[Icing]

Sent.

Confessions on a Dance Floor - 8.3
Love.Angel.Music.Baby - 7.83
Breakaway - 6.75
The Emancipation of Mimi - 6.5

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Auren

It really drags.

Can't agree with any more than I do right now.

Finally hearing it in full, I'm extra pissed it beat Gwen and FIONA in Pop Album.

[Kool_Aid_King]

Originally posted by Navin

I swear to ****ing god if you gave Isaac anything lower than a 7...

I gave it a 0. I hated everything about the song. The only song I gave a 0 in the entire rate.



ILNY was the highest from COADF with a 9.

[Icing]

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

I gave it a 0. I hated everything about the song. The only song I gave a 0 in the entire rate.



ILNY was the highest from COADF with a 9.

[Kool_Aid_King]

Originally posted by Icing

[Kool_Aid_King]

Originally posted by Rolland

This should start right now. I'm ready for Madonna to take this.

Not with my ratings.

And yeah, start this early! I doubt anyone else is gonna join this.

24 is more than enough

[Jameson Teqkilla]

Alright, alright, I'll finally listen to Kelly and Mimi 2night...or tomorrow morning.

[Taigan]

Originally posted by Icing

I have three songs left on Breakaway. Pray for me.

I'm praying for you girl. I'm surprised that you aren't already slayed by the fact that Kelly's vocals are more powerful and beautiful than most of the pop girls out today. That's why she's just come off a number one song on BB Breakaway is the perfect pop album. Don't be a hater, just Walk Away

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Taigan

I'm praying for you girl. I'm surprised that you aren't already slayed by the fact that Kelly's vocals are more powerful and beautiful than most of the pop girls out today. That's why she's just come off a number one song on BB Breakaway is the perfect pop album. Don't be a hater, just Walk Away

This is ... perilously close to stanning.

Just want you to know!

[Taigan]

Originally posted by madonnas

I think I gave it an 9 or 8.....
I just hope everyone trashes all the Kelly/Mariah ballads... they're really awful.

Funny cause Because of You (a ballad) was critically and commercially lauded, and a lot credit it for playing a large role Breakaway (the album) winning two Grammy's. You must be out of the loop. There's no way Madonna or Gwen could pull off a song like BOY, you need really powerful, emotive vocals for that. At least Madonna can dance though, right

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Taigan

Funny cause Because of You (a ballad) was critically and commercially lauded, and a lot credit it for playing a large role Breakaway (the album) winning two Grammy's. You must be out of the loop. There's no way Madonna or Gwen could pull off a song like BOY, you need really powerful, emotive vocals for that. At least Madonna can dance though, right

Oh yeah, you're a stan who doesn't understand the concept of a rate.

Oh yeah, I'll save you from yourself.

[@michael]

Thread bans are becoming a bit too common! First the Christina rate, now this!

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by @michael.

Thread bans are becoming a bit too common! First the Christina rate, now this!

The Only One in Shape's rate was the first. Katie, such a trendsetter!

When obvious stans/trolls enter a rate, they stand a chance and ruining it for the rest of us. They're the type to report others, and moderators who don't participate in these (obviously I do, and Katie/Eli/Patrick/Lipton all look on) warn. It's not fair to get warned for what you say in these threads; that limits and inhibits real conversation.

So threadbans for all that try it!

[madonnas]

Wait somebody reported my post?

Am I in danger for voicing my opinion as facts?

[Rolland]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Oh yeah, you're a stan who doesn't understand the concept of a rate.

Oh yeah, I'll save you from yourself.

Did I act and look like that in Xtina's rate?
Please, tell me I didn't.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Rolland

Did I act and look like that in Xtina's rate?
Please, tell me I didn't.

Although you DID try it with supaspaz ...

... for the most part you were sane. Obvious about your love for Christina, but sane.

Some of these Kelly stans ...

[MJ Boston]

This is going to be too difficult.

I have to listen to most of Gwen & Mariah's albums. I need to make a fair rating.. all of these albums have some seriously good tracks on them. oyyyyy I don't know if I can do it. lol

[Rolland]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Although you DID try it with supaspaz ...

... for the most part you were sane. Obvious about your love for Christina, but sane.

Some of these Kelly stans ...

That's such a relief!


IKR, let them enjoy their moment.
I love you Ace, for reasons unknown.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Addicted

Wait which Kelly stans?

As far as I know I rated everything fairly and havent said anything out of order in this thread.

You're good!

But that Taipen thing was troll of great import.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Although you DID try it with supaspaz ...

... for the most part you were sane. Obvious about your love for Christina, but sane.

Some of these Kelly stans ...

Ace, I really don't comprehend your dislike for Kelly stans. The one stan was merely presenting a counter point to the semi Kelly bashing that you and some of your peers were indulging in. What kinda bias?

My rating turned out as:
Kelly>Madonna>>>Mariah>>>>>>Gwen

Gwen has such good songs but some were less than pleasant to listen to