[400Lux]

Katy can't sing. She can scream. There's a difference.

[ultraviolento]

Katy is not the perfect songwriter but at least she's not one-dimensional and safe like Taylor so she wins, stop this nonsense

[feelslikeadream]

The fact that a discussion about who writes better lyrics has lasted this long is ridiculous. This thread is just an example of blind stanning at this point

EDIT: Case in point.

Originally posted by ultraviolento

Katy is not the perfect songwriter but at least she's not one-dimensional and safe like Taylor so she wins, stop this nonsense

[Dollas n Diamonds]

Originally posted by halcyonday

Yesss, so she's better. Thank you.

K? we all know Katy has the potential to be better than Taylor at her best, too bad Katy's vocal performances are usually a tragedy

[Swim]

Katy. There are some great songs on 1989 though.

[hellocory]

Originally posted by ultraviolento

Katy is not the perfect songwriter but at least she's not one-dimensional and safe like Taylor so she wins, stop this nonsense

Katy is one of the most one-dimensional pop stars of all-time.

[ahauntingnearu]

i hate when people **** on "do you ever feel like a plastic bag?", but some of the same people praise to the high heavens a(n amazing) song containing the lyric "i'm a crumpled up piece of paper"

like, seriously? the delusion

don't get me wrong, ATW is a fabulous song. that line isn't even that bad, but neither is the plastic bag lyric. people should be critical where it is necessary, but those two lines don't deserve it. pick apart some other lines. katy has some horrendous lyrics, but songs like TOY, Lost, ISB, Fingerprints, WAILF, TOTGA, WA, BTGOG, CYB are really great lyrics

[h.u.r.r.i.c.a.n.e]

Originally posted by feelslikeadream

EDIT: Case in point.

He doesn't even stan for Katy.

[ultraviolento]

Originally posted by hellocory

Katy is one of the most one-dimensional pop stars of all-time.

She's not the one only known for her boyfriend songs but ok, whatever helps you sleep

[Mau ®]

They're both mediocre live singers. Is one being better than the other a slayage? Settle for more, Kats.

[kevinnyc]

Grammys recognize her better.

[Miracle Whip]

WHEW

MY EDGES

[Nialler]

Originally posted by Dollas n Diamonds

Just cause Katy can Belt and has a powerful voice doesn't mean she can sing

Katy's High > TH > Taylors Average > KA > Taylors Worst > Katy's Worst

what in the world is this

Taylor Swift on average? She always hides behind the backing track 5x as loud as her to hide her paper-thin voice and can't stay on key for more than 5 seconds, she has the most embarrassing range of all pop girls sans Selena, why even try? And in before some stan posts one of those tragic flat notes she pretends she's belting like she's Mariah Carey

[RudeBoyy]

Both are redundant writers, both are weak singers, both have cute but safe bops but Katy is better at all three than Taylor so her.

[hellocory]

Originally posted by Miracle Whip

WHEW

MY EDGES

And it only took 4 people to write these average lyrics

[h.u.r.r.i.c.a.n.e]

Originally posted by Dollas n Diamonds

K? we all know Katy has the potential to be better than Taylor at her best, too bad Katy's vocal performances are usually a tragedy

Taylor is just as inconsistent as Katy. I mean the BRITs performance of BS? The verses

[400Lux]

Originally posted by ahauntingnearu

i hate when people **** on "do you ever feel like a plastic bag?", but some of the same people praise to the high heavens a(n amazing) song containing the lyric "i'm a crumpled up piece of paper"

like, seriously? the delusion

don't get me wrong, ATW is a fabulous song. that line isn't even that bad, but neither is the plastic bag lyric. people should be critical where it is necessary, but those two lines don't deserve it. pick apart some other lines. katy has some horrendous lyrics, but songs like TOY, Lost, ISB, Fingerprints, WAILF, TOTGA, WA, BTGOG, CYB are really great lyrics

If Katy's songs are that great, why didn't any song of hers appear on a Pazz & Jop top 10 year end list yet, when Taylor has had several?

And let me not even say anything about Grammy's

She's not acclaimed, Taylor is. Taylor always wins

[h.u.r.r.i.c.a.n.e]

Originally posted by Mau ®

They're both mediocre live singers. Is one being better than the other a slayage? Settle for more, Kats.

Then what are the swifties settling for?

Kii, like we're arguing between these two and if the Swifties can't have it they'll just make up something to escape the point.

[ultraviolento]

Taylor has no resonance at all, Katy's an average singer yet she's way way way better than Swift, let's not

[Miracle Whip]

Originally posted by hellocory

And it only took 4 people to write these average lyrics

It's almost like you can make better music when you work with other people except yourself!