1. AshleeSimpsonFan - Carrie Underwood - So Small
2. $CBCOOL$ - Fantasia - When I See U
3. Strangergab - Kelly Clarkson - Sober
4. berberocka - Kelly Clarkson - Behind These Hazel Eyes
5. Mezik - Carrie Underwood - Cowboy Casanova
6. jone631 - Kelly Clarkson - Breakaway
7. supaspaz - Kelly Clarkson - Already Gone
8. mitchie22 - Jordin Sparks - One Step At A Time
9. josh_923 - Pia Toscano - This Time
10. Sin With A Grin - Daughtry - It's Not Over
11. Simon2011 - David Archuleta - Crush
12. Jimmy Tancredi - Kelly Clarkson - My Life Would Suck Without You
13.VOTE AGAIN HERE: Ray Bass - Jordin Sparks featuring Chris Brown - No Air
14. jbstatic23- Kris Allen- Live Like We're Dying
15. masaru.chesney - David Archuleta - A Little Too Not Over You
16. Nait Phoenix - Katharine McPhee - Over It
17. TheCircle94 - Kelly Clarkson - Since U Been Gone
18. RawrEmyro - Kelly Clarkson - Miss Independent
19. Mr Loko - Kelly Clarkson - Because Of You
20. Razzle - Daughtry - Over You
ELIMINATED: 21. ReginaGeorge - Carrie Underwood - Before he cheats
That was hard, I love both of those songs