[JaiTina]

Originally posted by missy

DIRRTY! Better song for getting riled up and partying. If you're just listening to the song itself, it caters to a wider audience. It's a little more vague in lyrics... it's about partying in a trashy way, not completely about sex. Actually, the most sexual lyric is "give all you got, just hit the spot" but the rest is about dancing on tables and clothing choices, etc. I listen to it all the time and it still makes me want to dance. People go crazy for this in the clubs still. I hear it while shopping all the time, strangely...

Slave 4 U lyrics are just too sexy. It's more vulgar than Dirrty. Am I the only one who has to dive for my mp3 player when I'm with a group of people and this song comes on? I mean, if you have kids or older adults around, it's just too sexy. Great bedroom material. I ****ing LOVE it, but it's very submissive and there's just a lot of moaning and not all of us are so ... yielding. I just didn't REALIZE it as much as a kid but now I just can't ignore it lol. For that reason alone, the fact that I'm mildly embarrassed to have it come on at random times because ain't nobody got time for playlists, makes me pick Dirrty.

They're both classics imo and absolute gems though.



Dirrty beat Slave just last year on the VH1 Most Scandalous Sexy Music Videos of All Times list .

Clock them

Originally posted by dirrtydiana

But people don't even know dirrty was performed at the 2003 vmas

Who cares about where it was performed. Its still the better song.
I mean, this month alone so far, I've heard Dirrty in 2 clubs I've attended. Heard it on the radio once.. People still stan and get down to it and I sl*t drop everytime I hear it tbh

Slave for you remains unbothered with since early 2000's

[castle13]

Dirrty

[conatus]

dirrty but only just

[Legacy]

Damn it's hard!
I vote for I'm A Slave 4 U tho, everything about it is just so iconic

[frashcoholic]

Slave
Glee didn't lie that it's the Iconic one

[dirrtydiana]

Originally posted by JaiTina

Clock them



Who cares about where it was performed. Its still the better song.
I mean, this month alone so far, I've heard Dirrty in 2 clubs I've attended. Heard it on the radio once.. People still stan and get down to it and I sl*t drop everytime I hear it tbh

Slave for you remains unbothered with since early 2000's

Your logic slave is not as vulgar as dirrty and slave is more about dancing and being enslaved to the music.

I heard slave at a club last night. And I hear it numerous of times when I go out. I may have heard dirrty once at a gay club but that's it. People still choreograph routines at competitions for Slave.

Anyway, I love both but slave is superior.

[Sooyoung]

Dirrty.

It is still a fixture of club sets in the UK for their something-more-urban segments.

[Jonathan]

Dirrty

[teen-idle]

Not Xtina fans once again using recurrent airplay as a test to a song's longevity, that don't mean sh*t.

Both weren't flops either, USA doesn't equal the rest of the world. Anyway I prefer Dirrty, that song was HUGE in the UK. Everyone from Grandma's, to parents and even little kids were popping their sh*t to that song. It's my favourite Xtina track aswell, everyone of a certain age remembers X's Stripped era. Slave 4 U is great aswell, Britney should really get back in the studio with the Neptunes, the video was always on TV to.

[TikiMiss]

Dirrty song.
Slave video.

[B-Luke]

IAS4U turns gays into straights. Dirrty turns peaceable soccer moms into furious bitches.

[Nano]

I love them both, but Slave.

[Penny.]

omg @this thread randomly popping back up


i still prefer Dirrty

[Pristine]

I picked Dirrty. Masterpiece and it didnt flop everywhere, it was no1 all over Europe and stays her signature hit in the UK.