| |
Rate the American Idols: Season 5!
Member Since: 5/3/2003
Posts: 8,091
|
What is this big obsession with Vonzell? She was ugly and didn't deserve to win. Thats the end of it. The beautiful, and much better singer won that year 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/14/2004
Posts: 82
|
1. Taylor
2. Ace
3. Elliott
4. Geoden
5. Chris
BOTTOM THREE
6. Kevin
7. Will
8. Bucky
WHO SHOULD GO
Will
Bucky
WHO WILL GO
Will Bucky
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
I don't care much about the males, so I'll just do a rank and rating.
1) Elliot: 8.5
2) Ace: 8.0
3) Chris: 8.0
4) Will: 6.0
5) Gedeon: 5.0
---
6) Bucky: 4.0
7) Kevin: 2.0
8) Taylor: 0.0
Should be bottom 3: Bucky, Kevin, Taylor
Should be going home: Kevin, Taylor
Will be bottom 3: Bucky, Kevin, Will
Will be going home: Bucky, Kevin
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/19/2004
Posts: 13,032
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by .:Froggert:.
What is this big obsession with Vonzell? She was ugly and didn't deserve to win. Thats the end of it. The beautiful, and much better singer won that year |
Umm....
No.
1. Taylor
2.Ace
3. Elliot
4. Gedeon
5. Chris
6. Bucky
---LOSERS?---
7. Will
8. Kevin
Who should go home: Will & Kevin
Who will go home: Bucky * Kevin
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by .:Froggert:.
What is this big obsession with Vonzell? She was ugly and didn't deserve to win. Thats the end of it. The beautiful, and much better singer won that year |
Part 1: Matter of opinion (You only think she was ugly because she was black, I bet  ) (She was cute, too)
Part 2: Matter of opinion (I think she did)
Part 3: Matter of opinion (She's nothing spectacular)
Part 4: Matter of opinion (She was one of the worst singers in the top 24)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/30/2002
Posts: 3,522
|
I think this might just be a guy's year..
1. Taylor - Taylor Hicks definitely has some kind of palsy or something. Aside from the dancing, and the bunny suit, Taylor gave the performance of the night.
2. Chris - Oh, how I hoped he was going to do Seether's "Fine Again." Although I hated how Seether performed "Broken," Chris would've made me even remotely like the song. And plus I'm all about the rock and so is he, so I'm sticking as a fan for the long run.
3. Ace - Justin Timberlake was there? Could've fooled me..Liked how Ace went from falsetto back into his normal voice. One of my favorite performances by him.
4. Elliott - Thought it was a really good song choice, but kind of agreed with Simon when he called this a copout. Hands down Elliott has the best voice in the competition, but I don't know if I see him making it far...I just think he's middle of the pack and not one with many fans
5. Kevin - Poor little Kevin. If the contestants had to sit in a box and sing with no movement at all, Kevin would definitely shine. But he NEVER moves on stage and he's way too nervous. I'm just a big fan and I hope he makes it through tomorrow night..
6. Gedeon - Alright, Gedeon gave a good performance, but I just don't like the guy. And I will say it over and over again. I don't know what it is, but something about this guy IRKS the living hell out of me..
7. Will - A personal favorite of mine, but boy was he off tonight. Had a good song, but did nothing with it..
8. Bucky - Bye.
Should be bottom 3: Bucky, Will, and Gedeon
Should be 2 going home: Will and Bucky
Will be bottom 3: Kevin, Will, and Bucky
Will be 2 going home: Kevin and Will 
|
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 11/16/2004
Posts: 28,450
|
1) Elliott
2) Chris
3) Will
4) Ace
5) Taylor
6) Gideon
7) Bucky
8) Kevin
Bottom 3: Gideon Bucky Kevin
Goodbye Kevin and Bucky
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/6/2005
Posts: 17,088
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by .:Froggert:.
What is this big obsession with Vonzell? She was ugly and didn't deserve to win. Thats the end of it. The beautiful, and much better singer won that year |
I beg to differ sir! Every performance she did after "Best Of My Love" was AMAZING! She stepped up her game and was much better than Bo, but she did get really far. I love her, too, I thought she was cute...
1. Taylor
You guys didn't like that? What the ----? That was great!
2. Elliot
He's good but that song, meh, I thought he played it safe but, yeah, it was awesome still.
