[Icing]

Originally posted by madonnas

You should punch out The Power of Good-Bore too.

I like that "Memory of Trees" b-side.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Icing

I like that "Memory of Trees" b-side.

Well don't give it any higher than a 3, okay?

[Sanctuary]

Originally posted by Icing

Maybe. All I know is Frozen is getting annihilated. Straight punched.

Would you perhaps cherish the thought of helping me punch out a certain other beloved classic?

[Icing]

Tens:

Borderline
Angel
Like a Virgin
Into the Groove
Papa Don't Preach
Open Your Heart
Live to Tell
La Isla Bonita
Like a Prayer
Express Yourself
Till Death Do Us Part
Justify My Love
Waiting
Secret Garden
Up Down Suite
Impressive Instant
Amazing
Don't Tell Me
Get Together
Future Lovers

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Icing

Tens:

Borderline
Angel
Like a Virgin
Into the Groove
Papa Don't Preach
Open Your Heart
Live to Tell
La Isla Bonita
Like a Prayer
Express Yourself
Till Death Do Us Part
Waiting
Secret Garden
Impressive Instant
Amazing
Don't Tell Me
Get Together
Future Lovers

This is actually a good list
NBesides you snubbing her best song.

[bobbymfw]

What about "Your Honesty"? "Super Pop"? "Liquid Love"?

We need to get all the B-sides in. This is gonna be a doozy.

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by Icing

Tens:

Borderline
Angel
Like a Virgin
Into the Groove
Papa Don't Preach
Open Your Heart
Live to Tell
La Isla Bonita
Like a Prayer
Express Yourself
Till Death Do Us Part
Waiting
Secret Garden
Impressive Instant
Amazing
Don't Tell Me
Get Together
Future Lovers

Angel? Amazing?

Get some taste girl.

[Icing]

Originally posted by madonnas

This is actually a good list
NBesides you snubbing her best song.

People do TOO much to her 80s singles. Their placings in the immaculate rate and your base rate were alarming. Someone's gotta do something about it.

And Human Nature is getting shot down along with Frozen FYI.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Icing

People do TOO much to her 80s singles. Their placings in the immaculate rate and your base rate were alarming. Someone's gotta do something about it.

And Human Nature is getting shot down along with Frozen FYI.

ooh well i prefer her 90s stuff the most, but she had the best singles in the 80s. I know people will not like her debut as much as me, but let's be honest, it's fantastic. burning up deserves top 5.

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by Icing

People do TOO much to her 80s singles. Their placings in the immaculate rate and your base rate were alarming. Someone's gotta do something about it.

And Human Nature is getting shot down along with Frozen FYI.

Human Nature terminates Amazing on a mild day.

[Icing]

Amazing is better than Human Nature and I'll Forget combined, times two.

[Dream]

Originally posted by bobbymfw

What about "Your Honesty"? "Super Pop"? "Liquid Love"?

We need to get all the B-sides in. This is gonna be a doozy.

Your Honesty would have been another 10 from me.

It should've been on Bedtime Stories

[ImpressiveInstant]

If Beautiful Stranger, I'm a Sinner and Amazing were Destiny's Child, Amazing would be Michelle Williams.

[Dream]

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

If Beautiful Stranger, I'm a Sinner and Amazing were Destiny's Child, Amazing would be Michelle Williams.

No they would all be Michelle Williams.

None of those songs are very good. A 6 or 7 at most for each of them.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

If Beautiful Stranger, I'm a Sinner and Amazing were Destiny's Child, Amazing would be Michelle Williams.

oh god, according to my scores Beyonce is I'm a Sinner....

I'm going to have to edit some of my scores.


and I probably might bump up some of her 80s material, because Icing reminded me people on ATRL hate it.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Dream

No they would all be Michelle Williams.

None of those songs are very good. A 6 or 7 at most for each of them.

beautiful stranger and i'm a sinner are good.

[Dream]

Originally posted by madonnas

beautiful stranger and i'm a sinner are good.

I'm a Sinner is a 5 and Beautiful Stranger is a 6.

Well at least that what I gave them anyway

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by madonnas

oh god, according to my scores Beyonce is I'm a Sinner....

I'm going to have to edit some of my scores.


and I probably might bump up some of her 80s material, because Icing reminded me people on ATRL hate it.

I'm giving True Blue FOUR tens again. All of them really deserved.

I'm not sure if the previous two albums will get the same privilege.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

I'm giving True Blue FOUR tens again. All of them really deserved.

I'm not sure if the previous two albums will get the same privilege.

I think both got two 10s from me, but self titled had a much greater average.

[Blueberry Mary]

Originally posted by jose168

guuurl and madonnas in your sig?

well better late than never, i hope TDDUP goes far

Originally posted by Tainted Blood

And Madonna is in your sig? What kind of flop fan

I know

I only became a fan recently and only knew ROL - MDNA + The Immaculate Collection + a lot of her other singles