[2AM]

Originally posted by zzmyth

2005:

Pon De Replay - #2
If Its Loveing That You Want - #9

2006:

SOS - #1
Unfaithful - #2
We Ride - #34
Break It Off - #6

2007:

Umbrella - #2
Shut Up & Drive - #11
Hate That I Love You - #3
Dont Stop The Music - #2

2008:

If I Never See Your Face Again - #30
Take A Bow - #1
Disturbia - #1
Live Your Life - #1
Rehab - #17

2009:

Run This Town - #9
Russian Roulette - #21
Hard - #9

2010:

Rude Boy - #1
Rockstar101 - #51
Love The Way You Lie - #1
Only Girl - #1
What's My Name? - #4

2011:

Who's That Chick? - #33
All Of The Lights - #38
S&M - #1
California King Bed - #18
Cheers - #11
Fly - #16
We Found Love - #1

2012:

You Da One - #19
Talk That Talk - #52
Princess Of China - #35
Take Care - #32

Katy's run is far more impressive and more consistent.
2008
#2 I Kissed a Girl
#1 Hot N Cold

2009
#17 Thinking of You
#1 Waking Up In Vegas

2010
#1 California Gurls
#1 Teenage Dream
#1 Firework

2011
#1 E.T.
#1 Last Friday Night

2012
#1 The One That Got Away

[Hausofmonster]

Originally posted by Kats

Since she debuted years ago her airplay has been consistent.

And you think 5 years (approx.) of airplay will due?

She only started to be a massive radio artist with TD.

[2AM]

Originally posted by Hausofmonster

And you think 5 years (approx.) of airplay will due?

She only started to be a massive radio artist with TD.

Oh really?

2008
#2 I Kissed a Girl
#1 Hot N Cold

2009
#17 Thinking of You
#1 Waking Up In Vegas
I think basing it off five years and ten singles, not to mention the consistency will do yes, especially when comparing her to competition.

[Grim]

Absolutely not. She had a great era. End of story.

[TPG14]

With this pop #1, no one can deny that TOTGA was a hit.

[PurrKaty]

Originally posted by Squall

I can't at all those haters who voted "no" despite the facts show that she is the Queen.

haters will stay pressed, but the charts don't lie

[PurrKaty]

Originally posted by TPG14

With this pop #1, no one can deny that TOTGA was a hit.

#1 Pop Chart
#1 Dance Club Chart
#1 Adult Contemporary
#2 Digital Songs Chart
#3 Airplay Chart
#3 Hot 100

three #1, one #2, and two #3 peaks, no way people can say this wasn't a hit unless they are pressed

[Hausofmonster]

Originally posted by Kats

Oh really?

2008
#2 I Kissed a Girl
#1 Hot N Cold

2009
#17 Thinking of You
#1 Waking Up In Vegas
I think basing it off five years and ten singles, not to mention the consistency will do yes, especially when comparing her to competition.

Where does that leave Rihanna then?

[Cz!]

Definitely.

[nader]

of curse

[marky cat]

OFC she is!

[Yooorsh]

Obviously yes!

[umich]

Originally posted by PurrKaty

#1 Pop Chart
#1 Dance Club Chart
#1 Hot Adult Contemporary
#2 Digital Songs Chart
#3 Airplay Chart
#3 Hot 100

three #1, one #2, and two #3 peaks, no way people can say this wasn't a hit unless they are pressed

fixed, boo, for accurary

[slimmaz]

Originally posted by H-I-M

Perry has 6 #1 from THE SAME album on POP

....Point? Can she continue the success TD has had on pop radio with her upcoming releases, only time will tell. I don't think it's fair to say she's the Queen of Pop radio, I think a Queen would be one who can consistently have success in the format that is CHR

[lancelovesgaga]

Sure

[KoreanDream]

Originally posted by satellites™

One era can't make someone a queen, it takes constant success over the years.

!!!

That title isn't hers yet.

[heartbeats]

time 2 bow and cry every1 r queen katy made it through the end of the tunnel!!!!!

im w8ing for some meltdowns omfg ie: tl;dr how katy's untalented and doesn't deserve success.

[LP54]

Originally posted by Kats

Katy's run is far more impressive and more consistent.
2008
#2 I Kissed a Girl
#1 Hot N Cold

2009
#17 Thinking of You
#1 Waking Up In Vegas

2010
#1 California Gurls
#1 Teenage Dream
#1 Firework

2011
#1 E.T.
#1 Last Friday Night

2012
#1 The One That Got Away

[TiKToK]

Hmm..

Queen of Payola maybe...

[ethan]

Originally posted by zzmyth

2005:

Pon De Replay - #2
If Its Loveing That You Want - #9

2006:

SOS - #1
Unfaithful - #2
We Ride - #34
Break It Off - #6

2007:

Umbrella - #2
Shut Up & Drive - #11
Hate That I Love You - #3
Dont Stop The Music - #2

2008:

If I Never See Your Face Again - #30
Take A Bow - #1
Disturbia - #1
Live Your Life - #1
Rehab - #17

2009:

Run This Town - #9
Russian Roulette - #21
Hard - #9

2010:

Rude Boy - #1
Rockstar101 - #51
Love The Way You Lie - #1
Only Girl - #1
What's My Name? - #4

2011:

Who's That Chick? - #33
All Of The Lights - #38
S&M - #1
California King Bed - #18
Cheers - #11
Fly - #16
We Found Love - #1

2012:

You Da One - #19
Talk That Talk - #52
Princess Of China - #35
Take Care - #32

/sarcasm

In addition to the fact that over 1/5 of her #1s were songs she was featured on, her percentage of #1s are not as impressive as Katy's...

Overall:
80% of Katy's singles have hit #1.
26% of Rihanna's singles have hit #1.

90% of Katy's have gone top 2.
38% of Rihanna's have gone top 2.

From their first two albums/"eras":
80% of Katy's singles went to #1 [so far].
17% of Rihanna's singles went to #1.

Since 2008, when Katy released her first single:
80% of Katy's single hit the top spot.
33% of Rihanna's singles hit the top spot.

Katy has just slayed... in only 2 albums.

The fight between Katy and Rihanna is kind of silly though considering how good of friends they are... the Navy and KatyCats should really get along more.