I don't know about its general field nomination chances, but I'd laugh if "Judas" got a Pop nod over "You and I."
I don't know what it is about Judas but my opinion changes about that song every 5 minutes... I hate it but I love it at the same time, its "the demon I cling to". I do hope for the best at the Grammys, either song being nominated would be good for me. A nom is a nom. Judas isn't such a bad song, if it were a massive hit it would have been praised like crazy.