[JonnyϟLightning]

Originally posted by Shinning

The song reached it's peak position after the video premiered. It was insanely hyped and talked-about. It's also regarded as one the most memorable videos of both artists

Maybe Beyonce, but not Gaga lol. Bad Romance is her most memorable video.
And of course a song is gonna get bigger after a video, what kinda logic?

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by KRL

I meant the dialogues. it would have been awkward like this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZMjKwYzVpk

Not much worse than the car scene.

[Boomer]

Originally posted by Praise Mariallah

That **** would've sounded weird.

And that's what I most care about. Would've sounded a fool. And I could only imagine the video...

[Benjamin]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

She's not a big force there because she didn't properly promote her music with the last era. The opening sales of Circus and the chart performance for "Womanizer" was good because it received a proper release assisted with worthwhile promotion (The X Factor).

Oh, didn't know the album as a whole done well. I know Womanizer peaked at like #3 with The X Factor and none of the other singles done anything worth mentioning.

Just noticed that the first most pretty much specifies the US, so my answer is Yes, with no comment on the Worldwide appeal.

[JonnyϟLightning]

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

I don't think

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

I can't really imagine

oh, well I can.

[Julián]

Of course.

[BadBitch]

I don't want Gaga ever working with Britney (other than writing for her). It would seem so cliche and forced.

[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by Benjamin

Oh, didn't know the album as a whole done well. I know Womanizer peaked at like #3 with The X Factor and none of the other singles done anything worth mentioning.

Just noticed that the first most pretty much specifies the US, so my answer is Yes, with no comment on the Worldwide appeal.

The singles didn't do anything because she didn't offer much promotion. I also know she played a lot of shows at the O2 arena and I believe she held a record there until Rihanna broke it.

The best way to say it is that she could have the potential to have power in the U.K. if she promoted properly or in the long run. However, Gaga promoted the song "Telephone" so that would have made up for Britney not bothering to promote it.

[Last Boy on Earth]

Of course.

[PULSE.]

No.

How long was Telephone on itunes before it was actually released as single?

S&M was a Remix a song that no one heard that wasn't online, most ppl had Telephone months before it's release.

If the song never got out before it's release date and Gaga would have tweeted it the song would've hit #1 in the US trust.

But no biggie tho it's still the Biggest Selling Female Collabo of all time, so hey.

[Nii.]

If Britney + Bey was on it, yes.

[ChrisRTW]

Nope! Britney wouldn't add anything special to the song or video.
It was perfect the way it was.

[Chickenchiki]

Originally posted by Benjamin

Oh, didn't know the album as a whole done well. I know Womanizer peaked at like #3 with The X Factor and none of the other singles done anything worth mentioning.

Just noticed that the first most pretty much specifies the US, so my answer is Yes, with no comment on the Worldwide appeal.

Well, she only promoted Womanizer. She also broke an attendance record with the Circus tour.
And you're talking only about the UK, but overall Britney is much bigger WW. She's highly known in every country of the world, something that can't be said about Beyonce.

[csybeyking]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

Why would it have longevity? The original was already peaking on radio and the remix received no video.

I never said s&m should've had longevity

[JonnyϟLightning]

So we have all agreed that yes, it would be more successful.

Thanks for participating!

[PULSE.]

Originally posted by KRL

I meant the dialogues. it would have been awkward like this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZMjKwYzVpk

[Superbitch]

Yes you must be delusional if you think the opposite tbh.
I mean gaga was the biggest star on pop and then add the hype that surrounds Britney whenever there's a new release!!!

Edit:just remember what it did to s&m

[jinzo]

Originally posted by Dark Phoenix

Yes, Beyonce's a local act.

But it went to #1 in the UK....

[DvnR]

Originally posted by JonnyϟLightning

So we have all agreed that yes, it would be more successful.

Thanks for participating!

A 51%/49% split is not agreement.

[Starkboy]

S&M reached #1 not for Britney. It had amazing airplay + strong digital sales.
It only helped to reach it. Even with Beyoncé it would have been #1.