[INTRA]

Originally posted by Vin

This. I'm so tired of the judges babying Lauren. She has an amazing voice, but she is just NOT ready. She's not ready to be an American Idol. She needs more time and some experience. And then Hayley gives these great performances, works the stage, has so much personality in her voice and pushes herself and she doesn't get nearly as much recognition from the judges.

...Vin

!

[bendi_94]

James and Hayle were the best tonight, they oth did AMAZING!!!
My order for the night:
1. James / Hayle
2. Lauren
3. Scotty
4. Casey
5. Jacob.

I hope and believe Jacob is going to be Eliminated. If not I hope it's Casey.

[Reeces]

Haley is my pick to win the whole thing, but James was my favorite tonight. I hope they are the final 2, but I know Scotty or Lauren are gonna make that impossible.

01. James
02. Haley
03. Scotty
04. Lauren
05. Casey
06. Jacob

That's how I'd rank the performances. I think it's time for Jacob or Casey to go

[FAN]

DialIdol has become unreliable, but a new website Vote Fair gets the votes right almost every week & here's how they rank :

1.James
2.Scotty
3.Lauren

4.Haley
5.Casey
6.Jacob


Exactly the bottom 3 I preicted, hope it's right.

[Shy Boy]

As long as Haley is safe, I'll be a happy camper

[jbstatic23]

An all-female finale is still possible

[Vignesh]

Haley has grown a lot over the course of the competition and it has been completely amazing to watch her progression. I love her now!!

To me Scotty is the weakest at this stage and he needs to go. But he won't coz of the tone deaf girls voting for him.

[LightandDarkness]

Originally posted by Shy Boy

As long as Haley is safe, I'll be a happy camper

Same here, I could careless who goes home, as long as it's not Queen Haley!

[Deemy]

Casey needs to Get The **** Out!! Im still mad that Stefano went home last week when he had one of the best performances.

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by jbstatic23

An all-female finale is still possible

Really? I don't think so, it'll be a long shot.

Originally posted by LightandDarkness

Same here, I could careless who goes home, as long as it's not Queen Haley!

[Shy Boy]

Ryan said "a lot of people are going to be disappointed with tonight's result"

[JC.]

Originally posted by Shy Boy

Ryan said "a lot of people are going to be disappointed with tonight's result"

I bet it's Casey

Or Lauren

[Stepfon]

I thought RyGuy didn't know the results ahead of time, the producers must have told him they were disappointing to the fans.

Casey or Jacob need to go.

[Shy Boy]

Crystal has so many better songs on her album that this

[JC.]

Haley loving Adam

http://www.billboard.com/news/adam-l...05161062.story

Coincidence

[Shy Boy]

Idol needs to cut their results show to half an hour.

[Lee!!]

That medley hurt my ears

[Shy Boy]

YESSSSS! Haley is safe. Weeks ago, who wouldve thought she would make it to top 5

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by What It Seems

Haley loving Adam

http://www.billboard.com/news/adam-l...05161062.story

Coincidence

That picture

[Shy Boy]

Dead @ Jimmy Iovine: "The family dog doesnt vote"