[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

It was, in terms of rank and position:

Aretha > Tina > Whitney > Dusty > Bjork > The Devil > Mariah > Patti Smith > Mary J. Blige.

not Bjork

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by JClarkSTAN

So are you admitting that Beyonce lipped that song sis?

sHE sung it live plenty of times :celestiial4:

[Da beezness!]

Originally posted by Playboy

YES sis RUN, SCRAM and SCOOT!!!!!!! You know I'll snatch that rusty wig right off your scalp with the QUICKNESS!!!!!!






YALL WANNA PLAY?!?!?!?! jdfjgjnmsgnmmn,d

Atrocious.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

dskf,lggh
& what song was that? forreal, forreal.

The biggest non-Taylor Swift country song of the year, Don't You Wanna Stay. Robbed of a Grammy it was.

[Lipton]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

not Bjork

The Icelandic One has a superb vocal though.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

not Bjork

But Bjork DOES **** on most of the girls. Like, I'm not being funny - who has her power and range? At least a 2.5 octave range. Probably three plus.

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by satellites™

Let me tell you something, the average person think the louder someone can scream, the better a singer they are. My own grandmother had me red in the face (and im black as hell) trying to convince me that Jennifer Hudson was a better vocalist than Beyonce in 2006.

Christina fans live for her screams (so do I) but girl, it is just that..... screaming!

half of these girls think "power" means "loudness" when that isn't what power means at all

[satellites.™]

Originally posted by Kisuke

With her 4th octave belting

This is what im saying.

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

wasn't Xtina ahead of both Mariah & Whitney on that list?

Wait a minute.

11 Paul McCartney
10 James Brown
09 Stevie Wonder
08 Otis Redding
07 Bob Dylan
06 Marvin Gaye
05 John Lennon
04 Sam Cooke
03 Elvis Presley
02 Ray Charles
01 Aretha Franklin

Originally posted by JClarkSTAN

Aretha in her prime was a ****ing force. Her belts were ****ing powerful. She had incredible range and versatility. She's inspired all of our favs. I prefer Patti but I would never call Aretha overrated. She earned her title.

And Celine was on her Vegas tour for years. Which makes your original point invalid.

Im aware of Arethas influence, that should not be taken into account when judging solely on ability. And yes finally something we agree on, Queen Patti books all the girls from her time.

Originally posted by Ace Reject

It was, in terms of rank and position:

Aretha > Tina > Whitney > Dusty > Bjork > The Devil > Mariah > Patti Smith > Mary J. Blige.

Death at the Devil.

[Da beezness!]

Are we allowed to discuss how Alicia Key's "post baby weight" is more than 15 months old? Or do we have to only stick to her vocal flaws and overrated she is?

[Lipton]

Originally posted by Da beezness!

Atrocious.

She kills me when she actually thinks that she is engaging the crowd or serving anything.

[Playboy]

Originally posted by Da beezness!

Atrocious.

OMG @ those horrible ass runs kjfkfkjfsdks

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Da beezness!

Are we allowed to discuss how Alicia Key's "post baby weight" is more than 15 months old? Or do we have to only stick to her vocal flaws and overrated she is?

I am died. I AM DIED.

[Lipton]

Originally posted by satellites™

Queen Patti books all the girls from her time.

Patty is always last. That's why no one cares about her. What a mess.

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Lipton

The Icelandic One has a superb vocal though.

Originally posted by Ace Reject

But Bjork DOES **** on most of the girls. Like, I'm not being funny - who has her power and range? At least a 2.5 octave range. Probably three plus.

Her voice tho... something about her tone...
But I won't drag her. I hope Owl isn't lurking.

[Playboy]

Patti could NEVER book Aretha........ Aretha's vocal talents are VAST!!!!

jdgjsgjnsgnfj OMG what kind of EBT ignorance?

[Albany Guest]

Flo might not have a whistle register, but her belts are glorious:

[satellites.™]

Originally posted by JClarkSTAN

I don't understand why you being in a loud ass concert full of screaming fans proves that she sings 100% live.

Compare all her performances of LOT live minus the VMA's and they all sound identical. I just can't with you girls.

Yes for you using the TWO performances of LOT live while she was PREGNANT to try and prove a false point.

Sistren, don't act like Bey doesn't get >< close to peoples faces on tour, I mean hello....

Oh and PLESE do not forget.

[Lipton]

Originally posted by Playboy

Patti could NEVER book Aretha:

Or Gladys, or Yvette, or Betty, or Stephanie, or Anita, or anyone else that matters.

Patti is never credited with anything. It amazes me when people think she is, OR EVER WAS, a better vocalist than any of her peers.

I mean the only thing she did was shut down Diana a few times, but who can't do that.

[satellites.™]

Originally posted by Playboy

YALL WANNA PLAY?!?!?!?! jdfjgjnmsgnmmn,d

This is a lowblow, it should be against the rules.

The afro.

The gold outfit.

The song.

[Playboy]

jnklgsnlkfglkdkgmkdmd THESE VOCALS ARE A FOOL!!!!!!!!!