[Artemisia]

Originally posted by Mirrorwriting

Looking at the singles list I have no idea how Hotline Bling is #1 I like the song, but it isn't really even top 10 worthy, let alone the winner. The rest of the list is okay but I'd take out Hello and IKTGBGT as well.

Interesting how the singles list is very male-oriented whereas the albums top 5 is very female-oriented.

The nature of how the list is compiled favors songs that appear in many lists, regardless of how well they are liked.

Basically, everyone who put HB on their list could agree that there are several songs better than it, but HB is still on all their lists.

[Artemisia]

For Free? is iconic

IMMA GET MY UNCLE SAM TO **** YOU UP, YOU AINT NO KING

--> King Kunta

[minho]

Ohh never mind then. I thought it was something like each critic list's top 20 or top 10 was what gets counted. I didn't realize the whole list was taken into consideration.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Mirrorwriting

Ohh never mind then. I thought it was something like each critic list's top 20 or top 10 was what gets counted. I didn't realize the whole list was taken into consideration.

No, everyone only gets to submit a top ten. The albums list is weighted by points, but the singles list is purely based on mentions.

[supaspaz]

Five ballots and it's only day two. Slay slay slay!

[Ewan Chaos]

Count me the **** IN

Can't believe Courtney beat the trio of her/Julia/Natalie though smh. Gonna drag it a bit and sleater-kinney more if I'm being completely honest.

[holocene]

#justiceforNATALIE

[Kid A]

Will do this

Poor Courtney!

[Bloomers]

Critics want to mention that they miss when hip hop was rappin’
Mother****er, if you did, then Killer Mike'd be platinum

Kendrick gets it. Killer Mike should be plat.

[Tom Vercetti]

We either think that we're invincible or that we are invisible
When realistically we're somewhere in between
We all think that we're nobody but everybody is somebody else's somebody


Whew, Kim's Caravan goes pretty hard. The solo is also well executed.

[MP2K]

Guys, give World Princess Part II, Butterfly, Aqua Profundal, How Much a Dollar Cost, Momma and Price Tag good scores, kay? Underrated gems.

[Lucas32]

Originally posted by Tom Vercetti

We either think that we're invincible or that we are invisible
When realistically we're somewhere in between
We all think that we're nobody but everybody is somebody else's somebody


Whew, Kim's Caravan goes pretty hard. The solo is also well executed.

I see a dead seal on the beach
The old man says he's already saved it three times this week
Guess it just wants to die I would wanna die too
With people putting oil into my air but to be fair I've done my share
Guess everybody's got their different point of view


Love this song

Originally posted by MP2K

Guys, give World Princess Part II, Butterfly, Aqua Profundal, How Much a Dollar Cost, Momma and Price Tag good scores, kay? Underrated gems.

Yes

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Bloomers

Critics want to mention that they miss when hip hop was rappin’
Mother****er, if you did, then Killer Mike'd be platinum

Kendrick gets it. Killer Mike should be plat.

Originally posted by Tom Vercetti

We either think that we're invincible or that we are invisible
When realistically we're somewhere in between
We all think that we're nobody but everybody is somebody else's somebody


Whew, Kim's Caravan goes pretty hard. The solo is also well executed.

Yes! Stan for genius!

[supaspaz]

Courtney is not feeling like the #2 album of the year for me.

[conatus]

Originally posted by supaspaz

Courtney is not feeling like the #2 album of the year for me.

Yeah, it's pretty hit-and-miss. I never quite got the acclaim.

[conatus]

Originally posted by MP2K

Guys, give World Princess Part II, Butterfly, Aqua Profundal, How Much a Dollar Cost, Momma and Price Tag good scores, kay? Underrated gems.

The only songs on ARTANGELS worth 10s to be honest. Butterfly is the best of her career.

Let's also do right by Hood Politics. Nobody ever talks about it but it's easily one of my favourites on TPAB.

[conatus]

Originally posted by Ewan Chaos

Count me the **** IN

Can't believe Courtney beat the trio of her/Julia/Natalie though smh. Gonna drag it a bit and sleater-kinney more if I'm being completely honest.

Like, Natalie and Julia's albums were easily more deserving of the acclaim/position on P&J.

[Price of Fame]

Part of me wants to just drop 3 points from every Carly song on my ranking since she'll have the advantage here.

but no, I'll be fair.

Butterfly FTW

[Wilkes]

I slept on so much music this year!

[Temporal]

I wanted to do this when I saw the title, then I realized I'd have to get all the way through the Sleater-Kinney and Courtney albums I could barely get past one song by them