Overrated by his fans, way, way, way underrated by ATRL+the GP.
His albums (besides the Christmas one) are liked by critics, he's produced, his vocals are good, his dancing is good, he can play 3 instruments well, etc.
She's hugely overrated on ATRL.
Weak singer + at the time she had singing career she used to lip sync regulary.
Mediocre discography (yeah, even Dignity).
Ungifted actress.
No charisma or star power whatsoever.
She's pretty, that's it.
Overrated on atrl... I don't ever really hear anyone mention her in real life. She was a cute child star but that's about it tbh. She's not that great of a singer or actress... but she's really sweet so