[2AM]

Originally posted by Chrïs.

All 3 on TFM's singles easily destroy those local hits and BR is bigger than any other Katy single.

LOL, BR is the only one that is superior to anything Katy did with the TD era. The other two singles fall beneath several TD singles.

[hausofvina]

Originally posted by KatyCat007

that's all?

Originally posted by TheGeoKing

Singles sales? Katy

Album sales? Gaga
Grammy Awards? Gaga
Critical acclaim? Gaga
Cultural impact? Gaga
Tours? Gaga


Bye.

[2AM]

Originally posted by hausofvina

that's all?

No, there is another one, and another one on the way. Then there is another in the Top 5 and two others in the Top 30, one being in the Top 15.

[AshleeSimpsonFan]

The Fame Monster

[KRL]

Originally posted by Kats

LOL, BR is the only one that is superior to anything Katy did with the TD era. The other two singles fall beneath several TD singles.

Alejandro was as huge as Bad romance in Europe

[2AM]

Originally posted by KRL

Alejandro was as huge as Bad romance in Europe

In Europe being the key phrase.

[Nicole]

It's hard to compare.

One is an EP that only had 3 singles. Outside the US it was attached to TF.

The other is an LP with 6 singles.

One is bold, innovative and fresh in terms of sound and image - pop music as it should be from a pop artist.

The other is bland, safe, empty calories fun.

Totally different animals.

[PopBoi]

The one that had impact and will be remembered in 5 years.


... TFM, since Katy stans probably think I'm talking about TD.

[PopBoi]

Reading some of these comments .... you know you're a singles artist when thats all people think counts

[!ola]

Originally posted by Ramcoro

I missed when TFM sold 5 million.

no, hun... It's obvious that The Fame Monster era was better at moving albums. Can Teenager Dream era ?

TFM was better at moving albums? It only sold 1.5 mill albums in the US. TD sold over 1.8 or 2 million. WW sales are that far apart either.

Gaga:
US only:Before the EP = 1.5m albums
After the EP = 5.0 m albums

[gordovant]

Katy has Firework and E.T , they are a huuuge hits , and let's not forget about the 5 #1 hits.
But TFM was a ****ing monster WW
I can't vote

[Drowned_World]

TFM!

Originally posted by Kats

No hun, if your weary eyes can't see the cultural impact of "Firework" and Katy's chart success, then I think it is you who needs to take a rest.

[Symphonic]

'The Fame Monster', without question. It's a more iconic era and did much better worldwide.

[Brooklyn]

TEENAGE DREAM is so much better than TFM

[Cas]

Rated R

[gordovant]

Originally posted by Brooklyn

TEENAGE DREAM is so much better than TFM

More succefull era

Not :

Wich one is better ?

....

[Ramcoro]

Originally posted by Chrïs.

All 3 on TFM's singles easily destroy those local hits and BR is bigger than any other Katy single.

LOL are you serious? you cherry picked those countries and you know it.


TD (album) went #1 in 9 different countries. Top 5 in 8 more countries. Top 10 in 6 more countires, and Top 20 in 5 more countries. That's wonderful! Esp. considering her last album didn't go number 1 anywhere, and top in two countries!

It got certified 3X Platinum in Australia, 2 X Platinum in 5 countries (including the US), and Platinum in 3 countries.

California Gurls went #1 in 11 different countries, including #1 on Canada's year end chart and top 5 in 5 other countries.

TD went #1 in 5 different countries.

Firework in 4 different countries.

ET in 6 different countries.

LFN in 5 different countries (wonderful for a 5th single and no promo)

TOTGA well it looks like it could go #1 on the Hot 100. If that happen it'll probably go #1 in Canada too. Plus, it's probably going #1 in Australia and NZ because mid-tempos and ballads usually do better there than they do in the US, plus it charted a lot better and a lot faster there than it did here.

Katy has the most #1s on the Canadian Hot 100, and the most from one album,

Katy is tied for the 8th artist with most #1s in New Zealand and she has the shortest career of everyone on that list.

The first four singles of TD were certified at least Gold in Germany. That hasn't happened since Backstreet Boys' Backstreet Boys in 1995-1997 . Making Katy the only one this century (so far).

Oh and TFM's singles only sold about 10 million. The first 3 TD singles sold 14 million.

I'm none with this thread.

[slobro]

Originally posted by PopBoi

The one that had impact and will be remembered in 5 years.


... TFM, since Katy stans probably think I'm talking about TD.

[Austin]

TD was by far more commercially successful by far in terms of singles etc, but Gaga thrashed Katy w/ touring, her songs have made cultural impact, her album was actually well received by critics (unlike TD) and to be quite honest, Bad Romance will be remember in 10 years, as will the Fame Monster - Teenage Dream is forgettable radio friendly pop music, and won't be remembered because it pushed no boundaries, and wasn't revolutionary. What it will be remembered for is it's 5 no.1's (possibly 6 if she squeezes that remix in there)

[Mystic Boy]

Those little Katy stans are the definition of DELUSIONAL!! i cant!!


TFM ***** on every ****ing aspect of TD and you know it, stop fooling yourselves kids