Challenge #6 - Best ATRL Profile - Judges Comments
Bloomers / Drake
Prometheus. - Very you and I like it. I love how much thought was put into it. But it didn't wow me too much.
collin - This is good and simple. A very minimalistic revival. Borders on "too simple", though.
Zune - Your profile to me is good, but I still don't get a total sense of you in your profile. I didn't like what you did with your Custom Title.
Cupid - The avi is cute, not sure I like the filter on it though. It might be a little too short/basic. Everything else is cute but I feel like you could style the signature better, maybe use a different font, add in some bold or italic, color maybe. It's a very basic profile make-over.
BlooRiverAnimal / Ke$ha
Prometheus. - 1) that avi.
2) I feel like this could be the template ANY Ke$ha stan would use. Doesn't make you stand out as a Ke$ha stan, it just makes you look like another Ke$ha stan. Cute sig, though.
collin - A La Discotheque This was a pretty good profile makeover, you really thought it through. I feel it could've been executed better but it was decent.
Zune - Most of it works for me, I felt your location (and maybe some signature formatting) would have improved your profile a bit more. I liked it overall.
Cupid - I gave you a template and you send in that giant ass picture without resizing it into an actual avatar?! Girl... I don't like the colours in the signature and I think this is a bit of a mess.
Citrus / Cher
Prometheus. - Cute entry! Very singular and unique. Love the sig, too.
collin - Sleighing as per usual. Nice makeover
Zune - I thought yours was pretty clever overall. I felt your signature was indeed notable in its fact, but I think you could have added more things to it.
Cupid - I love the avatar, she looks gorgeous. The user title and everything else is great. I'm not usually into signatures that boast about achievements but you did it in a humorous way which I think would make you stand out on ATRL as a poster. I like it overall.
Cristhian / Sade
Prometheus. - What does your user title mean, btw? I'd say the rest of the profile fits your fave well- simplistic. It just felt bland, tbh. Cute little sig, though.
collin - Ooh, wow... I really like this, especially the signature being devoted to Sade Nice.
Zune - I like the main profile parts. I have an issue with the signature links. While its nice you have Sade's worked linked in your signature, it took away the fact you linked your last fm. This sort of confusion confused me when wondering if the twitter link was to your twitter or not, but that's is me getting a bit too detail oriented.
Cupid - The avatar is a bit too jumpy for me and doesn't really stand out colour wise. I feel like maybe a HQ still image or something would have been better, if she doesn't have incredibly graphic videos. The signature is cute and organized and that's what sold it for me.
e437 / Kelly Clarkson
Prometheus. - What does the location mean, btw? Nice entry, but nothing to WOW over. It feels like a template any Kelly stan could use.
collin - This makeover is alright, although it doesn't seem to be very cohesive/stick to a theme. Plus it's a bit bland... but hey, not terrible. I liked your thought processes!
Zune - I liked some parts of your profile more then others. To start: your NP excellent. Your signature...it was okay, I felt you could have made it more personalized, but I had no idea why Catch My Breath would be your custom title and the Location being North & South...is that a reference to a Kelly demo?
Cupid - The location is very clever but you forgot to explain that. The user title could have been more creative and not just a song name. The avatar is beautiful and I love everything else, the signature needs to be a size bigger though it's a strain on the eyes. But overall it's pretty nice.
EuphorianSea / Christina Aguilera
Prometheus. - Cute user title.
collin - Isn't this already your profile? Slay... but y'all still COULD'VE gone the extra mile, no?
Zune - I liked what you had in your profile except the signature. Firstly your signature just says Christina Aguilera...and that's it. No links to anything related to her, just that. Overall its a good profile, just your signature could have improved my score for you.
Cupid - It's cute, but it's so plain. Maybe you needed an explanation to give it some spice and try and sell it.
GetYourAssInMyBed / iamamiwhoami
Prometheus. - Thanks for the explanation. Was cool of you to add the color scheme in! The sig is kind of a mess and I don't think a Location can be that many, but I didn't knock off for that. Great entry.
collin - Whoa, sis, careful on that sig... a bit long! But hey, you hit it home. This is all great, down to the creatively picked color scheme
Zune - although realistically the links past Blue available Nov. 10th would unlikely appear on a common ATRL post. Other then that, excellent profile in terms of stan mode, but I would have liked to have seen a more personal side to your profile. I felt that was missing. PS. for those who read my comments for this member, notice how this member has to go into imense detail each entry they submit since no one knows who this person stans for. This members explanations is crucial to their success in this game, otherwise this member would have been out in the earlier rounds. Never assume you can just send in something without an decent (but only necessary) details about your entries. Essays are never needed really, just crucial details to your profile is all I'm recognizing from this member.
