Quote:
Originally posted by Instant
Funny because in the Slant review she is basically called an untalented rat and that the only reason Joanne is semi-decent is because of all the talented men who worked on it.
NYT barely said anything about the album and advices here to stfu and go to work with The Chainsmokers.
So no
|
Nah. The whole NYT review was a litany of criticisms about why Caramonica didn't like the album. He didn't talk about the Chainsmokers until the end of the review.
Quote:
Note her recent tiff with the club-pop dopes in the Chainsmokers, who said in an interview that they didn’t enjoy “Perfect Illusion.” She responded, coolly, on Twitter, in what felt like a mother dismissing an impudent child.
Which is fair: The Chainsmokers don’t see dance music as avant-garde theater or sociopolitical provocation. They see it as quick-stepping pop, which, though it’s fuzzy in the rearview, is also part of Lady Gaga’s legacy. That they were allergic to “Perfect Illusion” makes sense. But instead of taking offense and tossing off a tweet, she should maybe give them a call.
|
People are in their feelings about that one throwaway paragraph and a half about the Chainsmokers instead of everything else he had to say about Joanne. Caramonica only referred to the Chainsmokers because of their "recent tiff" and because they are making the type of pop that's hot right now. He could've inserted any pop hit-maker from Red One to Dr. Luke in that last paragraph, and the point would've gotten across
.
