[Bounce]

Originally posted by ianBK4

Gurl take out Japan sales and ARTPOP did less than 1m WW.

It's not my fault my fav is GLOBAL!

[2014]

Originally posted by Harry

Mess at these little monsters so engaged in tiny things like Unc vs DWUW and missing the bigger picture - PRISM outsold ARTPOP and C2C combined, Katy accumulated almost 2 Billion YT views, performing at Superbowl, Billboard's Female Artist of The Year, PRISM Tour outselling ARTRAVE, etc, etc

We are missing the bigger picture? We all know Katy outsold Gaga this era. Like, why would we think otherwise?

Weren't you the one who asked a few minutes ago receipts showing DWUW outsold Uncle?

After I posted those receipts, weren't you the one who posted a link to an article that apparently says DWUW sold only 1.37M when in reality DWUW wasn't even mentioned in that article?

Embarrassing !!

[H-I-M]

Originally posted by ianBK4

Gurl take out Japan sales and ARTPOP did less than 1m WW.

Take out the US and there isn't much left of Beyoncé's career. Luckily both countries are part of the world.

[Dämon]

Originally posted by ianBK4

Gurl take out Japan sales and ARTPOP did less than 1m WW.

Gurl, take out all the WW sales expect Kenya and ARTPOP did less than 100 WW.

[Harry]

Don't forget this:



Lady Gaga
The Monster Ball - 227M
The Born This Way Ball - 184M (19% decline from the last tour)
ArtRave - 88M (52% decline from the last tour)

Katy Perry
The California Dreams Tour - 68M
PRISM Tour - 154M (127% increase)

[Bounce]

Originally posted by ianBK4

Beyoncé being over selling 3.7m WW, I want to know what the other one is...

Yeah we now Bey right now IS BIGGER than GaGa by a lot but outside of the US not that much, sorry!

[slw84]

Originally posted by Brinny Baby

Drunk in Love hasn't sold over 2 million in the US despite MASSIVE radio play, and it was the biggest hit of that era

7/11 is flopping in sales too.

Her last Billboard hit with respectable sales is from the last decade.

She's OVER on the Hot 100

I think she can get top 20s though.

Originally posted by H-I-M

The Hive will probably come back saying that people were too busy buying the album, forgetting the fact that 21 and 1989 had sold way more when they got their smash hits left and right.

She's also over in Europe.

My goodness...true Adele and taylor had album and single sales.

Originally posted by Raava

I also think Beyoncé's chart topping days are over. Didn't her re-release fail to score a hit with 7/11, when past re-releases by pop girls (such as The Fame Monster, Teenage Dream - The Complete Confection and Gone Girl Gone Bad: Reloaded) have scanned multiple smash hits?

True

Originally posted by H-I-M

When the lead single of an album that "changed the game" can't scan 2x platinum, you know there's something wrong.

Ruthless. Wow.

Originally posted by ianBK4

When you struggle after only 5 years of career, you know there's something wrong.

Ruthless. Wow.

Originally posted by LONGWAY2GO.

What transparency? beyonce hasn't had a legit hit since GaGa's Telephone, and Single Lady before that

Halo was a hit.

[Bounce]

Originally posted by Harry

Don't forget this:



Lady Gaga
The Monster Ball - 227M
The Born This Way Ball - 184M (19% decline)
ArtRave - 83M (55% decline)

Katy Perry
The California Dreams Tour - 68M
PRISM Tour - 154M (127% increase)

Of course you will increase since you weren't big in the first place lol

[Rainsford]

Originally posted by H-I-M

And Beyoncé's 10 quick singles/era failed to make people buy 4 and self titled outside the states.

Both 4 (a R&B album) and BEYONCÉ (an URBAN album) outsold ARTPOP worldwide. Beyoncé stays winning.

[darkhorse]

I can't remember when Beyoncé last had a hit tbh.

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by Starstruck.

The US is from Hits Daily Double
Italy
Sweden
The UK is an estimate since it was at 100k early last year

Not even including Canada and Australia

The only acceptable one is the italy one
There are no source for the other countries

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by 2014

Dear God. And I thought I was overreacting using size 4 for my text

I said :

But if you really wanna go there, fine :

DWUW :

US : 1,350,000
UK : 310,000
Canada : 100,000
South Korea : 70,000
Mexico : 60,000
Sweden : 50,000
France : 60,000
Germany : 50,000
Denmark : 40,000

~2,050,000

OMG the inflation, mess

but hey, i guess since the monsters were clocked about US numbers they have to cling to inflating WW numbers now

Originally posted by 2014

Is this what you usually say when you are defeated ?

The question was which song sold more. The only correct answer is DWUW.

Don't see what's embarrassing about performing your songs?

Didn't Katy film her Birthday performance on her tour just cuz she wanted to promote the song? It aired on TV did nothing for the song. Cure effort, right? Now that's embarrassing.

Not to mention that awful Riff Raff (is that his name) remix for TIHWD.

The thing is I'm not defeated, DWUW sold more than two songs combined WW who also had 1 performance combined and 2 remixes combined

If you wanna go and brag about that, no one's stopping you

[B'Day]

Originally posted by Tanguy

Not over. She did worse than Gaga last era but she'll come back and slay the charts yet again !

But at least Gaga TRIES

[Lord Blackout]

I did not just see someone equating a Riff Raff remix to a Christina Aguilera remix & a Rick Ross remix.

[2014]

Originally posted by Brando

Ye, that's why she begged and begged and begged and begged for people to buy her album. All those cheap tactics they used to secure #1 during release week

Cheap tactics ?

Signing 2,000 copies to her beloved fans?

Each copy costed like $16.

If anything, her label made more profit cuz of it + she made her fans happy.

Embarrassing !

[Bounce]

Originally posted by darkhorse

I can't remember when Beyoncé last had a hit tbh.

It was Telephone with GaGa (you know the one that is over)

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Harry

Don't forget this:



Lady Gaga
The Monster Ball - 227M
The Born This Way Ball - 184M (19% decline from the last tour)
ArtRave - 83M (55% decline from the last tour)

Katy Perry
The California Dreams Tour - 68M
PRISM Tour - 154M (127% increase)

you can't be serious

Also, it seems to me you can't read properly since Popstar says :

Gross Millions:
88.7 artRAVE.

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by H-I-M

Take out the US and there isn't much left of Beyoncé's career. Luckily both countries are part of the world.

Damn

[Teen Idle]

Originally posted by Tanguy

And G.U.Y.'s her only single that couldn't go Top 30. It's kind of pointless to make such a thread when we all know who will run and vote for Gaga even tho she still topped BB 200 and scored 2 Top 10 singles in 2013. But I guess no other pop star did worse - I guess, for example, Britney Jean peaked at #1 and both Work Bitch and Perfume went Top 10, right?.

What was the other top 10 single in 2013?

[Rainsford]

Calling Beyoncé local is not a bad thing, considering Beyoncé's US sales ALONE outsells Gaga's WW sales. Beyoncé stays winning.