[chris1991]

Originally posted by Amaru

Britney stan's have no right to call Gaga's 3rd era forgettable when Britney's 3rd era is was paid dust by radio and stans alike.

Aside from Slave 4 U, Britney (The Album) will remain unused.

Nope! You see that's the magic of Britney Spears. She didn't need to have the huge smashes and all those #1. To cause and impact in music and out of music. She was bigger than just singles! Have you not seen the sales of Britney!
Our current girls albums would tank without a successful single!

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Mister Martian

Only because she had over 200 dates. If you wanna look at averages, Britney's Circus tour was a much better sale...

We can discuss debut tours...

[JonnyϟLightning]

Originally posted by mariska

If we're going to completely ignore The Fame Monster.. then yes. She did.
The Fame sold like 4.5 million in a calendar year. It didn't sell an additional 6 million until The Fame Monster rolled around.

We'll add The Fame and it's supporting EP. After all it was all one (1) era.

[Chickenchiki]

I'm not a girl, not yet a woman and Overprotected are classics in my country

[Mr.Dream]

No, cause Gaga's peak is bigger than Britney's peak.

[JonnyϟLightning]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

We can discuss debut tours...

Yes, we can.

[2AM]

Britney's Circus Tour grossed over 130 million in 97 dates. Gaga, while she grossed more, had over twice the amount of dates.

[Glamazon]

Originally posted by mariska

Rihanna hasn't done anything iconic. Rihanna's biggest hit Umbrella isn't even that iconic.

I mean

[Amaru]

Originally posted by Katie

Anticipating wasn't even a US single, and I don't think I Love Rock n Roll was either. Wasn't that when she was blacklisted from the radio? Even still, that's why I said Gaga was the bigger success.

I don't know I just got it from Wiki

I agree with you, think both girls were music phenomenons their own right.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by JonnyϟLightning

Yes, we can.

We can discuss TMB's gross > Britney's first four tours.

[Sushi]

Comparing impact is nearly impossible.

But one thing is for sure: They were both on top of the music world at their peaks.

Gaga is the biggest thing since Britney, and there has not been anyone bigger or as big since after Gaga's "peak" of TFM.

[fineandbambi]

Originally posted by chris1991

I feel like this should be about rihanna!
She might not have had the huge impact so early but she defiantly huge!

Rihanna and her music represent our current generation more so than Gagas. Her fashion, hair, and music are the most wanted since Umbrella. girls want to be her, guys wants to be with her. While gaga only gets most f her praise from the music industry/Grammys.

Rihanna is only getting bigger and seems like she will transend into other generations just like Britney doesn't today. Just looks at we found love 9weeka at #1. Who would have thought

Wait a second...

[Glamazon]

Originally posted by JonnyϟLightning

Yes, we can.

[KitKat]

There's no way to correctly compare finite things like sales, charts, and so on. They debuted too far apart for that to happen. It's only possible to look at the big picture and make general claims. They're from different times, and were completely different people when they debuted.

[Donny]

Originally posted by JonnyϟLightning

Yes, we can.

Oh Jonny

[i spit on haters]

Originally posted by Mr.Dream

No, cause Gaga's peak is bigger than Britney's peak.

...No...it's not. Even some of Gaga's own stans have said in this thread it isn't.

[Mister Martian]

Originally posted by ElectricFrancis

Well , you are right, but you can't compare the early 2000's with 2011's US album sales

[Donny]

Originally posted by Katie

There's no way to correctly compare finite things like sales, charts, and so on. They debuted too far apart for that to happen. It's only possible to look at the big picture and make general claims. They're from different times, and were completely different people when they debuted.

Pretty much all of this!

[Glamazon]

Originally posted by Sushi

Comparing impact is nearly impossible.

But one thing is for sure: They were both on top of the music world at their peaks.

Gaga is the biggest thing since Britney, and there has not been anyone bigger or as big since after Gaga's "peak" of TFM.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by JonnyϟLightning

We'll add The Fame and it's supporting EP. After all it was all one (1) era.

Then in market context that 16m she sold from TF(M) would be far and away a more impressive album performance than any numbers Britney put up.