Cupid - The user title could have been utilized better, it's nice but there's no real connection to the rest of your profile. The avatar is great, it stands out. The location is too long, it doesn't look right + I don't think that would even fit? Same thing with your signature, it's far too big, it wouldn't all fit onto your profile. I feel like you could have cut the sig in half if you organized it better and maybe put one half on the left and one half on the right in a table or something. Overall I like it though.
iHype. / Mariah Carey
Prometheus. - The best part of this entry is the color scheme in the avi you made. The rest of it could have been thought out more in my opinion, but still good nonetheless. Cute sig, too.
collin - I'm gonna brush aside the low-key annoying small-lowercase things. Why do people think those are cute? (i.e. this - Cᴀᴍᴏᴜғʟᴀɢᴇ). But, obviously, great entry.
Zune - I liked your signature, but I would have liked to hear some detail in your comments about why you made your Custom Title and Location what you made them.
Cupid - Everything is perfect except the avatar, i'm not fond of promo avis. They're cute for a few weeks around the album release, but as a long-term profile sort of thing, I think you should have gone with something else. Great though.
JustLuke / Alexandra Burke
Prometheus. - Mess of a user title, mess of a Location and MESS of a sig. Average NP and decent avi.
collin - Noootttt "looking for a label" Sums up the messiness of this entry well.
Zune - Signature too long to appear in regular ATRL posts, and same with the custom title. Had this been adjusted, you could have gotten a better score.
Cupid - The user title is too long, that wouldn't fit on your ATRL profile. The avatar is great, it's a classic look at the screen singing avi. Also I forgot to edit your name in the entries, why did you put Miss Burke?! I specifically told y'all to put your usernames in the template. If you're given a template, follow it! The signature is too basic and too long to fit in a real profile. I feel like you kinda threw this challenge.
keshaspearsxo / Ke$ha
Prometheus. - Felt rushed and kinda uninspired as if you just threw it together and hoped it worked. Only cute thing about it is the sig.
collin - This is cute. Kinda basic but what else would we expect from Pears? Kidding I luh it.
Zune - Let me just say, I get why you made your profile the way you did, I just didn't like the fact that being an Animal was the only really prominent thing that i took away from your profile. I just wanted more featured in your profile aside from Kesha and Animal,
Cupid - I understand the animal thing but I felt like it was animal overload. There's more to Kesha and there's more to being a Kesha fan. The signature would have been perfect, then if you had a diff custom title and NP that would have slayed. I don't really like the avi either tbh.. it just doesn't stand out.
Penk / Janelle Monae
Prometheus. - Cute but nothing really stands out.
collin - I like the avatar and most of the panel beneath it, but the signature and custom title are a bit "eh" for me. Good work regardless!
Zune - I thought it was a simple profile, but I think you could have done more with your signaure.
Cupid - User title is too long and you could have maybe jazzed up the signature a bit and still kept in the link to her new song. Apart from that it's great, love the avi. I feel like you could have done more though.
Posh / Michael Buble
Prometheus. - Brownie points for cohesiveness. I know it kinda strays away from the challenges original roots, but I can't dock you for being so creative. I love everything about this. The sig is kinda awkward at the end, but I still love it. Best entry and great job. Everything about it is so...
collin - Whoa, wait. This is kinda flawless. Very well done, everything is aligned beautifully and I use.
Zune - I liked the balance of Michael and you incorporated into this profile. Sure its not a full stan mode profile, but it has many elements of you and Michael brought out into this profile.
Cupid - You have an eye for design, this is clear from your profile and what I've seen in the past. Some people have it, some people don't. This is what I was looking for, unique, it stands out, it looks sleek and beautiful.
Subomie / Kylie Minogue
Prometheus. - An entry for a great Kylie stan. Great job! Loved the constant theme and the nods to her underrated BL b-sides/bonus tracks! This would definitely cement you as the "Body Language era Kylie stan". (Cupid edit: poor Dream!)
collin - This is all very well laid-out. Nice work - a tip would've been to kinda up the signature a lil bit. But that's about all!
Zune - I felt your User title/Location could have been used better. I feel for the roles the two play on a profile, naming it random songs you liked was not the way to go about your profile. I also didn't care for your signature.
Cupid - I'm so glad you kept your profile mostly the same, I've been admiring it hehe. Everything is perfect apart from the signature colour, it blends a little too much.
Truth Teller / Christina Aguilera
Prometheus. - Cute (but often used (it seems)) user title. Great song in the NP, but nothing too creative or noteworthy. Cute sig. A little to big, though.
collin - Great, great entry. Plus... "Get Mine, Get Yours" is a bop. Well played.
Zune - I think your signature could have been worked on a bit more (liked everything else). also BB code quotes I believe do not show up in signatures last I checked... (Cupid edit: they do by the way)
Cupid - Like Euphorian I feel like this is too basic. I love the avi but everything is is so simple and meh. The signature is too big, it wouldn't fit in an ATRL profile, I think you should have made the font smaller and more classy.
i should have made my location a bit shorter like the way I have it now. I didn't know we had to stay within ATRL requirements. I thought we could make everything as long or as short as we wanted to but it doesn't matter because the comments looked positive anyway 
thanks guys!
That's why I didn't even bother with an explanation.