[stoopidjenna]

#10 for Addicted is fair I think, but it deserves to higher than several of the songs left...

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by Chivas

It's about damn time Addicted went. Let Me Down should be next.

Agreed. Followed by You Love Me. That needs to get the **** out before the top 5.

[Jaymz]

Originally posted by Addicted

The Ultimate Kelly Clarkson Rate!

#15 You Love Me

239.6 Points - 8.5 Average Rating.

Highest Rating: 10 - Bathomet, KevinKDC, Mzd
Lowest Rating: 6.5 - MJ0497

#14 Dont Let Me Stop You

240.9 Points - 8.6 Average Rating.

Highest Rating: 10 - Bathomet, FAN
Lowest Rating: 5 - Sexy Boy

#13 The Day We Fell Apart

244.3 Points - 8.7 Average Rating.

Highest Rating: 10 - Bathomet, FAN, Kosmos, Erik, Heisenberg, jpsketch
Lowest Rating: 6.5 - supertiffany

#12 Cry

247.9 Points - 8.8 Average Rating.

Highest Rating: 10 - Jetsetter, Addicted, FAN, Kosmos, Mzd, jpsketch
Lowest Rating: 6 - Sexy Boy

#11 Never Again

249.4 Points - 8.9 Average Rating.

Highest Rating: 10 - FAN, Hot December, supertiffany, Mr. Know It All, Kosmos, Erik, KevinKDC, jpsketch
Lowest Rating: 7 - lpd446

---

Songs Out So Far

75. What’s Up Lonely – 149.3
74.Thankful – 155.9
73.Some Kind Of Miracle - 159.5
72. Yeah – 160.7
71. Standing In Front Of You – 170
70. Before Your Love – 172.7
69. I Hate Myself For Losing You – 174
68. Whyyawannabringmedown – 181.9
67. Don’t Waste Your Time – 184.3
66. If Noone Will Listen – 184.3
65. Be Still – 187.9
64. Not Today – 193
63. Hole – 193.4
62. Can I Have A Kiss – 194.2
61. Judas – 194.5
60. The Trouble With Love Is – 195.3
59. Dirty Little Secret – 197
58. Where Is Your Heart – 198.2
57. I Want You – 199
56. One Minute – 199.5
55. Beautiful Disaster – 199.8
54. Why Don’t You Try – 200.1
53. Einstein – 201.4
52. Breaking Your Own Heart – 204.3
51. You Thought Wrong – 204.5
50. Don’t Be A Girl About It – 205.1
49. Fading – 206
48. Low – 206.3
47. A Moment Like This – 207.6
46. Just Missed The Train – 208.3
45. Chivas – 208.9
44. Anytime – 209.2
43. Impossible – 209.6
42. Ready – 212.7
41. All I Ever Wanted – 213.2
40. I Forgive You – 213.6
39. You Can’t Win – 213.9
38. I Do Not Hook Up – 214
37. Save You – 216.2
36. Don’t You Wanna Stay – 216.9
35. Haunted – 217.3
34.How I Feel – 217.8
33. Hello – 218
32. Irvine – 218.6
31. You Found Me – 219.2
30. The Sun Will Rise – 221.8
29. Tip Of My Tongue – 222
28. Alone – 223.9
27. Long Shot – 224
26. If I Can’t Have You – 224.7
25. Hear Me – 225.9
24. Walk Away – 226.1
23. Mr. Know It All – 231.5
22. Honestly – 232.2
21. The War Is Over – 232.6
20. Miss Independent – 235.8
19. Gone – 236.1
18. Breakaway – 236.8
17. Maybe – 238.5
16. Can We Go Back – 239.5
15. You Love Me – 239.6
14. Don’t Let Me Stop You – 240.9
13.The Day We Fell Apart – 244.3
12. Cry – 247.9
11. Never Again – 249.4

---

Songs Left

Thankful: 0

Breakaway: 4
Since U Been Gone
Behind These Hazel Eyes
Because Of You
Addicted

My December: 1
Sober

All I Ever Wanted: 2
My Life Would Suck Without You
Already Gone

Stronger: 3
Stronger (What Doesnt Kill You)
Dark Side
Let Me Down

So these just missed out on the top 10! Thoughts?
Predictions for top 10?

Death at Sober making the top 10

[Taigan]

Originally posted by Chivas

It's about damn time Addicted went. Let Me Down should be next.

Motion to have Cry take LMD's place!!!!

We should have a vote in base. The song that wins will be top 10.

[stoopidjenna]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Agreed. Followed by You Love Me. That needs to get the **** out before the top 5.

YLM is already out boo.

[Jaymz]

Well done Addicted.... you deserve a place in the top 10... unlike Sober

Here's how it should go

09 Sober
08 Already Gone
07 Dark Side
06 My Life Would Suck Without You
05 Let Me Down
04 Because Of You
03 Stronger
02 Behind These Hazel Eyes
01 Since U Been Gone

[MJ Boston]

Originally posted by Taigan

Utterly delusional... I'm not here for SUBG pt 2 with a lesser chorus. LMD has much more substance, and is catchier.

Cry should have been in there instead of LMD, agreed on that point

Wait. LMD is a complete knock off of DLMSY which is a somewhat knock off of SUBG/BTHE so I'm not following your logic here. lol

DLMSY and LMD are almost interchangeable they're so similar. But DLMSY totally trumps it.

I'm not saying it's a fresh and amazing song that deserves top 10.. just top 10 over LMD for sure. It's definitely outdated now.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Death. I think Sober or Already Gone should leave. I love the other singles to much to have them leave...I think they all got 10s except BOY, and AG...

