[Benjy]

Originally posted by Coklek92

http://www.redbrick.me/music/album-r...y-gaga-joanne/



nnnnnn Not a review from Swifties

His review sounds like something an intern would write

[Almighty Gaga]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

http://prettymuchamazing.com/reviews/lady-gaga-joanne

A cute 83/100 gals. Certified Metacritic publisher too! Their average music review score is72: http://www.metacritic.com/publicatio...g?filter=music

Should give the overall grade a little push since their average score is a 72 and they gave her a B+.

[State of Grace.]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

http://prettymuchamazing.com/reviews/lady-gaga-joanne

A cute 83/100 gals. Certified Metacritic publisher too! Their average music review score is72: http://www.metacritic.com/publicatio...g?filter=music

Should give the overall grade a little push since their average score is a 72 and they gave her a B+.

yaaass

[Khal]

Originally posted by Brando

!!

+ Pretty much amazing & Billboard.

It's like every single album is 10/10 for them.

I haven't heard a single album in my life that I would grade 10/10.

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

http://prettymuchamazing.com/reviews/lady-gaga-joanne

A cute 83/100 gals. Certified Metacritic publisher too! Their average music review score is72: http://www.metacritic.com/publicatio...g?filter=music

Should give the overall grade a little push since their average score is a 72 and they gave her a B+.

So what's the truth?

They give every album a 10, but yet their average score is 72?

[TinkerbellClap]

Originally posted by Khal

So what's the truth?

They give every album a 10, but yet their average score is 72?

Also they're not afraid to give 0's. They gave MJ's Xscape a 0. However, Billboard (avg. 76) has only given 40.

[Pop]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

http://prettymuchamazing.com/reviews/lady-gaga-joanne

A cute 83/100 gals. Certified Metacritic publisher too! Their average music review score is72: http://www.metacritic.com/publicatio...g?filter=music

Should give the overall grade a little push since their average score is a 72 and they gave her a B+.

[Almighty Gaga]

Originally posted by Khal

So what's the truth?

They give every album a 10, but yet their average score is 72?

[Komet blu]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

Also they're not afraid to give 0's. They gave MJ's Xscape a 0. However, Billboard (avg. 76) has only given 40.

what on earth

ot: rise, joanne!!

[Dämon]

Some French reviews (I know they don't count towards MC, but whatevs).

ChartsinFrance: 4/5 for the album (Gave 3 songs 5/5: Millions Reasons; Sinner's Prayer and Joanne. Worst rated songs (2,5/5: Perfect Illusion & Giorgio Girls).

RTL: Very mixed. Not good, rather bad, not too bad though. Praised Joanne, Million Reasons & Angel Down, the rest is meh, trashed Perfect Illusion & A-YO.

[State of Grace.]

Originally posted by Instant

Funny because in the Slant review she is basically called an untalented rat and that the only reason Joanne is semi-decent is because of all the talented men who worked on it.

NYT barely said anything about the album and advices here to stfu and go to work with The Chainsmokers.

So no

basically this

[kwek_kwek]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

http://prettymuchamazing.com/reviews/lady-gaga-joanne

A cute 83/100 gals. Certified Metacritic publisher too! Their average music review score is72: http://www.metacritic.com/publicatio...g?filter=music

Should give the overall grade a little push since their average score is a 72 and they gave her a B+.

Does this count in MC?

Edit: it is.

Good score.

[BlackAura]

I hope the people who gave Born This Way and Born To Die a 0 won't review it this time.

[Pop]

Originally posted by Dämon

Giorgio Girls

delete it

[SpinThatShhh]

Originally posted by Komet blu

what on earth

They had moral issues with the release.

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Khal

So what's the truth?

They give every album a 10, but yet their average score is 72?

so 20 out of 600 is every album?

[HAPPI•LIL•PILL]

Originally posted by HASHTAGPOW

joanne deserves 65

How generous

[HandsOn]

83 is a B+ where y'all go to school?

[lightstheyblindme]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

http://prettymuchamazing.com/reviews/lady-gaga-joanne

A cute 83/100 gals. Certified Metacritic publisher too! Their average music review score is72: http://www.metacritic.com/publicatio...g?filter=music

Should give the overall grade a little push since their average score is a 72 and they gave her a B+.

honestly 83 is where Joanne deserves to stabilize
but because it's Gaga, who is held to a much higher standard than these others, people feel the need to give it ridiculously low scores

[Leptine]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

http://prettymuchamazing.com/reviews/lady-gaga-joanne

A cute 83/100 gals. Certified Metacritic publisher too! Their average music review score is72: http://www.metacritic.com/publicatio...g?filter=music

Should give the overall grade a little push since their average score is a 72 and they gave her a B+.

Finally.

I want more tho.

[Almighty Gaga]

Originally posted by HandsOn

83 is a B+ where y'all go to school?

The Metacritic school.