3. Ace
I guess you could say it was hot. He stepped up his game and did it awesome. Michael old school ^_^
4. Chris
God I've always hated that song. Regardless, he's awesome, so this is up there. But WOW, this song I hate more and more every time I hear it. lol
5. Bucky
I'm starting to like Bucky! He's getting way more consistent and I don't dislike him as much as I did two weeks ago!
6. Gedeon
This isn't even bad! But it was a little dull for me, even though I am pretty young so maybe more people other than me were interested in this.
7. Will
Well, after last week, I thought he may have had the chance to leave, but this is more the reason to let him go, AMERICA. Paula, shut the f.uck up and stop begging your boyfriend to stay in the damn game when you know there are WAAAAAAAAAAY more talented people in the game!
8. Kevin
Yes, Paula. We all know you f.ucking love him. Dear lord, it wasn't that bad but like, okay, I was bored, and I don't think he should be in the Top 12. Even if a performance wasn't bad, think logically. Pick the best Top 12, and imagine Kevin in it... No.
Should Be Bottom 3:
Kevin, Gedeon, Will
Will Be Bottom 3:
Will, Kevin, Bucky or Gedeon
Should Be Going Home (and Will Be Going Home)
Will, Kevin
Top 12:
Mandisa, Kellie, Katharine, Lisa, Paris, Melissa or Ayla
Ace, Gedeon, Bucky, Taylor, Chris, Elliot
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/15/2001
Posts: 2,449
|
i'm ranking the girls because i thought the guys were, in general, horrendous.
1. katharine
-i think she is the best vocalist of the competition. i love how she was the only girl who didn't end up dressing like a drag queen. simple is sometimes better.
2. mandisa
-this girl can definitely sing. she's one of my favorites. but i liked katharine more tonight.
*GAP*
3. lisa
-she's so cute. she can definitely sing. i actually liked this song choice. i could see how it would make sense to sing it in this competition. but it was pretty boring otherwise.
4. paris
-paris is one of my favorites too. but this was probably her worst week.
-gap-
5. kellie
-i like the song. her personality seems genuine to me. i don't think she's a great singer but her performance was entertaining.
6. melissa
-i thought she sang fairly well. i liked this song. her best performance. she's leaving idol with a bang. umm but yeah she looked like a man.
7. ayla
-this was a horrible song choice. fun song, yes, but not the right song to sing at idol. it was entertaining, again, but not impressive. and can someone please explain to me what she was wearing??
8. kinnik
-umm horrible. and kinnik is definitely a man. i hate this girl more than trenyce.
who i'd want to go home: kinnik, ayla
who will go home: kinnik, melissa
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/3/2003
Posts: 8,091
|
Taylor #1? Wow and it isn't even april fools yet. I honestly wish, hope I guess I should say, that he died of a heart attack on air. He just falls backward on stage, his head cracks open, and the blood is everywhere. Thats how bad I hate him. I really wish he was dead.
Tonight was atrocious
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
8 More Levels of Manly Hell
Gedion (5/10) Of course. Now HE can't start a song. Regresses back to smarmy ass he was two weeks ago. Not that great thing at all.
Chris (5/10) Yep, his voice is shot. Rather bland as well. Try not SCREAMING to save what remains of your pipes.
Will (2/10) Lord, how boring you are anyways. Anyways, lets discuss the suckage of this. So David left last week, and he picks up the affected **** nonsense. Go home.
Kevin (2/10) ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ. And looking more lost and forced at gunpoint than at any point, with more vibratto than need be. Can we send you home?
Bucky (1/10) WHAT? After making progress last week, lets spin backwards to unhearableness. Not like you had a chance anyways, but whatever.
Taylor (1/10) I hope to God that's a mic problem he had, cuz otherwise that was evil. I personally hate that song and he sounded flat and at times shouty. And why is he doing some old 60s girlgroup dancesteps and handswinging at the hips.
Elliot (0/10) Heaven?! HEAVEN?! The hell is wrong with you? He was under the song the entire time, failed trying to hold a note TWICE. And deciding to pull out the hearing loss NOW is such a try to save himself.
Ace (0/10) Ow. STOP IT. No more falsetto, dumbass. Lord, warbling, falsetto, off key screetching. Ladies and Gents, welcome the CHOSEN ONE to the final 12.
Should Be Gone: Ace, Elliot
GO THE ---- AWAY, JESUS!: All of them. Yep. Such suck!
