[madonnas]

Originally posted by RatedG²

Except for Michael Jackson

With all respect to MJ, his discography just isn't as strong.

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

"It's my birthday song
In my happy world
I know it's gonna be a good day
Oh yeah, today is my birthday."



More talented than Bethoven, tbh.

I could give you a reasonable answer, but then you said this...

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

Yes it is. So is Gaga's.

So I won't waste my time. Good night!

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by zach

Really? So 10 flawless albums get deleted because of 2 sub bar albums?

Mess

I've grown to love Hard Candy. Only 1 now

[LadyGagaStan93]

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

Ray of Light is better than Beyonce. Like a Prayer is better than Gaga. Don't make me laugh.

Originally posted by i spit on haters

Bad and laughable example.

Even though I love Beyonce I kinda thought the same in terms of writing lyrics.

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Originally posted by zach

The post was deleted

The delusion was caught rather quickly.

I'm on my iPhone and moved it to an earlier post because I don't like double posting

My opinion still stands dear.

[Shinning]

Originally posted by Muggwa

Most creative? Maybe.
Most talented? No way.

mte. She's a singer before being a dancer or a provocateur or whatever the hell she is. And as a singer she is far far far away from being the most talented popstar ever

[Alexz]

Beyoncé has ZERO good songs. And I'm not trolling. Madonna has COUNTLESS of amazing pop songs that are still played 30 years after. B will never achieve that.

[Sahn]

Originally posted by givemethatpop

Beyoncé is a good example.

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

Yes it is. So is Gaga's.

It's funny when other pop stars who've been in the industry for way shorter than Madonna get more respect because they can play an instrument or have a big voice, when in reality they couldn't do what Madonna has done.

[zach]

How is Beyonce a pop star, when she doesn't even sing pop music?

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Originally posted by Sahn

It's funny when other pop stars who've been in the industry for way shorter than Madonna get more respect because they can play an instrument or have a big voice, when in reality they couldn't do what Madonna has done.

Both of them already have though.

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by madonnas

With all respect to MJ, his discography just isn't as strong.

Oh I certainly agree. If comparing discographies, Madonna shows more talent in marketing herself, molding her music and career, etc.

But overall, when you include dance trends, performances, out-of-music lives, etc. Jackson is more talented in that respect

[Alexz]

Originally posted by madonnas

With all respect to MJ, his discography just isn't as strong.

Michael was never as prolific as Madonna. On longevity and consistency Madonna did way better.

[maldam]

Originally posted by Onen

Beyonce's music is not better than madonna's.

That's a matter of taste ,honey

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

Both of them already have though.

You're forcing me to bring up Christmas Tree's lyrics.

[zach]

Both Madonna & Michael are the most talented pop stars ever.

Anyone who doubts EITHER of them need to be taken out back...

[Onen]

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

You're calling American Life flawless?

This is why I can't take Madonna stans seriously.

She has 2-4 flawless albums.

All flawless

[Alexz]

Originally posted by zach

How is Beyonce a pop star, when she doesn't even sing pop music?

Most of her "hits" are pop songs.

[Rhythm]

Originally posted by ausread

I think Madonna is the best pop star, the most iconic, but not the most talented. Whitney had a better voice, Michael had better performances, Madonna isn't the best singer ever, or the best dancer, but she is good enough in all areas to be exceptional overall.

That's exactly what Sahn is trying to convey.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Alexz

Michael was never as prolific as Madonna. On longevity and consistency Madonna did way better.

That's what I mean by in discography. His prime musically was fairly short. Madonna has many more critically acclaimed albums than him.

(think Like a Prayer, Ray of Light, Music, Confessions and self titled verses Thriller, Off the Wall and Dangerous)

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by zach

How is Beyonce a pop star, when she doesn't even sing pop music?

A popstar is a celebrity that's easily recognized in a society or pop culture