
07. Lisa
08. Kellie
09. Bucky
10. Taylor
11. Kevin
12. Melissa
13. Becky
14. Kinnik
15. Ayla
16. Heather
17. Stevie
18. Brenna
19. Will
20. Gedeon
21. Sway
22. Patrick
23. David
24. Bobby
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/27/2002
Posts: 4,083
|
Honestly Kworb, how was Katharine's performance the worst of the night? Even Mikal thought it was decent.
|
|
|
|
|