I'm That Chick wouldve flopped badly.. It is annoying as hell. You need to listen from an urban perspective. Most people over here are top 40/dance fans and they do not appreciate this kind of music, they are used to fast upbeat songs.. An R&B lover on the other hands welcomes this with open arms, cause this is real old school r&B!
It's generic, though. I love older R&B (hell, I like it more than older pop), but it needs to not-suck.