I'd rather be with a normal guy and that is a guy who doesn't look like someone who spends 10 hours a day at the gym working out.
You may have your preferences, but don't come knocking ours... Lol. There's a reason people like men who are physically fit. Many people are attracted most to men who seem healthy and who seem strong/able to protect themselves and the ones they love. A man with muscles (as long as he isn't TOO muscular) gives off the image of being just that. You can have your "normal guys," and most of us probably won't end up with a guy who looks like a male model, but don't try to rip our fantasies away from us.