Get Me Bodied, Single Ladies, Crazy In Love, End Of Time and others prove otherwise.
On all of the songs, she sings and she may move from side to side but her dancers does most of the work while she sings. IF she does try, she sings with prerecorded tracks when she dances. How do I know?? You NEVER hear the change in motion in her voice. Im not saying hear it break or sound bad, just the change in motion.
Please show me the vids where she does without a prerecorded track.
end of time... not simultaneously
run the world (starting @ 3min)...NOPE
after dancing and once she starts singing at 3:56 NOT LIVE VOCALS besides her inflections(track is playing in the back). Then starting @4:33-on she is clearly singing with a prerecorded track.
I love Bey and I think those are bad ass performances but lets be real here
Quote:
Originally posted by alkralkra
I agree, her dancing is not amazing, although it's better than most pop stars because they suck.
I think her dancing as an aspect of her performances, nothing more.
I agree. She isnt a sorry or bad dancer by any means though.
I've actually already made points why Beyoncé is a better musician in my earlier post. Also Cakingbey is right. Alicia's piano playing is nothing to run home about.
I wouldn't be surprised if Beyonce already knew how to play piano since most vocalist do know how to to some extent.
You have got to be kidding me.
I've officially seen it all on ATRL.
I do not and will not use Beyonce's music, it does nothing for me. But I can watch or listen to Alicia Keys all day. Girl is an amazing artist and she got SOOUUULLL!
On all of the songs, she sings and she may move from side to side but her dancers does most of the work while she sings. IF she does try, she sings with prerecorded tracks when she dances. How do I know?? You NEVER hear the change in motion in her voice. Im not saying hear it break or sound bad, just the change in motion.
Please show me the vids where she does without a prerecorded track.
end of time... not simultaneously
run the world (starting @ 3min)...NOPE
after dancing and once she starts singing at 3:56 NOT LIVE VOCALS besides her inflections(track is playing in the back). Then starting @4:33-on she is clearly singing with a prerecorded track.
I love Bey and I think those are bad ass performances but lets be real here
I agree. She isnt a sorry or bad dancer by any means though.
God no. Stop confusing being on key with her not dancing. She's WIDELY praised for being able to dance and sing simultaneously.
Her tour performances alone prove this. Even when she has a headset mic she's usually still singing. But the bitch is ALWAYS singing with a mic in her hand. Have you even seen her live??
+1.
It could be argued that Alicia is also more talented because she can play instruments but ultimately Beyonce's singing and performing outweigh Alicia's abilities.
Beyonce does NOT always sing live and dance at the same time, lol. Not trying to knock her talent, Because she's extremely talented, but she definetly pre records alot.
God no. Stop confusing being on key with her not dancing. She's WIDELY praised for being able to dance and sing simultaneously.
Her tour performances alone prove this. Even when she has a headset mic she's usually still singing. But the bitch is ALWAYS singing with a mic in her hand. Have you even seen her live??
PLEASE!!!! I know prerecording when I see it whether its in person or on the TV/ computer. If she does, please show me the receipts.
I like Bey but COME ON!!!!!
Quote:
Originally posted by Lasers
Beyonce does NOT always sing live and dance at the same time, lol. Not trying to knock her talent, Because she's extremely talented, but she definetly pre records alot.
THANK YOU!!!! You can clearly see it in the video. How are you gonna dip your head down and shake and not hear any change in voice?? Hell when you are standing still your voice changes and it damn sure does while dancing. Some of her fans just dont want to let that go because they cant use it against other artist then. I never noticed it until my older sister pointed it out to me when we were watching her Thanksgiving special a few years back.
Quote:
Originally posted by Rafael
I can't at a Rihanna stan starting this thread...
LOL!!! They know good and well that Rhianna couldnt even win a middle school talent contest.
Alicia....her live voice is
Even better than studio track in some performances.
She puts more of herself into her music....she creates art through music.
She plays piano really well.
Alicia wrote many songs only by herself.
Beyonce only co-writes her music.
Beyonce blows her out the water, frankly. Dissect all you like but Beyonce is just TEN TIMES more entertaining as an artist. Her voice, dancing and performing skills generally are on a different level.
Also, anybody can learn to play an instrument(it may take some longer than others). But can she play them as well as a top session musician? If not then she should concentrate on her singing and performing skills and let the better person do the music. They need the work. Plus being stuck at a piano just makes her even more boring to watch.
and Alicia's voice is well flat and shakey at times..
+1.
It could be argued that Alicia is also more talented because she can play instruments but ultimately Beyonce's singing and performing outweigh Alicia's abilities.