[jpsketch]

Originally posted by Jaymz

Well done Addicted.... you deserve a place in the top 10... unlike Sober

Here's how it should go

09 Sober
08 Already Gone
07 Dark Side
06 My Life Would Suck Without You
05 Let Me Down
04 Because Of You
03 Stronger
02 Behind These Hazel Eyes
01 Since U Been Gone

Stop.

[Jaymz]

Originally posted by jpsketch

Stop.

When are you going to accept that it is going to happen... are you the person who thought Maybe was gonna hit the number one spot or am I confusing you with someone else...??

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by jpsketch

Stop.

Even Kelly is defending her #1 song. I suggest you back down.

[MJ Boston]

I think it'll be:

9.) Let Me Down
8.) Dark Side
7.) Already Gone
6.) Sober
5.) My Life Would Suck Without You
4.) Stronger
3.) Because Of You
2.) Since U Been Gone
1.) Behind These Hazel Eyes

[Lippy]

Nice! Addicted was the worst of the top 10

[esteee12]

LET ME DOWN SHOULD REPLACE CRY. OHMYGODZ!!!!!!!!! if lmd is that awesome, why glee prefer to cover cry instead of lmd? flop rates!

[stoopidjenna]

How I would rank it:
9) MLWSWY
8) LMD
7) BTHE
6) AG
5) WDKY
4) BOY
3) SUBG
2) DS
1) Sober

Meh fair enough, even I think LMD may be high, MLSWY needs to get out though.

[esteee12]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Even Kelly is defending her #1 song. I suggest you back down.

The US billboard chart didnt agree with it tho.

[jpsketch]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Even Kelly is defending her #1 song. I suggest you back down.

It never went #1.

[Jaymz]

Originally posted by Addicted

The Ultimate Kelly Clarkson Rate!

Time for the top 10 songs rated by ATRL. Coming in at #9... Too high in my opinion

#9 Let Me Down

250.9 Points - 8.9 Average Rating.

Highest Rating: 10 - dreclarkson, Bathomet, FAN, lpd446, Hot December, supertiffany, stoopidjenna, Kosmos, KevinKDC, Mzd
Lowest Rating: 6.5 - tell_me_a_lie

---

Songs Out So Far

75. What’s Up Lonely – 149.3
74.Thankful – 155.9
73.Some Kind Of Miracle - 159.5
72. Yeah – 160.7
71. Standing In Front Of You – 170
70. Before Your Love – 172.7
69. I Hate Myself For Losing You – 174
68. Whyyawannabringmedown – 181.9
67. Don’t Waste Your Time – 184.3
66. If Noone Will Listen – 184.3
65. Be Still – 187.9
64. Not Today – 193
63. Hole – 193.4
62. Can I Have A Kiss – 194.2
61. Judas – 194.5
60. The Trouble With Love Is – 195.3
59. Dirty Little Secret – 197
58. Where Is Your Heart – 198.2
57. I Want You – 199
56. One Minute – 199.5
55. Beautiful Disaster – 199.8
54. Why Don’t You Try – 200.1
53. Einstein – 201.4
52. Breaking Your Own Heart – 204.3
51. You Thought Wrong – 204.5
50. Don’t Be A Girl About It – 205.1
49. Fading – 206
48. Low – 206.3
47. A Moment Like This – 207.6
46. Just Missed The Train – 208.3
45. Chivas – 208.9
44. Anytime – 209.2
43. Impossible – 209.6
42. Ready – 212.7
41. All I Ever Wanted – 213.2
40. I Forgive You – 213.6
39. You Can’t Win – 213.9
38. I Do Not Hook Up – 214
37. Save You – 216.2
36. Don’t You Wanna Stay – 216.9
35. Haunted – 217.3
34.How I Feel – 217.8
33. Hello – 218
32. Irvine – 218.6
31. You Found Me – 219.2
30. The Sun Will Rise – 221.8
29. Tip Of My Tongue – 222
28. Alone – 223.9
27. Long Shot – 224
26. If I Can’t Have You – 224.7
25. Hear Me – 225.9
24. Walk Away – 226.1
23. Mr. Know It All – 231.5
22. Honestly – 232.2
21. The War Is Over – 232.6
20. Miss Independent – 235.8
19. Gone – 236.1
18. Breakaway – 236.8
17. Maybe – 238.5
16. Can We Go Back – 239.5
15. You Love Me – 239.6
14. Don’t Let Me Stop You – 240.9
13.The Day We Fell Apart – 244.3
12. Cry – 247.9
11. Never Again – 249.4
10. Addicted – 250.6
9. Let Me Down – 250.9

---

Songs Left

Thankful: 0

Breakaway: 3
Since U Been Gone
Behind These Hazel Eyes
Because Of You

My December: 1
Sober

All I Ever Wanted: 2
My Life Would Suck Without You
Already Gone

Stronger: 2
Stronger (What Doesnt Kill You)
Dark Side

But wait... I Forgive You #40..... Let Me Down #9........... #oop #teamLMD

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! How can Kelly's next single chart so low like that

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by stoopidjenna

How I would rank it:
9) MLWSWY
8) LMD
7) BTHE
6) AG
5) WDKY
4) BOY
3) SUBG
2) DS
1) Sober

Stop. MLWSWY is glorious. It's my third most played Kelly song. And thank god LMD is finally. Should have only been in top 20 tbh. AG next!

[Jaymz]

Originally posted by jpsketch

It never went #1.

I think he means number one on this list...