But the critics have praised both, so your argument isn't really weighted very much. If that is your only argument I don't see this thread going anywhere.
Frankly, I don't care how much you weigh my argument.
I'm sorry that you actually believe your approval makes a difference.
I'm just telling you the truth. I tried to brush it off the first few times, but you guys kept on twisting together statements I never made and reaching conclusions that were not actually based on logic, all the while claiming that I had some "flawed logic".
Anyways, I'm going to leave this here....
Okay Mr. Logician, here's your flaw. Sure, Taylor's work may be better acclaimed, but that doesn't mean she has more talent. It means the work she has released has been better (again, that is arguable because this is all based on opinion). But she's only released two albums. Kelly's been in this industry for more than a decade, with highs and lows, and she's still surprising us with new talents.
Also, stop being so hung up on the songwriting.
Kelly singing a song she didn't write, but emoting and just slaying lives:
Taylor singing a song she wrote, but it's just meh.
Kelly doesn't only just have a "good voice". She emotes powerfully. She owns the stage with her talent. Taylor can write songs but just can't perform them with the oomph they deserve. So maybe she should be a songwriter and let someone else do her songs justice. Or... idk, vocal lessons?
Frankly, I don't care how much you weigh my argument.
I'm sorry that you actually believe your approval makes a difference.
Well, judging from the poll, ATRL doesn't care much about The great Logician's arguments either, so maybe you should stop wasting your time?
Anyways, I'm out of this thread, I've stated my opinion. Kelly just has more talent, plain and simple. The Taylor stans aren't even giving Kelly's songwriting a chance because they are afraid it'll take away from Swift's credibility. They act like she's the best songwriter in the world and that automatically means that everyone else sucks.
Well, judging from the poll, ATRL doesn't care much about The great Logician's arguments, so maybe you should stop wasting your time?
Anyways, I'm out of this thread, I've stated my opinion. Kelly just has more talent, plain and simple. The Taylor stans aren't even giving Kelly's songwriting a chance because they are afraid it'll take away from Swift's credibility. They act like she's the best songwriter in the world and that automatically means that everyone else sucks.
Kelly is much better vocalist but Taylor's material is a lot better. In my opinion, artist's ultimate goal is to make great albums. So..
--
I vote for the one who can do what I can't do. A songwriter, performer, and musician too. And since talent is grown, not given, then Taylor Alison Swift.
I vote for the one who can do what I can't do. A songwriter, performer, and musician too. And since talent is grown, not given, then Taylor Alison Swift.
First and last post here. Bye.
I like Kelly a lot, but Taylor is an overall better musician. My opinion though.
Taigan- do not do too much with Taylor and her live vocals. If you really are a fan u know she has gotten really good lately. Oh, and as a fan u should know she has released 3 studio albums.
Taigan- do not do too much with Taylor and her live vocals. If you really are a fan u know she has gotten really good lately. Oh, and as a fan u should know she has released 3 studio albums.
Then post the best performance you can find and see if it comes anywhere close to Kelly's (not even her best performance). Somehow I have a feeling that it won't