But We Already Know Who's Leaving: Bucky, Kevin
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
OK, I'm not kidding when I say this but I can relate to Elliot. I also have a hearing loss in one of my ears. (In my left ear, and I think its about an 90%/Complete loss.) Very intresting to me, and I pretty much sucked at telephone too.
Allright,
This should be easy: The joke's up, Kevin needs to go. Followed by Will.
With that 1st Vote = Chris 2nd Vote = Elliot. Then I gotta go study for my Math test.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 1/5/2002
Posts: 11,088
|
1. Will i love you and i voted lots
2. Taylor
3. Chris
4. Gedion
5. Bucky
6. Kevin
7. Elliot
8. Ace
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by .:Froggert:.
What is this big obsession with Vonzell? She was ugly and didn't deserve to win. Thats the end of it. The beautiful, and much better singer won that year |
Wow, no, shes not ugly, and did deserve to win.
Carrie was not a better singer, granted I like her more than Bo, VonZell was better than her.
Anyways...
01. Chris - 9/10
02. Elliot - 8/10
03. Gideon - 7/10
04. Ace - 6/10
05. Bucky - 6/10
06. Will - 6/10
07. Taylor - 6/10
08. Kevin - 4/10 (WHATS WITH THE F-IN LISP!)
Should Go
Taylor and Kevin
Will Go
Bucky and Kevin
|
|
|
|
ATRL Administrator
Member Since: 6/29/2002
Posts: 77,601
|
Gedeon: 8.5
Ace: 8.5
Chris: 7.8
Elliott: 6.5
Kevin: 5.5
Bucky: 3.2
Will: 3.0
Taylor: 3.0
Top 16:
1. Paris: 25.3 (=)
2. Ayla: 22.6 (=)
3. Mandisa: 22.4 (+1)
4. Melissa: 22.3 (+1)
5. Lisa: 21.8 (-2)
6. Kinnik: 20.5 (=)
7. Gedeon: 20.4 (+3)
8. Katherine: 19.7 (-1)
9. Chris: 19.7 (+2)
10. Ace: 19.6 (+3)
11. Elliott: 19.1 (-3)
12. Kellie: 18.8 (=)
13. Taylor: 15.5 (-4)
14. Kevin: 13.7 (+2)
15. Will: 13.0 (-1)
16. Bucky: 11.6 (-1)
|
|
|
|
ATRL Moderator
Member Since: 11/16/2004
Posts: 28,450
|
Starting my top 12:
1) Katharine
2) Chris
3) Mandisa
4) Lisa
5) Elliott
6) Paris
7) Ace
8)Taylor
9) Kellie
10) Melissa
11) Bucky
12) Kevin
|
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
Rank'em 24 - Week 3
Ok...so now they all suck balls. Anyways:
01. Paris (NC)
02. Mandisa (+3)
*then a gap the size of the continential USA*
03. Melissa (NC)
*jump over Russia, Canada, and China, then you'll find*
04. Chris (NC)
05. Elliot (+3)
*My own personal level of hell*
06. Bucky (+1)
07. Katherine (+3)
08. Lisa (-1)
09. Taylor (+1)
*Deserves Having Vocal Chords Slit to NEVER SING AGAIN*
10. Kevin (+4)
11. Kellie (+4)
12. Ace (+4)
13. Gedion
14. Kinnik
15. Ayla
16. Patrick
17. Will
18. Becky
19. Stevie
20. David
21. Heather
22. Brenna
23. Bobby
24. "Sway"
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/3/2004
Posts: 6,932
|
The ones that have at least an ounce of talent:
1) Mandisa
2) Paris
3) Katharine
4) Elliot
5) Chris
6) Ace
7) Melissa
8) Lisa
---
You'll be gone early, as you deserve:
9) Bucky
10) Kevin
---
This is what I call Hell:
11) Kellie
12) Taylor
---
13) Kinnik
14) Will
15) Becky
16) Stevie
17) Brenna
18) Gedeon
19) Sway
20) Patrick
21) Ayla
22) Heather
23) David
24) Bobby
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
It really sucked to see Gideon get the Daniel Powter jam on him.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/30/2002
Posts: 3,522
|
Top 12:
1. Chris
2. Katharine
3. Kellie
4. Ace
5. Kevin
6. Taylor
7. Mandisa
8. Elliott
9. Melissa
10. Lisa
11. Bucky
12. Paris
|
|
|
|
|
|
