Early Reviews
Reception
Quote:
Jason Lipshutz of Billboard commented that the video "features the pop star at her most gloriously provocative, with extended dance sequences, explosions, nudity, and a violent attack on a box of Honey Nut Cheerios."
|
Quote:
Gin Sepre of E! Online compared the video with the book Girl, Interrupted noting that "with equal parts autobiography and pure spectacle, it truly has something for everyone."
|
Quote:
Sepre also praised the fact that the video is "certainly not hurting for a lack of creativity" with the scenes being showed in a "slightly more straightforward, [and] less metaphorical way".
|
Quote:
Jocelyn Vena from MTV opined that "with references to everything from Fame and Black Swan to The Bell Jar, the video is a sweeping look into Gaga's psyche."
|
Quote:
Entertainment Weekly's Tanner Stransky described the video as "quite the trip to Total Crazyville, population: 1, Lady Gaga... Leave it to Lady Gaga to unspool a mini-movie video that’s half the length of a sitcom episode."
|
Quote:
Eleanor Gower from Daily Mail felt that the video was "no less spectacular than her past offerings."
|
Quote:
Gilly Ferguson of Daily Mirror noted that the video "still has the shock factor – she's naked for starters."
|
From wikipedia, so I don't know if all are 100% true, but still
Should this deserve a thread?
