Good choices
Gavin is going to love you for having Break In as one of your favorites haha.
Mine are
Halestorm:
1. I Get Off
2. Bet U Wish U Had Me Back
3. Familiar Taste Of Poison
4. It's Not You (the live version is my fav though)
5. Innocence.
Reanimate:
1. All I Wanna Do Is Make Love To You
2. Hunger Strike
3. I Want You
The Strange Case Of...
1. I Miss The Misery
2. Mz Hyde
3. In Your Room
4. Beautiful With You
5. Private Parts (deluxe track but just so amazing. Shouldn't have been just a bonus track)
And agreed about overall it changing for all time favorite. Right now here is my order on which I have been listening to the most.
1. Mz Hyde
2. Hunger Strike
3. In Your Room
4. Private Parts
5. Familiar Taste Of Poison