[Trent W]

Originally posted by YonceIsFierce

It's like a constant thing on here to try and put Beyonce, out of all of her peers(Britney, Xtina, Pink) in her place. I wonder why.....

You can't discredit the rest just like that, Britney sold more albums WW as solo act. The Hive hates Britney because is the only female of this century who has the same level of legendary status than Beyonce. You are just aiming to get a huge backlash when Beyonce starts flopping again in a few years cause she is not gonna keep this success forever.

[YonceIsFierce]

Originally posted by Iman

judging a competition show, can't release an album, and struggling to scan platinum with her latest album. Bey remains unbothered on her sold out world tour.

They want her to fail so bad at life lmao. The fact that the producers have to seek out the flop female artist to judge these shows and Bey's name is never on their minds is a kiii unto itself.

[Superpower]

Originally posted by tcweh

Amy Winehouse had 2007 on lock

No she didnt

[iheartBrit]

Originally posted by Superpower

Yes she was just there, busy being the #1 artist of that decade (according to Billboard)

Britney sold more and has 10x the media attention and interest from the public. That's another thing though.

Anyways, the answer is no. Someone has always been bigger than Beyoncé.

[Superpower]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

Britney sold more and has 10x the media attention and interest from the public. That's another thing though.

Anyways, the answer is no. Someone has always been bigger than Beyoncé.

Billboard receipts >>>>>>>>>>> your perceptions
Artist of the decade: Beyoncé

[Johnny Cash]

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

I don't see shakira or christina booking the inauguration, so let's not.

And wasn't stripped released in 2002?
And aren't nelly & Christina Latinas?
Obviously you don't seem to understand that more than one person can slay at the same time.

You need to understand that nobody here is saying Beyonce is irrelevant or a flop, she was just never in the spotlight in a global scale like the others.

I don't see how the "inuguration" you love to brag about has anything to do with being the It girl. Stripped sales come from Beautiful's success which blew up in 2003. Why does it matter if they are latinas???

[YonceIsFierce]

Originally posted by Trent W

You can't discredit the rest just like that, Britney sold more albums WW as solo act. The Hive hates Britney because is the only female of this century who has the same level of legendary status than Beyonce. You are just aiming to get a huge backlash when Beyonce starts flopping again in a few years cause she is not gonna keep this success forever.

But unlike the people you just named she has been consistent at keeping her success lol. She unlike her peers has not peeked at an early age. She's not doing things that singers in their 40's should be doing. She still has a career a consistent one.

[iheartBrit]

Originally posted by YonceIsFierce

They want her to fail so bad at life lmao. The fact that the producers have to seek out the flop female artist to judge these shows and Bey's name is never on their minds is a kiii unto itself.

Katy was wanted for Idol and Simon wanted Gaga for X Factor. No Beyoncé though. Always an afterthought.

[DitaBoy12]

With BEYONCE she became an "IT" girl like let's be honest gurls.

[stayfly]

Originally posted by YonceIsFierce

It's like a constant thing on here to try and put Beyonce, out of all of her peers(Britney, Xtina, Pink) in her place. I wonder why.....

Because none of their faves are actually her peers. They stay confused because Beyonce is a legend, the only one of her generation. They don't know where to place her because she always wins.

[Trent W]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

Britney sold more and has 10x the media attention and interest from the public. That's another thing though.

Anyways, the answer is no. Someone has always been bigger than Beyoncé.

This was one of the things I saw, she has always been successful, but always in 2nd or 3rd place, but she has always been there, which is kind of consistent

[YonceIsFierce]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

Britney sold more and has 10x the media attention and interest from the public. That's another thing though.

Anyways, the answer is no. Someone has always been bigger than Beyoncé.

And yet only on ATRL is that the perception. No one beyond this forum believes this.

[Johnny Cash]

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

Once again, she doesn't have the amount of impact as beyonce, which was implied in the initial comment.

Impact is subjective, specially here on ATRL

[BabyJane]

Nope.

[alestevens]

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

You do realize that nowadays beyonce is DECIMATING The "it girls", right?
Christina,Britney,Fergie,Shakira,& Gaga, do not compare

And Shakira doesn't have the impact, not is she as influential as beyonce. Madonna doesn't count, she's the queen of pop, & has been doing this for years.

Madonna wasnt the queen of pop when she was an IT girl, but was on her way to, lol. She counts, and so does everyone else owning a year. Mariah was the IT girl of 2005, for instance.

And dead at Shakira not having the impact. The delusion

I agree with the rest, even when i stan for Britney. Girl doesnt try nor care, so why would I?

[Superpower]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

Katy was wanted for Idol and Simon wanted Gaga for X Factor. No Beyoncé though. Always an afterthought.

False. Bey was Simon's first choice for X Factor. He said "it would be a dream to have Beyoncé"

[YonceIsFierce]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

Katy as wanted for Idol and Simon wanted Gaga for X Factor. No Beyoncé though. Always an afterthought.

Being wanted to judge flop canceled talent shows is not something to brag about. It's something you do when you no longer have a career and you want to desperately try, and most likely fail, to restart said career. Beyonce is to huge for such...foolishness.

[stayfly]

Originally posted by iheartBrit

Katy as wanted for Idol and Simon wanted Gaga for X Factor. No Beyoncé though. Always an afterthought.

Beyoncé was wanted at the Superbowl, at every awards show as they begged for her presence and at the White House.

But you can keep the wannabe reality stars

[Bey_Rihstan]

Originally posted by Johnny Cash

Impact is subjective, specially here on ATRL

On Atrl it is, but in reality (which you don't seem to live in), beyonce has Undoubtedly had more impact than shakira

[Indigo Blue]

Yes.