[OhYeahYouMad]

Originally posted by Sinvius

The ignorance of anyone who tries to discredit Beyonce when using receipts from the Destiny's Child era.


Cackling at this

Each day the girls discredit, DC will be brought up

They just never win

[Ascension]

Originally posted by FatShady

We're splitting hairs here dahling. Point is its all rap singing dahling everyone does it their own way it doesn't mean its new.

No, we're not splitting hairs at all. You don't know what you're talking about and your only goal and agenda in this (and ANY Beyonce related) thread is to deny and discredit. Again all Black music sounds the same to you, there's no difference between rappers and singers nor melodic or rhythmic singing according to your very delusional ears.

[Ascension]

Originally posted by Harmonic Dreamer

You don't even understand the fundamentals of legato vs staccato.
Aaliyah used a legato vocal styling all throughout her career, minus maybe Your Love Is a One in a Million.
Salt N Peppa are RAPPERS.
Not singers incorporating a rapid-fire staccato formation to vocal melodic lines.
TLC also sang very one or the other.
IN FACT, No Scrubs, a song that contains mainly staccato phrasing, came AFTER Destiny's Child.

Chile. Serve the education.

[swissman]

Originally posted by Ascension

Chile. Serve the education.

I'm here for all these reads.

It's funny that people think that just naming a song proves something.

[bijonse]

Originally posted by Six

Stay pressed as much as you like but I'm sticking with my own opinion that Beyonce did NOT change the music industry. All she did was CONFORM and CONTINUE to spread what pop music has been doing since it was installed: objectifying women to make profit.

I'm out.



(Sorry to crash all of your dreams tho)

Beyoncé has not objectified herself anymore than any other female pop star in the world lol stop being dense

[FatShady]

Originally posted by Ascension

No, we're not splitting hairs at all. You don't know what you're talking about and your only goal and agenda in this (and ANY Beyonce related) thread is to deny and discredit. Again all Black music sounds the same to you, there's no difference between rappers and singers nor melodic or rhythmic singing according to your very delusional ears.

I don't think all black music sound the same lol
My point at that time was in the 80s/70s all music had the same elements just slowed down sped up.

I'm not discrediting Beyonce anything. I will give credit were credit is due i.e she's the best entertainer and has the most star power but in her musical career she's so recycled. In 10 years time people like you will credit Beyonce as the marketing genius but really Kanye and Jay did it right before but she was more successful. I see a lot of other things she chirpsed but point is Beyonce is really talented and has a great life but she's not really innovative.

[OhYeahYouMad]

The poll was made for a reason

Let's see how the majority feel....

[OhYeahYouMad]

100 votes says yes

[Ascension]

Originally posted by FatShady

I don't think all black music sound the same lol
My point at that time was in the 80s/70s all music had the same elements just slowed down sped up.

I'm not discrediting Beyonce anything. I will give credit were credit is due i.e she's the best entertainer and has the most star power but in her musical career she's so recycled. In 10 years time people like you will credit Beyonce as the marketing genius but really Kanye and Jay did it right before but she was more successful. I see a lot of other things she chirpsed but point is Beyonce is really talented and has a great life but she's not really innovative.

I requested you give examples of the rhythmic rap singing as delivered by Bey/DC and you proceeded to give me an artist singing melodically with elongated notes over a hip hop Bey; another group that sings in a similar fashion but had a rapper that RAPPED separately and Salt N Pepa -- RAPPERS -- on what god damn planet does any of that sound like the hiccupy, rapid fire staccato flow displayed on songs like No, No, No and Bug a Boo?

You aren't even discerning between genres let alone vocal styles and phrasing. You need more people, sis.

[DIAMONDZ]

i think B'Day and BEYONCE are her only albums that had impact on the industry.

[suneclipse121]

Am I really seeing an Avril Lavigne stan trying to shade Beyonce?? What is Life??

[FatShady]

Originally posted by Ascension

I requested you give examples of the rhythmic rap singing as delivered by Bey/DC and you proceeded to give me an artist singing melodically with elongated notes over a hip hop Bey; another group that sings in a similar fashion but had a rapper that RAPPED separately and Salt N Pepa -- RAPPERS -- on what god damn planet does any of that sound like the hiccupy, rapid fire staccato flow displayed on songs like No, No, No and Bug a Boo?

You aren't even discerning between genres let alone vocal styles and phrasing. You need more people, sis.

what god damn planet does any of that sound like the hiccupy, rapid fire staccato flow displayed on songs like No, No, No and Bug a Boo?

I don't really know what the **** you're talking about because all I hear is rap singing as does the whole world. Either way if thats your receipt for Beyonce's musical impact then she has none.




p.s I put Salt n Pepa there because like most female rappers they also rap sing.

[OhYeahYouMad]

Originally posted by suneclipse121

Am I really seeing an Avril Lavigne stan trying to shade Beyonce?? What is Life??

Even Rihanna stans

[Ascension]

Originally posted by FatShady

I don't really know what the **** you're talking about because all I hear is rap singing as does the whole world. Either way if thats your receipt for Beyonce's musical impact then she has none.




p.s I put Salt n Pepa there because like most female rappers they also rap sing.

D. lusional.

[Harmonic Dreamer]

Originally posted by FatShady

I don't really know what the **** you're talking about because all I hear is rap singing as does the whole world. Either way if thats your receipt for Beyonce's musical impact then she has none.




p.s I put Salt n Pepa there because like most female rappers they also rap sing.

GIRL.
You came in here twirling, thinking you knew what you were talking about.
You can't even discern between rapping, singing, and a blend of both.
All three of these are very different.
One is rhythmic and syncopated, jarring and it's backbone is centered in speech.
The next is very melodic and legato structured, having to do with the way the vocal folds move and vibrate with one another.

B took both of those elements, a rhythmic backbone and a melodic line and combined the two together to create rap-singing.

I'm not understanding what you don't get here.

[Six]

Originally posted by suneclipse121

Am I really seeing an Avril Lavigne stan trying to shade Beyonce?? What is Life??

Oh stop it you!

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

Originally posted by GenieBaby

Yes, well Single Ladies definitely did!!

It's now forgotten.

[Tom_Ford]

Originally posted by Summertime Love

Girl, that last sentence is so contradictory.

Right.

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

Originally posted by Tom_Ford

Right.

There are still almost 80 people who think otherwise.

[Addicted_]

Heard Baby Boy, Irreplaceable, Single Ladies, & XO on the radio today