This is the first time i've heard anything about Judas's directing or editing. I never saw a problem with it, but I guess if you look at it some shots were definitely shot awkwardly. Like the motorcycle scene. And actually a lot of people could not get the message behind the video, i'm only punching fun at you.
Oh... I'm always talking about how she needs professional directors and stuff.
It's not very hard to understand... but I guess you're right.
Edit: This website that reviewed Gaga's album said it was their biggest dissapointment this year and then they said
"what Lady Gaga did wrong was release an album with too little filler. I sometimes think we judge her by a harsher standard than we do our other popstars."