[iHype.]

Originally posted by halcyonday

Where is We Belong Together

In the same amount of countries as HU despite one 'being 50x more global'.

[Bey_Rihstan]

Originally posted by iC0NIC

http://kworb.net/itunes/artist/mariahcarey.html

Omg

Hung Up isn't there either so... your point?

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by Miracle Whip

We Belong Together - 127,619,042 views on YT

Hung Up - 58,559,725 views on YT

WBT is on VEVO let's not with this argument.

WBT is only more remembered in the US.

[iHype.]

So 11 pages in, and Madonna stans cling to 'GLOBAL!!11!' and haven't actually provided ONE receipt of COADF's singles being more listened to in 2015, because truth already proven -- TEOM's are.

Nothing new.

[halcyonday]

We Belong Together is more remembered in the US.
Hang Up is more remembered in Europe.

I think.

[Madonno]

Originally posted by iHype.

It's asking what's more MEMORABLE. As in 2015. Not what was done back in 2005. What's hard to understand?

Go find receipts of HU being more popular in 2015 instead. Would love to see that!

And Youtube views are receipts of more "memorable/iconic" song?
LOL.... I didn´t knew that the nowadays standars are youtube and spotifye.
Such a shame, sorry..

Recepits?

1. COADF more acclaimed than TEOM

2. Hung Up being playing in three of the most succeful concerts ever (2006-2013): Confessions Tour, S&S Tour and the MDNA Tour... together makes an attendance of 5.755.244 people and gross more than US$908 million.


And still Hung Up is less iconic/memorable than WBT. Mess

[Miracle Whip]

This thread isn't about who's more "GLOBAL!" it is about which is more remembered

WBT has higher views on YT

WBT has bigger streaming numbers

WBT also gets more recurrent airplay

WBT is CLEARLY the winner

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Starstruck.

WBT is on VEVO let's not with this argument.

WBT is only more remembered in the US.

And?



WBT also had 10x more views on Soundcloud from an unofficial fan page before the audio was taken down by the label.


WBT > HU in every listening service in 2015. Clearly it's more memorable. Acting as if HU being added to VEVO would make that 70M view gap close.

If it was 50x the hit globally, it should have more listeners globally. End of.

[Bey_Rihstan]

Originally posted by Madonno

And Youtube views are receipts of more "memorable/iconic" song?
LOL.... I didn´t knew that the nowadays standars are youtube and spotifye.
Such a shame, sorry..

You're getting it now!

[idkher]

http://comparemyradio.com/tracks/Madonna/Hung_Up
http://comparemyradio.com/tracks/mar...elong_Together

Not song of the decade also getting more recurrent airplay in the UK... Localriah strikes again

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Madonno

And Youtube views are receipts of more "memorable/iconic" song?
LOL.... I didn´t knew that the nowadays standars are youtube and spotifye.
Such a shame, sorry..

Recepits?

1. COADF more acclaimed than TEOM

2. Hung Up being playing in three of the most succeful concerts ever (2006-2013): Confessions Tour, S&S Tour and the MDNA Tour... together makes an attendance of 5.755.244 people and gross more than US$908 million.


And still Hung Up is less iconic/memorable than WBT. Mess

Yes, because YouTube is a Streaming Service. Both of them are pulling 0 sales currently, so it'd make sense to see who's being Streamed more.

YouTube, Soundcloud, Spotify, every popular Streaming service WBT had COUNTLESS times more listeners. Get real. Stop living in 2005 statistics for a thread asking memorability in 2015. It's messy.

[Miracle Whip]

Originally posted by idkher

http://comparemyradio.com/tracks/Madonna/Hung_Up
http://comparemyradio.com/tracks/mar...elong_Together

Not song of the decade also getting more recurrent airplay in the UK... Localriah strikes again

She's so "local"

[Madonno]

Originally posted by iHype.

Yes, because YouTube is a Streaming Service. Both of them are pulling 0 sales currently, so it'd make sense to see who's being Streamed more.

YouTube, Soundcloud, Spotify, every popular Streaming service WBT had COUNTLESS times more listeners. Get real. Stop living in 2005 statistics for a thread asking memorability in 2015. It's messy.

Sorry, but NO.
Youtube, Spotify and similars remains only in the internet.
The real world is outside the internet.
And outside the internet Hung Up is still being part on the most succeful tours ever, and the look alone is still being mentioned. If you gonna say that judge a song because the ammount of listener you're wrong. What the point when you may have the same person replaying a song more than once?

Receipts are real fact, and timeless.

[iHype.]

Originally posted by Madonno

Sorry, but NO.
Youtube, Spotify and similars remains only in the internet.

Sorry people talk about HU in real life, but nobody does on the internet? (Oh the logic).

[johnsuxx]

Originally posted by idkher

http://comparemyradio.com/tracks/Madonna/Hung_Up
http://comparemyradio.com/tracks/mar...elong_Together

Not song of the decade also getting more recurrent airplay in the UK... Localriah strikes again

[KatyLegendperry]

The fact that there are several people in this thread who think that WBT was Emancipation's lead single kinda speaks volumes.

Anyway;

Confessions on a Dance Floor
#8 Barbados
#107 Greece
#185 Sweden
#199 Finland

The Emancipation of Mimi
#114 Qatar

[ELECTRAHEARTPOP]

Just thought I'd say that before I joined ATRL I couldn't name a Mariah Carey song other than Hero and certainly had never heard of WBT, however I did know Hung Up (and have done since being a child).

I stan both and don't care about numbers but I think that says a lot about HU's reach WW/in Europe since I'm from the UK.

[UMS125]

Originally posted by ELECTRAHEARTPOP

Just thought I'd say that before I joined ATRL I couldn't name a Mariah Carey song other than Hero and certainly had never heard of WBT, however I did know Hung Up (and have done since being a child).

I stan both and don't care about numbers but I think that says a lot about HU's reach WW/in Europe since I'm from the UK.

this

[Miracle Whip]

Originally posted by ELECTRAHEARTPOP

Just thought I'd say that before I joined ATRL I couldn't name a Mariah Carey song other than Hero and certainly had never heard of WBT, however I did know Hung Up (and have done since being a child).

I stan both and don't care about numbers but I think that says a lot about HU's reach WW/in Europe since I'm from the UK.

I'm from the UK as well but I hear WBT more than HU

WBT also has bigger recurrent airplay in the UK despite HU being a #1

[ELECTRAHEARTPOP]

Originally posted by Miracle Whip

I'm from the UK as well but I hear WBT more than HU

WBT also has bigger recurrent airplay in the UK despite HU being a #1

I rarely hear HU (but I've definitely heard it before, on Heart specifically) but I have never heard WBT on the radio.

In the end I think:
WW: Hung Up
US: We Belong Together

/discussion