[Nerevanin]

Originally posted by Music & Science

OMG CANCEL IT NOW!!!!!

I love WIR album but Kelly's best song doesn't deserve this

Calm down, sis, Kelly's best song is Sober.

[Music & Science]

Originally posted by Nerevanin

Calm down, sis, Kelly's best song is Sober.

Sorry sis but Maybe ***** over Sober

[Nerevanin]

Originally posted by Mhs90

I only knew like 5 demos from that demo list. Ain't nobody got time to listen to all that.

Really? You're missing a lot!

[Nerevanin]

Originally posted by Music & Science

Sorry sis but Maybe ***** over Sober

Nope. Sober's bridge alone blows Maybe out of the water.

[KevinKDC]

Thanks for the welcome guys

Originally posted by Cupid

People really did overrated WIR.

I'm only half way through there's still loads more to count, it will probably all change.

Can I still send mine?

[Temporal]

I can't listen to Maybe anymore because me and my friend used the instrumental to sing over for a school project.... It wasn't pretty

[Kriskiki89]

What kind of flop stans. The demo's have been around for years now. No excuses for having not listening to them! I didn't partake but I'm ready for the results!

[Eyarimu]

WIR songs beats Maybe.

Ya'll just can't. Deal with it. The freshness of these songs + their flawlessness is making Maybe sound weak.

Edit: I gave Maybe a high score, though.

[Eyarimu]

So this is Amy Lee

I would love Kelly to have a picture like this but it's too late

[Music & Science]

Originally posted by Nerevanin

Nope. Sober's bridge alone blows Maybe out of the water.

Originally posted by Kriskiki89

What kind of flop stans. The demo's have been around for years now. No excuses for having not listening to them! I didn't partake but I'm ready for the results!

!

Originally posted by Eyarimu

So this is Amy Lee

I would love Kelly to have a picture like this but it's too late

I ship little Jack and baby River already The future King and Queen of music

[rivers]

Originally posted by Cupid

Oh believe me, i'm not fixing this. If I was then 'Maybe' wouldn't be getting beat by every song on Wrapped In Red right now.

Omg


I am guilty of rating Wrapped In Jesus high though

[Nerevanin]

Originally posted by rivers

Omg

I am guilty of rating Wrapped In Jesus high though

I just counted the scores I gave and my suspicion was confirmed: Wrapped In Red has the highest average score. Out of the "normal" albums Breakaway has the highest one, followed by Stronger, which surprised me a lot. But it's true that the two highest rated albums (but WIR) won the Grammies so maybe I ain't that wrong.

Here are my average scores for albums:

7.115 - Thankful
7.882 - All I Ever Wanted
7.941 - My December
8.278 - Stronger
8.333 - Breakaway
8.500 - Wrapped In Red

[Qwords]

Originally posted by Nerevanin

I just counted the scores I gave and my suspicion was confirmed: Wrapped In Red has the highest average score. Out of the "normal" albums Breakaway has the highest one, followed by Stronger, which surprised me a lot. But it's true that the two highest rated albums (but WIR) won the Grammies so maybe I ain't that wrong.

Here are my average scores for albums:

7.115 - Thankful
7.882 - All I Ever Wanted
7.941 - My December
8.278 - Stronger
8.333 - Breakaway
8.500 - Wrapped In Red

It kinda makes sense, tho. It's the freshest/least played out. And cheesy songs on a holiday album work to a certain extent. Whereas cheesy songs on a regular album are just cheesy. -- dumb + dumb y'all.

[KevinKDC]

I'm not really sure who said that (I think it was Garath) even Stronger struggled on pop

FYI:
@americantop40
@kelly_clarkson moves to #2 with “Stronger” in just her 6th week. If she hits #1 next week, it’ll be the fastest climb in 7 years.

And yes she went to #1 the next week.

[Nerevanin]

Originally posted by Qwords

It kinda makes sense, tho. It's the freshest/least played out. And cheesy songs on a holiday album work to a certain extent. Whereas cheesy songs on a regular album are just cheesy. -- dumb + dumb y'all.

You mean that it makes sense that WIR has the highest average score because it's the least played out of her albums? I don't think so tbh, I played the hell out of it since its release til Christmas, I'm pretty sure I heard it more times than Thankful or All I Ever Wanted. I think it's rather because most of the songs are time-tested classics and if they were awful, they wouldn't be classics for 20, 30, 50 years. Then you add Kelly's flawless vocals and Greg's great production and very good original songs and you have it.

EDIT: BTW, I gave Einstein a pretty high score. Not a 10 but higher than average. At least one person has to show some love for it.

[Nerevanin]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

I'm not really sure who said that (I think it was Garath) even Stronger struggled on pop

FYI:
@americantop40
@kelly_clarkson moves to #2 with “Stronger” in just her 6th week. If she hits #1 next week, it’ll be the fastest climb in 7 years.

And yes she went to #1 the next week.

Pop just hates Kelly. She struggled there with all her post Stronger (WDKY) songs. How MKIA did there? Or previous songs from All I Ever Wanted?

[Eyarimu]

@Kelly Clarkson

Loving Bang Bang by Jessie J Ariana Grande and Nicki Minaj!! Awesome, fun song ladies


I guess I'll force myself to listen to it now. Is there a version withour Nicki, though?

[Mzd]

I regret nothing on rating WIR so high. The production and vocals she delivered were perfect.

[Nerevanin]

Originally posted by Mzd

I regret nothing on rating WIR so high. The production and vocals she delivered were perfect.

I agree. WIR is flawless and it deserves high score.

[Music & Science]

Originally posted by Nerevanin

I just counted the scores I gave and my suspicion was confirmed: Wrapped In Red has the highest average score. Out of the "normal" albums Breakaway has the highest one, followed by Stronger, which surprised me a lot. But it's true that the two highest rated albums (but WIR) won the Grammies so maybe I ain't that wrong.

Here are my average scores for albums:

7.115 - Thankful
7.882 - All I Ever Wanted
7.941 - My December
8.278 - Stronger
8.333 - Breakaway
8.500 - Wrapped In Red

your rates are so different to mine My Dec is in my top 2

Originally posted by Eyarimu

@Kelly Clarkson

Loving Bang Bang by Jessie J Ariana Grande and Nicki Minaj!! Awesome, fun song ladies


I guess I'll force myself to listen to it now. Is there a version withour Nicki, though?

same here. Get that elusive promo, lessors

Originally posted by Mzd

I regret nothing on rating WIR so high. The production and vocals she delivered were perfect.

I gave it a good score as well (her vocals were on fire), most of the songs are really perfect but i just want Maybe and BTHE to win this rate